Day 7 of 365, my ninth read of the year, and my fourth 1-star read of 2024.
The only good thing about this was the angst—the poverty, the abuse Roman endured from his brother, the found family aspect, Roman’s mutism, food insecurity, sex work for money—I really liked it. This is my second read from this author, and unfortunately, it’s another miss. Despite that, I do believe this book has potential, but the BDSM representation, lack of character development, lack of relationship development, and how I was not the biggest fan of Scout made the reading experience unenjoyable and not emotional.
I’ll give it to this author for his ability to write angst. It’s well written and heart felt, and I could feel myself rooting for the characters as the story started. We find out about their terrible living conditions, making it out one way or another. While they’re both living in different situations and places, Roman and Scout aren’t entirely different in how they only have each other for reliable. Scout has his two best friends, Dallas and Beck, which makes it more worthwhile; Roman, on the other hand, doesn’t have anyone. The author’s ability to tug at your heartstrings shines here, not just with the topic of poverty but in how both men are broken and shattered in their own ways. Roman, especially, was easier to connect to, although I did feel a little conflicted about him in the end. His inner angst comes from his abusive relationship with his toxic brother. He’s never been properly cared for, not after his grandma was taken away from him, so finding trust and care for and from others isn’t easy for him. I loved how the author wrote his character, admittedly. His struggles were heartfelt. The author never cures or forgets his mutism, which I would say is selective mutism because Roman isn’t able to speak during certain times of anxiety. He slowly works up the courage when he needs to, including for his brother and Scout.
On the other hand, my issues with the book have to do with everything else, from Scout, to the poor BDSM representation, to the lack of relationship development.
I won’t comment much on the puppy play because it’s not my thing, but I will say it didn’t affect my enjoyment. It helped to know beforehand that this has puppy play and that Roman is referred to as ‘pup’ and ‘puppy’ by Roman, which isn’t my thing at all but in this world we don’t kink shame. I could see how the puppy role was something Roman felt connected to, given his need to obey, follow commands, and even bite. I personally think the author did a good job with this, especially as I am someone who isn’t super familiar with role playing and the like. Yeah, I wouldn’t look for a book with puppy play specifically but I’ll admit that I didn’t hate it. It felt fitting for Roman’s character, it just didn’t help the relationship much.
In my opinion, Roman deserved better. It was difficult to root for the two, especially for their BDSM relationship, when it felt like Roman didn’t even know what he was agreeing to, and Scout felt like he didn’t know what he was doing. There’s nothing wrong with him being a baby Dom. He’s inexperienced, so course it’s gonna take practice and experience, but that’s exactly my issue. Roman needed more caretaking and aftercare, someone more confident and sure. This has nothing to do with Scout also living in poverty and doing sex-work as a means for finances, but his Dominant role felt shallow, with no sufficient depth. He claimed to be experienced and someone who would teach Roman, yet he’d forget some of the most important, basic parts, like aftercare. And why did he forget aftercare after their first scene? Because he was so focused on his porn and editing the footage. I also thought he came off as unreliable for the entire book. His personality came off as ignorant, a little standoffish, and not sure enough on what he was doing. This wouldn’t have been an issue, considering he’s learning and doesn’t have the best gear and equipment, but Roman’s position didn’t help. The way I saw it, Roman agreed to his submission not because he felt that way, but because he thought there wasn’t anything better. There are some instances where Roman holds himself back for Scout’s sake, like not using a safeword.
A wave of dizziness washes over me and my stomach flips as I squeeze my eyes shut tighter, telling myself that I could probably snap the belt if I really had to. Trav has never restrained me, so I didn’t think I’d feel scared. But all I can imagine is that this is how it would feel if he tried, if I was helpless to escape and he could hurt me and hurt me and hurt me. Flexing my fingers, I tell myself not to safeword. We just fucking started, and I can tell Scout’s happy with me. I don’t want it to stop.
1) He has to tell himself to not safe word.
2) He’s doing it for Scout’s sake despite not being the most comfortable in that moment.
3) He’s scared of taking away Scout’s happiness because he’s doing so good?
Just. No.
Scout’s experience on BDSM and being a Dom mostly came from his sex work. We don’t learn any backstory on why he is a Dom and/or wants a sub. We don’t know anything about previous experiences. We just know that once he locks eyes with Roman, he wants him, and he always gets what he wants. Excuse me as I roll my eyes.
Once again, his lack of experience isn’t the issue; it’s how Roman’s position didn’t help him, so to me, it felt like Roman was being used. Scout wasn’t patient, understanding, and kind all the time. Instead of coming off as authoritative, he came off as unreliable. Where was the kindness? The care? The patience? The trust? Roman needed someone else and more proper knowledge on what he was doing. Scout didn’t really give him that. Roman wasn’t taught right, he was simply doing as he was told. His character was broken too much that a submissive role didn’t feel appropriate enough for everything he needed.
I’m no expert on BDSM. I haven’t read that many kinky romances in general, let alone books with strict roles. While the D/s and Sir/boy dynamics are clear here, with what I have read and learned, this wasn’t the best. It also felt like Scout was using him for his porn, and if it weren’t for that, there wouldn’t be any other way these two would be together. They didn’t give me ‘happy ever after’ vibes. It’s as if Scout was more interested in his porn and footage than actually coming to properly care about Roman.
Also, Scout’s character was hardly explored. We learn more about Roman than Scout. All we know is that he stuffed himself with Oreo cookies and noodles when he could, he jerked off to horny men for payment, and came out with his own ways to make equipment for his porn. We also know his siblings ran off, his mom OD’d, and his dad was killed. Truly angst stuff, yet they offered nothing to his character. He was just someone who did sex work and was a baby Dom in the making. His relationship with Roman is mostly through the BDSM roles, especially for the first 50% of the book. We don’t really see them going out and getting to know each other unless it’s with Beck and Dallas, which is fine but I would’ve preferred to see more of them together and alone. This also prevented me from enjoying the book and rooting for the romance because there wasn’t enough connection.
This story had potential, but I started losing interest 40% in when Scout’s dominant role felt too underdeveloped. I really can’t use the excuse of them learning and them being inexperienced as a way to validate what they did. This wouldn’t be an issue if Roman came off as someone with more security and confidence. Instead, I saw him as someone unsure, scared, and willing to do things asked for him because he thought that was what he was good for. He was too broken, damaged, and traumatized. He couldn’t stand up to himself for himself. The only times he did were with Scout, and it was probably because he knew Scout wouldn’t hurt him. It makes sense, yet that’s where the character developing was lacking.
Then the ending comes along and everything is easy. It felt as if the author wrote this with that intention to excuse Roman’s lack of character development. No structure and build up is made throughout the book because the ending wouldn’t have required it. It’s very lazy writing to me.
Overall, not a fan in the slightest.