This book continues the Thula Thula story from ‘The Elephant Whisperer’ and ‘An Elephant in my Kitchen’. It has new experiences over the following period from the last book, while referring briefly to past events. This book is as beautiful as the previous two books referred above.
Lawrence Anthony brought a herd of elephants regarded as problematic and established Thula Thula (Thula means quiet in Zulu). He died in 2012, and his ashes were scattered near the Mkhulu dam he built. Francoise Malby Anthony took over, continuing & expanding on his work & legacy. Francoise knew very little of the ways of the wild, and recounts how at one time she got off with a friend near some rhinos, which is an especially dangerous thing to do. She picked up the skills by observing and helping Lawrence. The Thula Thula website and news articles describe how the elephants Lawrence saved came over to pay their respects at their house for 3 years in a row on the same date. Elephants are such remarkable creatures – sensitive, intelligent, social and intuitive!
The narration picks up on the period just before the pandemic. The matriarch is now Frankie, who has taken over from the aging Nana. The past books describe Nana’s maturity in leading the herd. While the elephants provide Thula Thula its identity, this book is also about the other animals who have made Thula Thula their home – rhinos (Thabo, Ntombi, Sissi and later additions Mona & Rambo), cheetah (Savannah), hippos (Jo), leopards, giraffes, mercats, hyenas, crocodiles, and others. Each of the animals have their personalities, much like us humans, and the rangers know it well over time. ‘An Elephant in my Kitchen’ covers the dangers due to poaching in detail, including the death of the rhinos in the orphanage as part of Thula Thula. Poaching casts its shadow in this book as well though an attack was foiled. As a result, rhinos at Thula Thula are dehorned.
Francoise was at an ayurvedic resort in Kerala in 2020 when she reads first about the Coronavirus. She mentions that she visits India quite frequently and loves the culture & grand temples among other things. She observes how the space for elephants is shrinking and Indian Elephants are also struggling in less-than-ideal conditions. That is true and I just wish we create space for them and limit elephants in captivity; they deserve to be free as much as we do. The pandemic strikes and strains Thula Thula’s finances. In desperation, they launch an adoption scheme where contributors are sent photos and other material. This proves to be a success. Later, as restrictions were lifted, local South African guests start coming back first. There are further problems though with the space available, a plan to mine for coal in the area, local unrest and others.
The books revisits and describes new experiences for many of the animals introduced in previous books; such as with rhinos – Thabo & Ntombi, matriarch Frankie (Lawrence close escape once), Numzane elephant who got aggressive and had to be put down. There are heart-warming experiences with the animals sprinkled through the book – and they make you smile as well as cry – encounter of Shaka, the elephant & Thabo, the rhino; death of young rhino Lisa; death of Frankie and funeral march the other elephants conduct in homage; Marula taking over as the new matriarch; introduction of a cheetah (Savannah), movement of a few male giraffes; contraception for the elephants to limit expansion due to space restrictions; the contest between Thabo and new rhino Rambo on who will court the ladies. There is a touch of speciesism in the book, as some categories of animals have no names and descriptions of individuality (some are simply food for cheetahs). There are complex issues referred such as the impact elephants have on ecosystems – Kruger culled many elephants many years back in a controversial move. While opinions are still divided, creating good pathways, and living spaces is regarded as more critical. Elephants have the remarkable ability to covert bushes to grasslands, and can disperse seeds even as far as 65 kms away.
Francoise mentions that there is never a dull moment with the elephants at Thula Thula. They are remarkable animals and can even console and support others, at times even humans. Animals can share our feelings and are good companions when we are troubled and stressed. There is no dull moment in this lovely & fascinating book as well. It is a tribute to the wonderful place Lawrence Anthony set up & nurtured, Francoise’s strength in continuing his legacy and the amazing life of animals, especially the elephants.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Roshina Ratnam and it was excellent, bringing alive the environment of Thula Thula.
A much-recommended book!