Winona was an interesting tale about slavery in that Winona and Judah were not born into slavery as was common in the south. After their father's death and their enslavement, Winona and Judah grew up quickly. Judah in particular was not used to a life without freedom, which caused him to "act out" and resulted in punishment. One scene in particular was striking, in which Judah tamed an unruly horse, impressing an audience. He then received a harsh punishment for his display of intelligence, which shows the nature of the relationship between slaves and their owners. Slave owners as a whole wanted to keep slaves subservient, uneducated, and make them feel inferior. Judah also received harsher treatment than Winona because he was a man. Winona was educated, a privilege that was uncommon for slaves. This is one aspect of Winona growing up. When the novel began, Winona had an innocence about her, something that made her attractive to Maxwell. Then after her father died, Maxwell felt responsible for her and Judah and throughout the book he checked in on them.