I'd actually give this book 2.5 stars. Parts of this book were heartwarming but others parts were frustrating or defied facts and logic.
Izzy answers a mail-order bride ad placed by Matt's son Aaron (who is my favourite character in the book.) