What do you think?
Rate this book
In Her Own Right: A Novel of Lady Mary Tudor
Born into a world of privilege and power, Mary Tudor expected to live the life of every other European Princess during the Renaissance.
She knew it was her duty to marry well, and provide sons and heirs to her future husband, while remaining in the political shadows of a world dominated by ruthless men.
Her father's desperate need for a male heir and his willingness to send everybody who got in his way to their deaths, meant that Mary had very little hope of obtaining the English Crown.
But a series of traumatic events nobody could see coming would propel Mary on a life-long journey to claim what so many believe to be rightfully The Throne of England.
She knew it was her duty to marry well, and provide sons and heirs to her future husband, while remaining in the political shadows of a world dominated by ruthless men.
Her father's desperate need for a male heir and his willingness to send everybody who got in his way to their deaths, meant that Mary had very little hope of obtaining the English Crown.
But a series of traumatic events nobody could see coming would propel Mary on a life-long journey to claim what so many believe to be rightfully The Throne of England.
252 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 20, 2023
19 people are currently reading
145 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews
September 13, 2023
I didn't realize until reading this novel that, while I've read lots of Tudor historical fiction, I've never read something written from Mary Tudor's perspective. This very well-researched novel made me reconsider my views on Mary as a queen and especially as a young woman. It's very simply written (occasionally to its detriment) and definitely a quick read.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
August 23, 2023
Warning: The following review may be considered to contain spoilers if you have little to no familiarity with Mary I and Tudor history.
A lot of the historical fiction I read is set in Tudor England; it’s one of my favorite time periods to read about. I couldn’t even tell you how many books I’ve read in this genre. Most of them have to do with Henry VIII and his six wives or his second daughter, Elizabeth I. Few of the ones I come across deal with Henry’s firstborn, Mary I, and I don’t know why as she’s a fascinating person. Often written off as “Bloody Mary” (even though she sent far fewer people to their death than her father), she was a devout Catholic who tried to bring the practice back to the forefront of English life during her reign. The daughter of Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon, Mary was the only one of her parents’ children to survive to adulthood. This was quite the problem for Henry as he needed a son to carry on the family line and inherit the throne – he was completely against the idea of a woman doing so.
"In Her Own Right: A Novel of Lady Mary Tudor" tells Mary’s story from the time she was two years old until the day she is crowned Queen of England. At two years of age, she is betrothed to the Dauphin of France and already acts like a little queen. This marriage contract falls through three years later however, and she is eventually betrothed again at the age of six to her 22-year-old cousin, Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor. This engagement was also broken off (by Charles) and yet a third marriage treaty was proposed by Cardinal Wolsey to either Francis I of France or his second son, Henri, Duke of Orleans. Just like the two previous marriage contracts, this one falls through as well.
Mary loses her status as princess once her father decides that his marriage to Catherine should be annulled, stating that their marriage was a sin, quoting bible passages as his proof since Catherine was the widow of his brother, Arthur. After much legal debate, the marriage between Henry and Catherine is considered invalid and mother and daughter are separated as Henry essentially banishes Catherine from court. Mary is now called “Lady Mary” as her father pursues a new marriage with Anne Boelyn, resulting in the birth of the future Elizabeth I. Mary adamantly refuses to acknowledge her stepmother as queen, emphatically stating that her mother, Catherine, is the true queen of England, that her parents’ marriage was valid, and therefore she is still a princess of the realm. Henry is not happy with his daughter’s stance and their once close relationship becomes strained.
This battle of wills between father and daughter is a constant theme through the novel and their relationship continues to change as successive wives march down the aisle with Henry VIII. In fact, one of the stronger themes of the novel seems to be Mary’s relationships with others around her and how that affects her status both personally and royally. Once Henry finally passes away, Mary’s position in the line of succession again comes into question as her younger brother, Edward VI, a strict Protestant, takes the crown. With her being a Catholic, Edward doesn’t want his sister taking the throne in the event of his death and Mary must again fight for her position once he does pass. Cue the entrance of the “nine days queen,” Jane Grey and her tragic story (but we’ll have to save that for another day).
This novel does take large jumps forward in the historical timeline to be able to cover most of her life in such a short book (only 231 pages) which can be a little jarring if you have knowledge of Tudor history and know what to expect next. It’s a good general overview for a newbie to the subject matter but for someone who is a little more experienced with the material, it’s hard to get engrossed in the storyline and not wish for more. While well written, the incredibly short length does a disservice to Mary I feel. With its stopping point as she takes the crown in July 1553, it skips over her entire marriage to Philip of Spain, her fervor for religious policy, and her false pregnancies, the last of which led to her death (most likely due to ovarian cysts or uterine cancer). I wish the author would have just continued her story up until her death. As an experienced Tudor era reader, I didn’t really care for this book but if you’re totally new to the subject matter, it should be enjoyable.
A lot of the historical fiction I read is set in Tudor England; it’s one of my favorite time periods to read about. I couldn’t even tell you how many books I’ve read in this genre. Most of them have to do with Henry VIII and his six wives or his second daughter, Elizabeth I. Few of the ones I come across deal with Henry’s firstborn, Mary I, and I don’t know why as she’s a fascinating person. Often written off as “Bloody Mary” (even though she sent far fewer people to their death than her father), she was a devout Catholic who tried to bring the practice back to the forefront of English life during her reign. The daughter of Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon, Mary was the only one of her parents’ children to survive to adulthood. This was quite the problem for Henry as he needed a son to carry on the family line and inherit the throne – he was completely against the idea of a woman doing so.
"In Her Own Right: A Novel of Lady Mary Tudor" tells Mary’s story from the time she was two years old until the day she is crowned Queen of England. At two years of age, she is betrothed to the Dauphin of France and already acts like a little queen. This marriage contract falls through three years later however, and she is eventually betrothed again at the age of six to her 22-year-old cousin, Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor. This engagement was also broken off (by Charles) and yet a third marriage treaty was proposed by Cardinal Wolsey to either Francis I of France or his second son, Henri, Duke of Orleans. Just like the two previous marriage contracts, this one falls through as well.
