Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Secret Self: Short Stories by Women: v. 2

Rate this book

380 pages, Paperback

First published July 18, 1991

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Women

15 books1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (31%)
4 stars
10 (45%)
3 stars
3 (13%)
2 stars
2 (9%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
Profile Image for Shane.
170 reviews25 followers
October 17, 2014
It’s always hard to rate an anthology (leaving aside the fact that to assign any number, let alone just from 1–5, is reductive). The thing is, quite a few of these stories deserve more than 4. So, though I didn’t love all of them, this book gets 5 from me: for uniqueness, historical significance, and its wide range of takes on the theme.

In her introduction, editor Hermione Lee articulates this uniting, though not narrowly defined, theme: ‘the disclosure of a private, alternative imaginative vision in some ways alien to the “normal” socialized world but […] made recognisable and authentic.’ Lee denies ‘that a literal-minded search for a consistent woman’s language or subject will be rewarded in this selection of stories. But there is, possibly, an intensification of the conflict between the aberrant and the socialized…’

True, and I got more from each story by bearing that in mind as I read. Perhaps best of all, this anthology gave me a rare opportunity to sample a range of brilliant and influential writers, several of them women one now seldom hears of, if at all, and a few I’d never heard of – like Anna Kavan, whose chilling, original story got me searching for more of her work.

One of the first things to strike me – and I read out of order, not chronologically – was the vivid contrast in styles. Too often, in both short and long contemporary fiction, the voice, ideas, and/or technique feel derivative. Some of the stories gathered here by Lee were conceived before a host of imitators turned their tropes and styles into clichés.

Hard to beat was ‘Everything that Rises Must Converge’, Flannery O’Connor’s devastating mother–son tale told in third person through the eyes of a self-righteous male. Another standout, which couldn’t be more different, is Antonia White’s haunting, dreamlike account of madness, clearly written from experience, ‘The House of Clouds’. Its opening line: ‘The night before, Helen had tried to drown herself.’ And the closing line: ‘She had become an Inmate.’ Also, Fay Weldon’s savage satire of housewifely oppression, though 30+ years old now, remains disturbingly recognisable, in essence if not in all details.

How do these 33 stories, nearly all written and published last century – except for Kate Chopin’s ‘The Storm’ (1899), the only one I’d read before – compare with those being written by women and published today? They’re better in some cases. But maybe that’s because most of them have stood the test of time. Even seasoned editors lack perspective re current fiction. Amid the hype, they might mistake novelty for quality. So, one of the newest stories in The Secret Self/2, and by far the longest at 39 pages, is also the biggest disappointment. ‘Third Time Lucky’ by Rachel Ingalls lacks not just economy, but the distinctive style and compelling voice of many of Lee’s other choices – harder to take since the concept feels dated: woman finds fulfilment through motherhood after three tragic marriages, with a backdrop of Ancient Egyptian myth and a theme of reincarnation. Elizabeth Bowen’s ‘ghost story’ seems fresher, and remains affecting, 70 years after its initial publication.
Profile Image for Lucie.
88 reviews9 followers
December 28, 2008
An excellently edited selection of short stories from the never disappointing hands of Hermione Lee. A vibrant, thought-provoking & resonating collection.
562 reviews
May 24, 2014
"One tries to go deep -- to speak the secret self we all have…" Katherine Mansfield in a letter of 1921 about the writing of "At the Bay." (Introduction)

Married people always strike me as treating each other a bit like bonsai trees. They nip and clip an train each other into odd, accommodating shapes, then sometimes complain about the result. Or one partner can go to endless lengths of patience with the other and then be obdurate about some trifling thing. (p. 193, "Diego," Julia O'Faolain)

… in Assumption, he had k issued her and kissed and kissed her; until his senses could well nigh fail, and to save her he would resort to a desperate flight. If she was not an immaculate dove in those days, she was still inviolate; a passionate creature whose very defenselessness had made her defense, against which his honor forbade him to prevail. (p. 3-4)

She was a revelation in that dim, mysterious chamber; as white as the couch she lay upon. Her firm, elastic flesh that was knowing for the first time its birthright, was like a creamy lily that the sun invites to contribute its breath and perfume to the undying life of the world.
The generous abundance of her passion, without guile or trickery, was like a white flame which penetrated and found response in depths of his own sensuous nature that had never yet been reached. (p. 4)

And the first free breath since her marriage seemed to restore the pleasant liberty of her maiden days. Devoted as she was to her husband, their intimate conjugal life was something which she was more than willing to forego for a while. (p. 5-6, "The Storm," Kate Chopin)

