Sidney Sheldon is always one of my favorite authors, and The Stars Shine Down is another masterpiece by "the top-10 best-selling fiction writers of all time".
However, The Stars Shine Down didn't win my heart.
Lara Cameron is one of Sidney Sheldon's motif main girls, she shares many similarities with Kate (Master of the Game), Paige Taylor (Nothing Last Forever), Tracy (If Tomorrow Comes) or Jennifer Parker (Rage of Angels). Lara had a tough childhood when her mother and her male twin died during their birth and her Scottish father, who collected rents for boarding houses, didn't want her, as she admitted that "it was difficult for her to express her emotions. Her father had ridiculed her when she had tried".
Lara experienced kind of the same past with Tracy (If Tomorrow Comes) when she had to have sex by forced, but Tracy was raped, when Lara made a contract with Sean MacAllister by her virgin body. I think that is the big reason why Lara is petty, vindictive, savvy more than any Sidney Sheldon's main girls. Lara is smart, but she couldn't have what she wanted in the first place if her life didn't revolve around Charles Cohn, Howard Keller, Paul Martin. For me, reading Lara's story was like reading an amazing story of a beautiful villain.
First part, I thought Sidney would give Charles Cohn more land because the relationship between Lara and Cohn sounds quite similar to Paige Taylor and Dr. Benjamin's, or as least he should be someone who can save her in the end, bringing some warm stories like what happened in Nothing Last Forever, but it didn't happen. He just shined for one moment in her life, like a chess piece and nothing. I wanted to read more about him.
Howard Keller, Sidney gave Howard Keller a small story telling about his young life, he also had a tough life like Lara did. But Howard Keller didn't actually even have a happy moment because every guy who met Lara would be obsessed with her, and Keller did, too. He was loyal, working hard until he was losing his memories, and finally committed crimes because of Lara. Howard had always been Lara's advisor, telling her what to do but he was too loyal to stop her making foolish decision. It was always Lara ignored his advice, then something happened, and she would be "All right. Then do it" (page 185, she put more homeless people inside the building and kicked them out, not being sorry to them).
In my opinion, this ending for Howard Keller didn't sound like a twist, it was just so suddenly, so wasteful and Keller didn't sound like a mad guy who lost his mind to be fail in jealousy trap. I wonder if he was so mad with her change (page 103, "Don't ever change, Lara" She looked at him hard "I won't")
If Sidney wrote more about his feeling and his thoughts, we might find the answer. I think Howard Keller deserved more.
Paul Martin was my favorite character; he might deserve to be betrayed by Lara in the end, but if it was not because of her foolish and selfishness, maybe he was still "very much married" with his wife and did not cheat on her. Lara excused " she had never been in love with him and going to bed with him had been easy - the payment for all he had done for her". That was not true, going to bed with him was not the payment because Lara was obsessed with Paul, and herself too. She loved herself too much that couldn't deny the fact that a man refuses her, and she tried her best to gain Paul's attention. And when she had to face Paul as her biggest enemy, she thought he went mad at her because he became old. Everything was about herself and her "narcissistic personality disorder".
One more thing I didn't like is, Lara sounded like a good boss by "her employees were her family. She worried about them and was generous with them". But her action proved the opposite. She fired Marian for being nice with her husband, when she asked her to do it. She doesn't sound like a good boss to Kathy too when scared her at the same time. What she did to her tenants, employees etc., was absolutely unforgivable.
In the end, she still had 40 people celebrating her birthday, instead of 200 people as her expectation. I was moved at the part "I haven't lost everything after all. I'll spend the rest of my life making up to him (Philip)... I don't need anything else"
And then, she failed me again by stopping the car and explained to Philip her plan of buying a shopping mall. In my imagination, if the story continues, Philip will not be a teacher and will be the second Howard Keller and work for her. Who knows.