Disavowing Constantine: Mission, Chruch and the Social Order in the Theologies of John Howard Yoder and Jurgen Moltmann

by Nigel G. Wright

This book is a timely restatement of a radical theology of church and state in the Anabaptist and Baptist tradition. Dr Wright constructs his argument in dialogue and debate with Yoder and Moltmann, major contributors to a free church perspective.

Genres: Church History

266 pages, Paperback

First published May 1, 2000

Reviews

[Andrew · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is a sober-minded examination of Christian political theology in dialogue (trialogue?) with John Howard Yoder and Jurgen Moltmann. Yoder represents Anabaptism while Moltmann represents a Lutheran/Reformed perspective, though obviously not without independent nuance for both theologians. Wright tackles a difficult, controversial subject with poise and reserve, as well as penetrating critical insight. Wright's position essentially criticizes Yoder and Moltmann, while taking from the best of what they offer in order to define an English Baptist point of view that emphasizes the necessity of a free church ecclesiology which leaves church and state free to be themselves in their respective proper roles.

Wright takes an ambiguous position (and admits its ambiguity as well as being entirely comfortable with it) concerning the theological tension inherent in viewing human structures as created, fallen, and redeemable. Criticizing Yoder's pessimism concerning fallen-ness and Moltmann's optimism regarding creation and redemption, Wright nevertheless likewise leans toward fallen-ness. This would, I think, be characteristic of a Reformed view and it would be interesting to hear a Wesleyan/Methodist voice - perhaps examining Hauerwas (though I think Hauerwas too heavily influenced by Yoder and Anabaptism) and/or Wesley himself.