Terry Gross’s All I Did Was Ask: Conversations with Writers, Actors, Musicians, and Artists is not as interesting as I thought it would be. In the Introduction, she discusses why none of the interviews she included in the book are political; she didn’t think the topics covered would still be current. The problem, of course, is that some of the artists are not current either. Maybe when the book was published in 2004, Grandmaster Flash and Divine were still hot topics but they certainly aren’t more than a decade later. That’s not Terry’s fault. But I think that some of her more dynamic interviews (Bill O’Reilly) could have still been interesting reading, even if she considered them “topical.” I also don’t think politics is topical at all; we’re still fighting over basic the same thing: one group of people wanting to disenfranchise and rule over another group. Dress it up all you like, but the wealthy are fighting to not only stay wealthy, but to become emperors, and they’ll do anything they need to to win.
I’ve been listening to Fresh Air for a decade or so. I’m not a loyal fan; I catch the interviews mostly when I’m in my car. I’m usually more interested in the interviewee, not Terry’s interviewing style. I guess if I had to interview people for a living I’d appreciate her skill more, but if I’m listening to an interview that bores me, I’m bored no matter how well she asks the questions. The problem I have with the transcripts of these interviews is that she’s edited them for content and length. So when you’re reading, the conversation doesn’t naturally flow from one idea to another and I’m guessing that’s where she took out a chunk of dialogue. I also found a number of the interviews boring because they did seem to be dated to me and I wasn’t interested. I don’t like jazz, so automatically any conversation about the technicalities of jazz lulls me to sleep.
The most dramatic interview is of course the famous Gene Simmons interview. Gene Simmons is, of course, the lead singer of the craptastic rock band Kiss. Listening to their music is like eating really shitty food because you’re hungry and it’s right there and it looks sorta good but later you want to throw up. That’s Kiss. Gene Simmons is a narcissist. Not on the scale of Trump, but comparisons can be made. What’s interesting about this interview (and Terry does say this to him) is that you don’t know if his sexism and rudeness are genuine or if he’s playing a role. I suspect with Gene Simmons that the two are very close. He’s also extremely defensive about being perceived as an uneducated idiot and sneers at NPR and Terry. Which of course just displays his own weaknesses. When Terry asks him if all he cares about is money (vs. creating music for artistic purposes, ha ha ha ha ha) he says that in order to survive we all need air and money. Then he says that Terry, as a woman, has the option of selling her body for money, an option he doesn’t have. Now, we can have a discussion that we all use our bodies to make money (writers’ hands type the words that create books that sell, Terry’s voice conducts interviews, etc.) but he says this just after describing all the makeup he wears, the weird costumes he puts on, the high-heeled boots he wears. Why does he do all this? Because his physical presence—his body—is a large part of the band’s appeal. Fans talking about the band don’t rhapsodize over the band harmonies—they discuss the costumes and the extraordinarily long tongue of Gene Simmons. He, much more than Terry, sells his body to make money. The correlations between Gene Simmons the narcissist and Donald Trump the narcissist are interesting: they are both extremely defensive, care about material goods and their image to the exclusion of everything else and claim not to drink, smoke or use drugs of any kind. That actually makes sense to me. If you’re a narcissist with psychopathic tendencies, why would you need to drink/use drugs? You have a limited inner life and don’t have the worries and anxieties of normal people. People imbibe in mind or mood-altering drugs to relax, to take their mind of their troubles, etc. I don’t think Gene Simmons or Donald Trump have the same doubts, anxieties, guilt, worries, concerns that normal people have so why would they need to drink? Perhaps Gene should drink so he could maybe find a sense of humor because he comes across as douche bag spouting crudeness just for the sake of being crude. He’s not witty and he’s not intriguing. He’s shallow and asinine (like his music).
I enjoyed some of the interviews much more than others but overall would recommend listening to them rather than reading. Something is lost in the translation.