Mary loses her status as princess once her father decides that his marriage to Catherine should be annulled, stating that their marriage was a sin, quoting bible passages as his proof since Catherine was the widow of his brother, Arthur. After much legal debate, the marriage between Henry and Catherine is considered invalid and mother and daughter are separated as Henry essentially banishes Catherine from court. Mary is now called “Lady Mary” as her father pursues a new marriage with Anne Boelyn, resulting in the birth of the future Elizabeth I. Mary adamantly refuses to acknowledge her stepmother as queen, emphatically stating that her mother, Catherine, is the true queen of England, that her parents’ marriage was valid, and therefore she is still a princess of the realm. Henry is not happy with his daughter’s stance and their once close relationship becomes strained.
This battle of wills between father and daughter is a constant theme through the novel and their relationship continues to change as successive wives march down the aisle with Henry VIII. In fact, one of the stronger themes of the novel seems to be Mary’s relationships with others around her and how that affects her status both personally and royally. Once Henry finally passes away, Mary’s position in the line of succession again comes into question as her younger brother, Edward VI, a strict Protestant, takes the crown. With her being a Catholic, Edward doesn’t want his sister taking the throne in the event of his death and Mary must again fight for her position once he does pass. Cue the entrance of the “nine days queen,” Jane Grey and her tragic story (but we’ll have to save that for another day).
This novel does take large jumps forward in the historical timeline to be able to cover most of her life in such a short book (only 231 pages) which can be a little jarring if you have knowledge of Tudor history and know what to expect next. It’s a good general overview for a newbie to the subject matter but for someone who is a little more experienced with the material, it’s hard to get engrossed in the storyline and not wish for more. While well written, the incredibly short length does a disservice to Mary I feel. With its stopping point as she takes the crown in July 1553, it skips over her entire marriage to Philip of Spain, her fervor for religious policy, and her false pregnancies, the last of which led to her death (most likely due to ovarian cysts or uterine cancer). I wish the author would have just continued her story up until her death. As an experienced Tudor era reader, I didn’t really care for this book but if you’re totally new to the subject matter, it should be enjoyable.
August 2, 2023
“Princess Mary stood before the envoys from France looking elegant beyond her few years in a dress of cloth of gold and a black velvet cap.” Visiting ambassadors “were at her father’s court to discuss a treaty between the two nations, which would be sealed with Mary’s betrothal to the dauphin.”
Princess Mary was two years old.
The status of women in the Renaissance era is very much a theme in this novel. A reader will see Mary Tudor and women in general used as tokens in a game of comparative male status. Much loved by her father as a child, Mary’s situation changes drastically as King Henry’s mental state morphs, twisted by his insatiable greed for power and admiration.
Denied by her father and his adherents when the marriage of her mother to the king is deemed invalid, Mary’s own world view hardens. In private and public dealings, she presses the acknowledgment of Roman Catholicism as the one true religion, while stamping out Protestantism, even as her father insists on her submission and her life is in jeopardy.
The author mirrors this disunion in descriptions of Mary’s mode of dress. Having studied historic costuming, attended workshops and participated in costuming events, I found this informative and particularly enjoyable. For example, readers see Mary required to appear in the garb of a “proper Protestant woman,” but on another occasion, “wearing a gown of green and white velvet, with an assortment of large, precious jewels.”
When in King Henry’s disfavor, Mary is forced from her home to assume the position of nurse to her young half-sister, Elizabeth. Mary, who is highly educated, sees this as an opportunity to both tutor the girl and assert her stance regarding the “one true religion.” Elizabeth quietly expresses her belief that religion should be a private thing. The reader asks, is that the character of religion? And what are the differences between religion and faith?
Considered in depth, I perceive this historical novel as a cautionary tale about the intermingling of, and tension between, the edicts of religious and secular law, the parsing of which will long engage my mind.
Indeed, the subject era was a time very different from ours. Or was it?
I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley. My review is voluntary and honest.
Princess Mary was two years old.
The status of women in the Renaissance era is very much a theme in this novel. A reader will see Mary Tudor and women in general used as tokens in a game of comparative male status. Much loved by her father as a child, Mary’s situation changes drastically as King Henry’s mental state morphs, twisted by his insatiable greed for power and admiration.
Denied by her father and his adherents when the marriage of her mother to the king is deemed invalid, Mary’s own world view hardens. In private and public dealings, she presses the acknowledgment of Roman Catholicism as the one true religion, while stamping out Protestantism, even as her father insists on her submission and her life is in jeopardy.
The author mirrors this disunion in descriptions of Mary’s mode of dress. Having studied historic costuming, attended workshops and participated in costuming events, I found this informative and particularly enjoyable. For example, readers see Mary required to appear in the garb of a “proper Protestant woman,” but on another occasion, “wearing a gown of green and white velvet, with an assortment of large, precious jewels.”
When in King Henry’s disfavor, Mary is forced from her home to assume the position of nurse to her young half-sister, Elizabeth. Mary, who is highly educated, sees this as an opportunity to both tutor the girl and assert her stance regarding the “one true religion.” Elizabeth quietly expresses her belief that religion should be a private thing. The reader asks, is that the character of religion? And what are the differences between religion and faith?
Considered in depth, I perceive this historical novel as a cautionary tale about the intermingling of, and tension between, the edicts of religious and secular law, the parsing of which will long engage my mind.
Indeed, the subject era was a time very different from ours. Or was it?
I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley. My review is voluntary and honest.
July 18, 2023
A fabulous historical fiction work and introduction to Lady Mary Tudor. The writing style is simple and direct, and the story keeps a good pace to ensure the reader remains engaged. The author's focus on Mary is a refreshing one, as she suggests in the author's note, that many other works are preoccupied with other events during this same period (King Henry, his wives and their gruesome deaths, is one clear example).
Mary's proposed personality, views and opinions are given quality page time and I enjoyed trying to understand more about her position instead of her just being written off simply as 'Bloody Mary, the tyrant.' (Of course, bearing in mind that this book is still historical fiction and not taking everything as gospel therein.) I would love to read a part two to this novel which dives into her marriage to King Phillip II of Spain and the Marian persecutions. It would be interesting to see what Mary-focused light the author sheds on those events having already laid out clear origins and the early tribulations of a defiant and determined young royal in this book.
Mary's relationships with those close to her play a significant role which keeps things ever-so interesting, especially given the fact that not all her closest companions shared her views. While Mary was firmly allied with her mother, her relationships with Elizabeth and Edward are conveyed as being close despite their fundamental disagreements on religion and reform. The story also does a great job of remaining character-driven, instead of simply a dry political retelling.
An excellent novel, one that is a great and simplified introduction to the beginnings of Mary I of England's relatively short but eventful life. That you to NetGalley and Black Rose Writing for the opportunity to provide this early review.
Mary's proposed personality, views and opinions are given quality page time and I enjoyed trying to understand more about her position instead of her just being written off simply as 'Bloody Mary, the tyrant.' (Of course, bearing in mind that this book is still historical fiction and not taking everything as gospel therein.) I would love to read a part two to this novel which dives into her marriage to King Phillip II of Spain and the Marian persecutions. It would be interesting to see what Mary-focused light the author sheds on those events having already laid out clear origins and the early tribulations of a defiant and determined young royal in this book.
Mary's relationships with those close to her play a significant role which keeps things ever-so interesting, especially given the fact that not all her closest companions shared her views. While Mary was firmly allied with her mother, her relationships with Elizabeth and Edward are conveyed as being close despite their fundamental disagreements on religion and reform. The story also does a great job of remaining character-driven, instead of simply a dry political retelling.
An excellent novel, one that is a great and simplified introduction to the beginnings of Mary I of England's relatively short but eventful life. That you to NetGalley and Black Rose Writing for the opportunity to provide this early review.
August 18, 2023
I am a huge fan of the Tudor dynasty, and I've read many books - both fiction & nonfiction - about them. Some were great, some not so great. Amanda Schiavo's "In Her Own Right" falls into the great category. A fictionalized account of Mary I's life from young girlhood up to her coronation as queen, I found it to be thoroughly engrossing and a whirlwind with regard to Mary's emotions. And so much is addressed in the book that it would take an in-depth report to cover it all.
However, one major conclusion I've come to regarding Mary I: her anger and resentment over how she & her mother were treated by Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn colored her life from the moment Anne appeared until the day she, Mary, died. This is understandable, but only up to a point. Anne did not bewitch Henry, despite what many at the time said and thought. Henry made a conscious choice to get involved with Anne - though he misused the Bible to justify it, something that neither Mary or her mother ever truly believed or accepted. Laying all the blame at Anne Boleyn's feet is wrong, because as the saying goes, it takes two to tango.
In the end, Schiavo wrote an excellent book. She does a stellar job painting a more nuanced portrait of Mary I, rather than the usual portrayal of her being fanatically Catholic, the executioner of Protestants (hence the nickname 'Bloody Mary'), the one who lost Calais, and the poor woman who had 2 phantom pregnancies, while bearing unrequited love for her husband Philip II of Spain. While all this may be true, Schiavo proved that so much of what happened to Mary were due to events happening around her. Like all humans, she did the best she knew how to, while striving to stay true to herself and to her mother.
A winner of a read for any Tudor history fan. Thanks to NetGalley and Black Rose Writing for this arc, which I voluntarily reviewed.
However, one major conclusion I've come to regarding Mary I: her anger and resentment over how she & her mother were treated by Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn colored her life from the moment Anne appeared until the day she, Mary, died. This is understandable, but only up to a point. Anne did not bewitch Henry, despite what many at the time said and thought. Henry made a conscious choice to get involved with Anne - though he misused the Bible to justify it, something that neither Mary or her mother ever truly believed or accepted. Laying all the blame at Anne Boleyn's feet is wrong, because as the saying goes, it takes two to tango.
In the end, Schiavo wrote an excellent book. She does a stellar job painting a more nuanced portrait of Mary I, rather than the usual portrayal of her being fanatically Catholic, the executioner of Protestants (hence the nickname 'Bloody Mary'), the one who lost Calais, and the poor woman who had 2 phantom pregnancies, while bearing unrequited love for her husband Philip II of Spain. While all this may be true, Schiavo proved that so much of what happened to Mary were due to events happening around her. Like all humans, she did the best she knew how to, while striving to stay true to herself and to her mother.
A winner of a read for any Tudor history fan. Thanks to NetGalley and Black Rose Writing for this arc, which I voluntarily reviewed.
September 23, 2025
Mary Tudor was known as the first Queen of England. She had a negative reputation and was often known as Bloody Mary. This historical novel followed Mary’s life as an infant to being a sovereign Queen. It showed how she went from being a spoiled and pampered princess to becoming neglected by her own father.
Mary was a very sympathetic character. She was once a cheerful and happy young child. When her father put her own mother aside, she was neglected. Mary fought for her rights as a true princess. She refused to be acknowledged as illegitimate. Mary was also very devoted to her religion and was willing to fight against her father and brother in order to stand true to her beliefs. Therefore, I really liked Mary Tudor, and I couldn’t wait for her to become queen in her own right!
Overall, this novel is about patience, ambition, and faith. I found all the characters to be realistic and well-developed. I particularly like the characters of Elizabeth and Edward. My favorite part of the book is as the tense relationship between Anne Boleyn and Mary Tudor! I thought that it portrayed their intense rivalry well! There were times that I thought that this novel was very rushed and would have liked for it to be longer! Nevertheless, it was a light and short read that can be read on a lazy Sunday afternoon! I loved how the story was rich in detail and the writing made Tudor England come alive! I recommend this for fans of Carolly Erickson, Alison Weir, and Tony Riches!
(Note: I read an ARC copy of this book in courtesy of Netgalley.)
Mary was a very sympathetic character. She was once a cheerful and happy young child. When her father put her own mother aside, she was neglected. Mary fought for her rights as a true princess. She refused to be acknowledged as illegitimate. Mary was also very devoted to her religion and was willing to fight against her father and brother in order to stand true to her beliefs. Therefore, I really liked Mary Tudor, and I couldn’t wait for her to become queen in her own right!
Overall, this novel is about patience, ambition, and faith. I found all the characters to be realistic and well-developed. I particularly like the characters of Elizabeth and Edward. My favorite part of the book is as the tense relationship between Anne Boleyn and Mary Tudor! I thought that it portrayed their intense rivalry well! There were times that I thought that this novel was very rushed and would have liked for it to be longer! Nevertheless, it was a light and short read that can be read on a lazy Sunday afternoon! I loved how the story was rich in detail and the writing made Tudor England come alive! I recommend this for fans of Carolly Erickson, Alison Weir, and Tony Riches!
(Note: I read an ARC copy of this book in courtesy of Netgalley.)
July 3, 2023
This is the story of Mary Tudor's early years - up to her coronation. It does not appear that there will be a continuation of the story. It is well written historical fiction and told from Mary's pov - rather than her just being a character in someone else's story. The author writes in Mary's voice very much as we have come to know her throughout other historical facts. Very entertaining and doesn't drag out those events that all Tudor fans know like the back of their hands. Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
Update.... Per the author there will be a sequel to this book. Yay!