"All my life I heard, Educated people don't do this, educated people don't do that. And now I'm here, and you're all educated people, and you're nothing but pigs. You're educated and you drink and do every thing wrong and you know what you're doing, and that makes you worse than pigs. My family worked to make me an educated person, but they didn't know you." (p. 144)

"I told you about the ice wagon," Agnes said. "I don't remember everything, so you're wrong about remembering. But I remember telling you that. That was the best. It's the best you can hope to have. In a big family, if you want to be alone, you have to get up before the rest of them. You get up early in the morning in the summer and it's you, you, once in your life alone in the universe. Yo think you know everything that can happen …. Nothing is ever like that again." (p. 144)

He was afraid for himself. The story was still unfinished. It had to come to a climax, something threatening to him. But there was no climax. They talked that day and afterward nothing else was said …. Agnes and Peter were too tired to speak after that morning. They were like a married couple in danger, taking care. (p. 145)

When, on Sunday mornings, Sheilah and Peter talk about those times, they take on the glamor of something still to come. It is then he remembers Agnes Brusen. He never says her name. Sheilah wouldn't remember Agnes. Agnes is the only secret Peter has kept from his wife, the only puzzle he pieces together without her help. (p. 145, "The Ice Wagon Going down the Street," Mavis Gallant)

Behind the newspaper, Julian was withdrawing into the inner compartment of his mind where he spent most of his time. This was a kind of mental bubble in which he established himself when he could not bear to be a part of what was going on around him. From it he could see out and judge but in it he was safe from an kind of penetration from without. It was the only place where he felt free of the general idiocy of his fellows. His mother had never entered it but from it he could see her with absolute clarity.
The old lady was never clever enough and he thought that if she had started from any of the right premises, more might be expected of her. She lived according to the laws of her own fantasy wold, outside of which he had never seen her set foot. The law of it was to sacrifice herself to him after she had first created the necessity to do so by making a mess of things. (p. 152-153, "Everything that Rises Must Converge," Flannery O'Connor)

He seldom spoke a harsh word, but Martha, after the fashion of wives, could detect his mood from what he did not say rather than what he did. (p. 216, "Weekend," Fay Weldon)

She'd never treated anyone so badly. She was ashamed of herself, but she couldn't quit. She realized that although she couldn't accept his love, she wanted him to keep on caring. Her resistance to him was like a lack of faith, an atheistic impulse; if there were suddenly nothing against which to fight, she might be completely lost….
She felt tears of stubbornness and remorse rising in her eyes. Her throat ached. But she was also proud at the way he was standing up to her. If he could hold out like that, he might win her over and exorcize the curse. (p. 259)
He stared at her so fiercely that he looked almost frightening, but also exciting. (p. 262)
The child was born: a boy. She couldn't sleep. She couldn't concentrate on anything else. She forgot the pain and regret she had felt about not being able to love her husband. The business of being a mother was harder than anyone had led her to believe. It was exhausting to the limit of her patience, and at times so far beyond that she didn't think she was going to get through it….
She confessed to her mother-in-law that she thought she hadn't loved Don enough -- not as much as he'd deserved.
Her mother-in-law said, "That's the way people always feel. But I know you loved him. Anyone can see what a good mother you are."
She didn't think she was such a good mother. She thought she was slapdash and nervous, constantly fussing. The only thing she was sure of was that she loved her son. (p. 269, "Third Time Lucky," Rachel Ingalls)

Yet when they look at each other, almost furtively under my gaze, I recognize the look. The look says: "These moments with strangers are nothing. Into our private moments together -- only there --is crammed all that we ask of life." (p. 278, "My Wife Is a White Russian," Rose Tremain)

"Svayamvara"
[princess good at whistling wins whistling competitions against her suitors]
"Never mind, father. Now let me set a test and perhaps some good will come of it." Then she turned to the suitors, "Do you acknowledge that you were beaten fairly?" "No," they all roared, all except one, "we think it was magic or some sort of trick." But one said, "Yes." "Yes," he said, "I was beaten fairly." The princess smiled and turning to her father she pointed to this man. "If he will have me," she said, "I will marry him." (p. 282, "THree Feminist Fables," Suniti Namjoshi)

Had she told him? She had talked a great deal in Albuquerque…. In the great wave of female saying, who could discern a trickle here, a rivulet there? If only semaphores could be flung up to draw attention to some telling detail! (p. 302, "The Passion of Marco Z----" Anne Leaton)
Profile Image for Amanda.
940 reviews
March 7, 2023
Man of these are great but Alice Munro is truly the best of the best at short stories.

Also, I found this book under my rental car in a parking lot. What a great find!
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews