It was a fun read. I saw the movie a long time ago and apparently remembered nothing. So I watched the movie again after reading the book, and I can see why I remembered nothing.
The movie glosses over the importance of the protoganist’s relationship with his fat girlfriend, Cassidy. The movie did do one thing right: omit the the part where Aimee gets stupid drunk and does shit completely out of character at a party. As I read that part of the book, I felt the author was really letting me down.
It took a little while to get used to the writing style of the book, and to even relate to or like Sutter, but I totally bought in halfway through. All the third-person “Sutter-man” stuff was cringeworthy though. But I did get super into the way the author captured Sutter’s voice with the constant “I’m like” and “she’s like” before quoting people. It was unique (to me at least). I totally imagined a drunk Sutter just retelling this story at a party.
The ending of the book at first left me questioning if it ruined my experience, but the more I thought about it, it was a perfectly tragic way to leave things. Also, much better than the movie ending, which was sort of a cop out, one-toe-in-the-water type of finish.