Update.... Per the author there will be a sequel to this book. Yay!
July 17, 2023
Interesting and well-written. I always found Mary's life fascinating, especially before her reign. The pain, turmoil, and uncertainty she suffered was unimaginable during her father's lifetime, but likewise she caused the same to others later when crowned queen.
August 16, 2023
We all know the story of Henry VIII, Anne Boleyn, and Elizabeth, but who was Mary Tudor, often called Bloody Mary. In the stories of these people people, Mary is portrayed as the villain; a blood-thirsty, power-hungry, conniving woman. Who was the real Mary, the oldest surviving child of Henry VIII and his first wife, Katherine of Aragon?
This is the novelization of the life of Mary from 2 years until her coronation, and you learn so much of the tragedy of her life through this personal lens, as well as her heart for the women in her life including her mother, Elizabeth, and Jane Grey. You see the political mechinations behind the theological strife in her life, and men who are still well-respected in Anglicanism like Thomas Cranmer are seen from a new point-of-view in how they dealt with Mary.
While I do think the embellishments made the lurch to "kill all non-Catholics in the ruling class and royal family" feel more drastic, I did enjoy the pacing of getting to know Mary at so many different stages of her life. Great if you've ever been interested in this period of history!
This is the novelization of the life of Mary from 2 years until her coronation, and you learn so much of the tragedy of her life through this personal lens, as well as her heart for the women in her life including her mother, Elizabeth, and Jane Grey. You see the political mechinations behind the theological strife in her life, and men who are still well-respected in Anglicanism like Thomas Cranmer are seen from a new point-of-view in how they dealt with Mary.
While I do think the embellishments made the lurch to "kill all non-Catholics in the ruling class and royal family" feel more drastic, I did enjoy the pacing of getting to know Mary at so many different stages of her life. Great if you've ever been interested in this period of history!
July 8, 2023
This is well written historical fiction about Queen Mary, the daughter of Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon. This takes you from her childhood to becoming Queen. I appreciate this information, as I continue to be muddled about the Royals.
Mary went through many hardships - her father was Henry VIII after all. Beheadings, trips to the Tower, scheming, the incredibly distant parenting of the Royals, her loneliness. This is an excellent read.
Netgalley
Mary went through many hardships - her father was Henry VIII after all. Beheadings, trips to the Tower, scheming, the incredibly distant parenting of the Royals, her loneliness. This is an excellent read.
Netgalley
May 15, 2025
Good helping of Historical Fiction
I found this author on TikTok and decided to give it a shot. It was a good and quick read!
I found this author on TikTok and decided to give it a shot. It was a good and quick read!
August 25, 2023
A fantastic read giving a wider view of the life and trials of the much maligned Mary first.
We'll researched and written in a style which is easy to read and follow.
A must read and must have for any Tudor enthusiasts books shelf.
We'll researched and written in a style which is easy to read and follow.
A must read and must have for any Tudor enthusiasts books shelf.
August 8, 2023
This is bound to become one of my favourite reads of the year, which I wasn't expecting at all. I've always disliked Mary just as much as I've always adored Anne Boleyn, but this novel has opened up a space for her in my heart.
Mind you, this isn't a history book, it's mostly fictional but has enough truth in it to be interesting and cherished by any Tudor nerd.
I've loved how delicate and compelling the writer was, and how short the chapters are. Makes for a quick read.
Mind you, this isn't a history book, it's mostly fictional but has enough truth in it to be interesting and cherished by any Tudor nerd.
I've loved how delicate and compelling the writer was, and how short the chapters are. Makes for a quick read.
November 6, 2023
Full review at: https://readingourshelves.wordpress.c...
In Her Own Right tells Mary’s story from the time she was two years old until the day she is crowned Queen of England. At two years of age, she is betrothed to the Dauphin of France and already acts like a little queen. This marriage contract falls through three years later however, and she is eventually betrothed again at the age of six to her 22-year-old cousin, Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor. This engagement was also broken off (by Charles) and yet a third marriage treaty was proposed by Cardinal Wolsey to either Francis I of France or his second son, Henri, Duke of Orleans. Just like the two previous marriage contracts, this one falls through as well.
Mary loses her status as princess once her father decides that his marriage to Catherine should be annulled, stating that their marriage was a sin, quoting bible passages as his proof since Catherine was the widow of his brother, Arthur. After much legal debate, the marriage between Henry and Catherine is considered invalid and mother and daughter are separated as Henry essentially banishes Catherine from court. Mary is now called “Lady Mary” as her father pursues a new marriage with Anne Boelyn, resulting in the birth of the future Elizabeth I. Mary adamantly refuses to acknowledge her stepmother as queen, emphatically stating that her mother, Catherine, is the true queen of England, that her parents’ marriage was valid. Therefore she is still a princess of the realm. Henry is unhappy with his daughter’s stance and their once close relationship becomes strained.
This battle of wills between father and daughter is a constant theme throughout the novel and their relationship continues to change as successive wives march down the aisle with Henry VIII. In fact, one of the stronger themes of the novel seems to be Mary’s relationships with others around her and how that affects her status both personally and royally. Once Henry finally passes away, Mary’s position in the line of succession again comes into question as her younger brother, Edward VI, a strict Protestant, takes the crown. With her being a Catholic, Edward doesn’t want his sister taking the throne in the event of his death and Mary must again fight for her position once he does pass. Cue the entrance of the “Nine Days Queen,” Jane Grey and her tragic story.
This novel does take large jumps forward in the historical timeline to be able to cover most of her life in such a short book (only 231 pages) which can be a little jarring if you have knowledge of Tudor history and know what to expect next. It’s a good general overview for a newbie to the subject matter but for someone who is a little more experienced with the material, it’s hard to get engrossed in the storyline and not wish for more. While well written, the incredibly short length does a disservice to Mary I feel. With its stopping point as she takes the crown in July 1553, it skips over her entire marriage to Philip of Spain, her fervor for religious policy, and her false pregnancies, the last of which led to her death (most likely due to ovarian cysts or uterine cancer). I wish the author would have just continued her story up until her death. As an experienced Tudor era reader, I didn’t really care for this book but if you’re totally new to the subject matter, it should be enjoyable.
In Her Own Right tells Mary’s story from the time she was two years old until the day she is crowned Queen of England. At two years of age, she is betrothed to the Dauphin of France and already acts like a little queen. This marriage contract falls through three years later however, and she is eventually betrothed again at the age of six to her 22-year-old cousin, Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor. This engagement was also broken off (by Charles) and yet a third marriage treaty was proposed by Cardinal Wolsey to either Francis I of France or his second son, Henri, Duke of Orleans. Just like the two previous marriage contracts, this one falls through as well.
Mary loses her status as princess once her father decides that his marriage to Catherine should be annulled, stating that their marriage was a sin, quoting bible passages as his proof since Catherine was the widow of his brother, Arthur. After much legal debate, the marriage between Henry and Catherine is considered invalid and mother and daughter are separated as Henry essentially banishes Catherine from court. Mary is now called “Lady Mary” as her father pursues a new marriage with Anne Boelyn, resulting in the birth of the future Elizabeth I. Mary adamantly refuses to acknowledge her stepmother as queen, emphatically stating that her mother, Catherine, is the true queen of England, that her parents’ marriage was valid. Therefore she is still a princess of the realm. Henry is unhappy with his daughter’s stance and their once close relationship becomes strained.
This battle of wills between father and daughter is a constant theme throughout the novel and their relationship continues to change as successive wives march down the aisle with Henry VIII. In fact, one of the stronger themes of the novel seems to be Mary’s relationships with others around her and how that affects her status both personally and royally. Once Henry finally passes away, Mary’s position in the line of succession again comes into question as her younger brother, Edward VI, a strict Protestant, takes the crown. With her being a Catholic, Edward doesn’t want his sister taking the throne in the event of his death and Mary must again fight for her position once he does pass. Cue the entrance of the “Nine Days Queen,” Jane Grey and her tragic story.
This novel does take large jumps forward in the historical timeline to be able to cover most of her life in such a short book (only 231 pages) which can be a little jarring if you have knowledge of Tudor history and know what to expect next. It’s a good general overview for a newbie to the subject matter but for someone who is a little more experienced with the material, it’s hard to get engrossed in the storyline and not wish for more. While well written, the incredibly short length does a disservice to Mary I feel. With its stopping point as she takes the crown in July 1553, it skips over her entire marriage to Philip of Spain, her fervor for religious policy, and her false pregnancies, the last of which led to her death (most likely due to ovarian cysts or uterine cancer). I wish the author would have just continued her story up until her death. As an experienced Tudor era reader, I didn’t really care for this book but if you’re totally new to the subject matter, it should be enjoyable.
August 7, 2023
This straightforward narrative describes Mary Tudor’s early life from a third person point of view bias to Mary’s thoughts and feelings, unlike other Mary Tudor novels (Plaidy, Arnopp, and Lewis) that describe Mary’s life as a remembering later in life. This fresh approach presents Mary’s view of life and the harshness endured by her father’s need for a male heir until her coronation at 37. The reader becomes part of Mary’s life as she moves from “the pearl of [Henry’s] world” to a mistreated servant. Ms. Schiavo allows readers to feel how Mary was loved and cherished and thrown away because she was a diplomatic tool and promised to several of her father’s allies. The book focuses on Mary’s relationships with her half-sister, Elizabeth, and Lady Margaret. The bond between Mary and Margaret is a genuine, long-lasting friendship with its ups and downs. Mary’s bitterness, jealousy, and anger result from her father’s abuse. Mary’s relationships with Elizabeth and Lady Margaret keep the reader wanting more.
Reviews are subjective and depend entirely on the reader. In Her Own Right – A Novel of Lady Mary Tudor is a historical fiction novel, and the author explains this. Still, there are a few challenges this reader encountered. I struggled with Chapter 1, 1518, when Mary was two. While it is well-documented that the dialogue between Mary and the French ambassador took place and that she was a gifted child, the rest of Mary’s dialogue and actions in this chapter portray a much older child. A two-year-old child has limits, and there are certain developmental milestones for creating a believable character. At two years of age, a child is not receiving a “rigorous education” because they are incapable of thinking or speaking critically; they begin to understand other people and have thoughts and feelings that are different than their own.
The author made a judgment call balancing the sense of history with enough modernity in dialogue to be understandable for a modern reader. There are anachronisms used in the narrative and characters’ dialogue that the English people of the novel’s setting would have been doubtful to say. For example. ‘holler’ is an American word used in the late 1670s. The term’ jilt’ is a 17th-century word, and ‘jellyfish,’ used figuratively for a person of weak character, was not in use until later. There are many medieval insults Henry VIII would have used instead.
Moreover, when speaking with a king/queen, one tends to use formal language and would not use idioms, ‘been down this road before.’ Some conversations spoke too much like a modern person or someone from the recent past, not 16th-century royal England. For a well-read logophile, there are parts where I stopped and questioned the language used. However, other readers may keep reading because the dialogue is not usual enough to pull them out of the story. Depending on the target audience, language immerses the reader in the story.
A three-star book is a good read. I recommend you read the novel for a new approach to Mary Tudor’s early life.
August 5, 2023
Mary is the only living child of her father Henry VIII’s marriage to Catherine of Aragon. She’s the apple of his eye at court until he casts aside her mother for Anne Boleyn. Catherine is exiled, the catholic faith abandoned and Mary has to serve her new half-sister Elizabeth while being called a bastard herself. Nonetheless, Mary keeps fighting for her status as true heir of her father and her own catholic faith.
Elizabeth certainly outnumbers the attention Mary Tudor receives in historical fiction. Schiavo debut novel makes a fine attempt to sketch Mary’s childhood as a girl who has had a lot to endure. But also of a stubborn woman who continued to fight for her rights and her faith.
Unlike other authors, Schiavo does manage to portray Mary humanely. Mainly by creating her fictional friend Margaret and by establishing a warm relationship with Elizabeth. The two sisters are very close in this story. But once again we get a Mary who acts coldly towards all Henry’s other wives (except Jane Seymour) and most of the nobles at court… She doesn’t make things easy for herself.
The book goes in a very fast pace by just about everything that happens at the Tudor court and therefore lacks some depth for me. The story does its best to frame what happens later during her reign in the light of her unhappy childhood. And as the author herself puts it: this doesn’t excuse what ‘Bloody Mary’ did afterwards, but we may be judging this queen a bit too much for those five years of reign, rather than on everything that happened before that.
This is not the best Tudor novel I’ve read. Mary is certainly not my favourite Tudor figure. But this novel does shed a -probably- quite correct and rather warm light on England’s first queen regnant.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
Dutch review:
Mary is de enige levende dochter uit het huwelijk van haar vader Henry VIII met Catherine of Aragon. Ze is dan ook zijn oogappel aan het hof, dat hij haar moeder aan de kant schuift voor Anne Boleyn. Catherine wordt verbannen, het katholieke geloof komt onder druk te staan en Mary moet als bastaard haar nieuwe halfzus Elizabeth gaan dienen. Mary wil blijven vechten voor haar status als ware erfgenaam en haar geloof en dat zal haar niet altijd in dank worden afgenomen.
De boeken over Mary Tudor zijn in de minderheid ten opzichte van de aandacht die Elizabeth krijgt. Schiavo doet een mooie poging om vanaf Mary's kinderjaren het leven te schetsen van een meisje dat veel te verduren krijgt. Maar ook van een koppige vrouw die is blijven vechten voor in eerste instantie haar geloof.
In tegenstelling tot andere auteurs slaagt Schiavo er wel in om Mary menselijk neer te zetten. Voornamelijk door haar fictieve vriendin Margaret in het leven te roepen en door een warme relatie met Elizabeth neer te zetten. De twee zussen komen heel mooi naar voren in dit verhaal. Maar we krijgen opnieuw een Mary die heel koud doet tegenover alle andere vrouwen van Henry (behalve Jane Seymour), de meeste nobelen aan het hof... enfin, ze maakt het haarzelf niet makkelijk.
Het boek gaat aan een sneltempo voorbij aan zowat alles wat er aan het Tudorhof gebeurt en mist voor mij daardoor wat diepgang. Het verhaal doet wel zijn best om wat er later tijdens haar regeerperiode gebeurt wat te kaderen in het licht van haar ongelukkige jeugd. En zoals de auteur het zelf verwoordt: dit is geen excuus voor wat 'Bloody Mary' nadien uitrichtte, maar we rekenen deze koningin misschien wel wat te veel af of die 5 jaar regeerperiode, in plaats van op alles wat er daarvoor gebeurde.
Bedankt aan Netgalley en de uitgever voor een exemplaar van dit boek in ruil voor mijn eerlijke mening.
Elizabeth certainly outnumbers the attention Mary Tudor receives in historical fiction. Schiavo debut novel makes a fine attempt to sketch Mary’s childhood as a girl who has had a lot to endure. But also of a stubborn woman who continued to fight for her rights and her faith.
Unlike other authors, Schiavo does manage to portray Mary humanely. Mainly by creating her fictional friend Margaret and by establishing a warm relationship with Elizabeth. The two sisters are very close in this story. But once again we get a Mary who acts coldly towards all Henry’s other wives (except Jane Seymour) and most of the nobles at court… She doesn’t make things easy for herself.
The book goes in a very fast pace by just about everything that happens at the Tudor court and therefore lacks some depth for me. The story does its best to frame what happens later during her reign in the light of her unhappy childhood. And as the author herself puts it: this doesn’t excuse what ‘Bloody Mary’ did afterwards, but we may be judging this queen a bit too much for those five years of reign, rather than on everything that happened before that.
This is not the best Tudor novel I’ve read. Mary is certainly not my favourite Tudor figure. But this novel does shed a -probably- quite correct and rather warm light on England’s first queen regnant.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
Dutch review:
Mary is de enige levende dochter uit het huwelijk van haar vader Henry VIII met Catherine of Aragon. Ze is dan ook zijn oogappel aan het hof, dat hij haar moeder aan de kant schuift voor Anne Boleyn. Catherine wordt verbannen, het katholieke geloof komt onder druk te staan en Mary moet als bastaard haar nieuwe halfzus Elizabeth gaan dienen. Mary wil blijven vechten voor haar status als ware erfgenaam en haar geloof en dat zal haar niet altijd in dank worden afgenomen.
De boeken over Mary Tudor zijn in de minderheid ten opzichte van de aandacht die Elizabeth krijgt. Schiavo doet een mooie poging om vanaf Mary's kinderjaren het leven te schetsen van een meisje dat veel te verduren krijgt. Maar ook van een koppige vrouw die is blijven vechten voor in eerste instantie haar geloof.
In tegenstelling tot andere auteurs slaagt Schiavo er wel in om Mary menselijk neer te zetten. Voornamelijk door haar fictieve vriendin Margaret in het leven te roepen en door een warme relatie met Elizabeth neer te zetten. De twee zussen komen heel mooi naar voren in dit verhaal. Maar we krijgen opnieuw een Mary die heel koud doet tegenover alle andere vrouwen van Henry (behalve Jane Seymour), de meeste nobelen aan het hof... enfin, ze maakt het haarzelf niet makkelijk.
Het boek gaat aan een sneltempo voorbij aan zowat alles wat er aan het Tudorhof gebeurt en mist voor mij daardoor wat diepgang. Het verhaal doet wel zijn best om wat er later tijdens haar regeerperiode gebeurt wat te kaderen in het licht van haar ongelukkige jeugd. En zoals de auteur het zelf verwoordt: dit is geen excuus voor wat 'Bloody Mary' nadien uitrichtte, maar we rekenen deze koningin misschien wel wat te veel af of die 5 jaar regeerperiode, in plaats van op alles wat er daarvoor gebeurde.
Bedankt aan Netgalley en de uitgever voor een exemplaar van dit boek in ruil voor mijn eerlijke mening.
October 3, 2024
👑Amanda Schiavo’s novel Born into a World of Privilege and Power transports readers into the Renaissance era, focusing on Mary Tudor's tumultuous journey. Raised in a world of wealth and influence, Mary is initially resigned to her expected role as a European princess. She understands her duty to marry for political advantage and produce heirs, yet she remains sidelined in a male-dominated world. The weight of her father’s relentless quest for a male heir further diminishes her hopes of securing her place in history.⚔️👑
📝Author vividly captures the struggles Mary faced in this patriarchal society, showing her strength and determination. The novel explores how her father, Henry VIII, and his brutal decisions shaped Mary’s life and aspirations. Living in the shadows of powerful men, Mary learns that the throne she desires is nearly unattainable, and she is forced to navigate a political landscape fraught with danger and betrayal.⚡
✍️The narrative shifts dramatically as unexpected events shake the foundation of her life. Author masterfully uses these traumas to propel Mary’s character development, transforming her from a passive princess into a woman determined to claim the English throne. The journey to power is not just political; it’s deeply personal as Mary confronts societal expectations, her own insecurities, and the ghosts of her family’s legacy.🌟
💫In this well-researched and gripping historical novel, Author delves into Mary Tudor’s fierce resilience and rightful claim to power. The reader is taken on a journey through the highs and lows of Mary’s life, making this a compelling and inspiring tale of ambition, survival, and the quest for power.✴️
📝Author vividly captures the struggles Mary faced in this patriarchal society, showing her strength and determination. The novel explores how her father, Henry VIII, and his brutal decisions shaped Mary’s life and aspirations. Living in the shadows of powerful men, Mary learns that the throne she desires is nearly unattainable, and she is forced to navigate a political landscape fraught with danger and betrayal.⚡
✍️The narrative shifts dramatically as unexpected events shake the foundation of her life. Author masterfully uses these traumas to propel Mary’s character development, transforming her from a passive princess into a woman determined to claim the English throne. The journey to power is not just political; it’s deeply personal as Mary confronts societal expectations, her own insecurities, and the ghosts of her family’s legacy.🌟
💫In this well-researched and gripping historical novel, Author delves into Mary Tudor’s fierce resilience and rightful claim to power. The reader is taken on a journey through the highs and lows of Mary’s life, making this a compelling and inspiring tale of ambition, survival, and the quest for power.✴️
July 20, 2023
This was an excellent book. I have been reading about this book about Princess Mary and when I received an email from Black Rose that it was available at NetGalley for review, I immediately requested a chance to review it. I am so glad I did. I am one of those followers of the British Royal family that have read numerous books on all of the Kings and Queens since 1066 but have not read much about Queen Mary I herself, just the terrible things that happened to non-Catholics during her reign.
This book deals with what happens to her after her parents marriage falls apart. All the turmoil she went through when she was declared illegitimate and knew that there were so many people against her because they considered her a threat to their own ambitions. I know that this not a biography but a fictional account of Princess Mary's life but does ring true in so many ways, especially since I have read more history books about her recently.
King Henry VIII was a horrible man and the way he treated his wives and daughters was appalling. In full disclosure, I am an admirer of Richard III and not a fan of either King Henry. But I have read a lot of books on King Henry VII, his wives and children. Queen Elizabeth I, on the other hand, is the true shining star of the Tudor family. And this book was very flattering to her legacy.
I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley. My review is voluntary and honest
This book deals with what happens to her after her parents marriage falls apart. All the turmoil she went through when she was declared illegitimate and knew that there were so many people against her because they considered her a threat to their own ambitions. I know that this not a biography but a fictional account of Princess Mary's life but does ring true in so many ways, especially since I have read more history books about her recently.
King Henry VIII was a horrible man and the way he treated his wives and daughters was appalling. In full disclosure, I am an admirer of Richard III and not a fan of either King Henry. But I have read a lot of books on King Henry VII, his wives and children. Queen Elizabeth I, on the other hand, is the true shining star of the Tudor family. And this book was very flattering to her legacy.
I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley. My review is voluntary and honest
July 30, 2023
I have read many historical fiction books that were set during the life of Henry VIII and Mary I, but this was my first historical fiction book featuring a member of the Tudor family. I will say that some of the conversations and situations in this book could have taken place in real life. I love how a book can take you right to that time period. This one can. From the beginning, you are transported to a day when Mary was the apple of her father's eye. He wanted a boy, yes, but he loved his Mary and even her mother. Once the narcissistic king realized Katherine would never bore him a son and Mary was not suitable to lead England, his eye starts wandering and lands on the captivating Anne Boleyn. Anne is different than other women, she won't sleep with the King until he weds her. Henry will uproot everything, including the religion of a country to have this woman. And this is just the start of this book!!! Henry will win this woman, and the next one, and the next one, and the next one, and finally the last one. Mary's father can shed wives as we do soiled clothes. All the while Mary is unsure where her fate lies. Sometimes she is cast aside, sometimes she is welcome, but always she is called "illegitimate". She has siblings that she cares about, and her faith in God is steadfast. She practices a secret religion that is banned in her country and tries to plan for a future that sometimes has little hope. The Mary we see here is just existing, trying to be faithful to God and her father, whom she does love.
Thanks, NetGalley for letting me get a hold of this one.
Thanks, NetGalley for letting me get a hold of this one.
December 28, 2023
There is a LOT of telling rather than showing here, as Schiavo is determined to cover nearly 40 years in one book, so we often skip through several years in one paragraph. Also, the POV often skitters away from Mary to those around you, so you have to pay attention to keep track of whose thoughts are being shown.
Still, I enjoyed seeing the arc of showing how Mary developed her sense of right and wrong, and we do see how the gentle princess will eventually turn into "Bloody Mary".
My favorite scene was her being brought to say goodbye to her father Henry VIII on his death bed and he sadly tells her: "life has been hard to you" and we see the effort it takes for her to keep her mouth closed rather than scream at him: YOU! YOU made my life hard!" The scene encapsulates both Henry's delusions and the how much Mary had to hold back when other people were in power.
Still, I enjoyed seeing the arc of showing how Mary developed her sense of right and wrong, and we do see how the gentle princess will eventually turn into "Bloody Mary".
My favorite scene was her being brought to say goodbye to her father Henry VIII on his death bed and he sadly tells her: "life has been hard to you" and we see the effort it takes for her to keep her mouth closed rather than scream at him: YOU! YOU made my life hard!" The scene encapsulates both Henry's delusions and the how much Mary had to hold back when other people were in power.
June 18, 2023
Thank you NetGalley, Amanda Schiavo, and Black Rose Writing for allowing me to read an advanced copy of In Her Own Right: A Novel of Lady Mary Tudor in exchange for an honest review.
Let me preface by saying that this book is a fictional account of Mary's life. It should in no way be viewed as being historically accurate. The events mentioned were extremely choppy and rushed. The author does acknowledge all of this at the end, which was much appreciated for the awareness.
Mary was not present for a lot that went on at court, so it makes sense her version of everything that went on would be shortsighted based on things she would hear.
With that said, this novel is brief and to the point. It was very easy to finish it in one sitting. This is finally a version of Mary in a more positive light and not the mopey and depressed person she is often portrayed as in other books on the time period. It was entertaining and I would read it again. I wish it would have continued through to the end of her life to include her brief reign and her marriage to Philip. This book ends with her coronation.
Let me preface by saying that this book is a fictional account of Mary's life. It should in no way be viewed as being historically accurate. The events mentioned were extremely choppy and rushed. The author does acknowledge all of this at the end, which was much appreciated for the awareness.
Mary was not present for a lot that went on at court, so it makes sense her version of everything that went on would be shortsighted based on things she would hear.
With that said, this novel is brief and to the point. It was very easy to finish it in one sitting. This is finally a version of Mary in a more positive light and not the mopey and depressed person she is often portrayed as in other books on the time period. It was entertaining and I would read it again. I wish it would have continued through to the end of her life to include her brief reign and her marriage to Philip. This book ends with her coronation.
July 28, 2023
This was such an interesting read. We have all heard the story of "Bloody Mary". Her reign was not a happy one for her people many of whom were burned at the stake as heretics. But have you ever wondered what made Mary who she was?
In this book Amanda Schiavo tries to answer that question. It starts with Mary's childhood and goes as far as her accession to the thrown of England. It gives an insite into Marys thoughts and feelings and tells her story in a sympathetic way. A story most other historical novels skip over. It tries to show Mary the person rather than just Mary the "evil" Queen.
I would recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in Tudor history or anyone who likes historical fiction. It is important to point out that In Her Own Right is in no way a historical textbook. It is a historical novel based on fact. As such some characters have been made up to help the flow of the story.
Thank you to netgalley and Amanda Schiavo for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this book in return for a fair and honest review.
In this book Amanda Schiavo tries to answer that question. It starts with Mary's childhood and goes as far as her accession to the thrown of England. It gives an insite into Marys thoughts and feelings and tells her story in a sympathetic way. A story most other historical novels skip over. It tries to show Mary the person rather than just Mary the "evil" Queen.
I would recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in Tudor history or anyone who likes historical fiction. It is important to point out that In Her Own Right is in no way a historical textbook. It is a historical novel based on fact. As such some characters have been made up to help the flow of the story.
Thank you to netgalley and Amanda Schiavo for allowing me to read an advanced copy of this book in return for a fair and honest review.
July 30, 2023
In Her Own Right, to me, is the book I've been waiting for and desperately wanting! This is the backstory of Lady Mary Tudor, the woman the world knows as Queen Mary I of England. By backstory, I mean that this is the story of the trials and tribulations of Lady Mary Tudor's life - from being princess to her various demotions and the vexations that became her life. We see how all these developments affect Mary's life and their outcomes upon the end when she becomes queen!
A breathtaking story from beginning to end and told in rich detail, "In Her Own Right" is absolutely worth reading - especially if interested both in the Tudor Dynasty and in hearing a story about a girl that seems to get lost with all the to do of her father's wives and much loved and popular younger sister, Elizabeth.
A breathtaking story from beginning to end and told in rich detail, "In Her Own Right" is absolutely worth reading - especially if interested both in the Tudor Dynasty and in hearing a story about a girl that seems to get lost with all the to do of her father's wives and much loved and popular younger sister, Elizabeth.
June 24, 2023
In Her Own Right is a fictionalized history of Queen Mary, daughter of Henry VIII and Catherine of Aragon.
The book starts in early childhood and continues up to her marriage.
A quick and easy read, Ms. Schiavo 'takes us into a fictionalized account that is easy to understand (the Tudor line can be confusing) and pulls us into Mary's fraught relationship with her father and her devotion to her mother.
I really enjoyed this book and afterwards fell into the rabbit hole of European royal families.
I received this book as an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions are strictly my own.
The book starts in early childhood and continues up to her marriage.
A quick and easy read, Ms. Schiavo 'takes us into a fictionalized account that is easy to understand (the Tudor line can be confusing) and pulls us into Mary's fraught relationship with her father and her devotion to her mother.
I really enjoyed this book and afterwards fell into the rabbit hole of European royal families.
I received this book as an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions are strictly my own.
July 28, 2023
This was a brilliant peak into the past, although with a fictional twist. Normally, books around this time period focus on Mary's father, Henry (the one with all those wives that there's a rhyme about). This one focuses on Mary - and not on how history portrays her, as bloodthirsty and mad. Getting to see another side of Mary, and have her be the star of her own story, was refreshing in a way. While it isn't necessarily completely historically accurate, it's clearly based in the author's extensive research. The story was engaging, and moved along smoothly. If you're looking for a new view on the Tudors, and enjoy historical fiction, then I'd recommend grabbing this one.
July 30, 2023
I love history. I love the Tudors. I loved that this book focused on Mary in a fictionalized way and from her viewpoint. For some reason, most books I have read on Mary are History heavy and dry. This book, though I will reiterate, fictional account, makes her more human. I would definitely recommend to those who love historical fiction and anyone who would like to know more about her without every detail of her life.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC for my honest opinion.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for this ARC for my honest opinion.
July 30, 2024
Okay, this was absolutely a really quick read. Schiavo knows exactly what she's doing in her fictionalized portrayal of Mary Tudor as exactly who she was: a devout Catholic, a fierce personality, and a complex individual who would become the first Queen Regnant of England. She does not skim over the harsher aspects of Mary, but she also is consistent in her portrayal of Mary's perspective. My only notes are for spelling and punctuation errors, but these are not done so often that it greatly impacts the story.
December 20, 2024
I am motivated in my reading when I connect with a character and care about what happens to them. This did not happen with this novel. Mary Tutor is a sympathetic character in her younger years but the religious zealot she becomes does not create much sympathy on the readers part, at least not for me. By the end of my reading, I just wanted to be done. The amount of people killed in the name of religion is disgusting!
April 30, 2025
it was actually a pretty decent novel. i'm amazed because most novels about mary are disgusting and disrespectful. of course it has its own problems (such as anne stanhope erasure, or jane grey somehow being kind to mary. in real life, jane was pretty much all the time rude to mary.) it is also way too much focused on religion but still, i did enjoy this book very much. i also liked that we didn't get to read her reign because those last five years of her life reeeeaaaly bore me
August 22, 2023
This is a good book for someone just learning about Mary Tudor. The storyline was very fast paced, I wish some more time was given to the more significant times in her life. There was so much more that could have been written about, but was left out. I did enjoy how the author did go into the complex relationship between Mary and Elizabeth when they were younger.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews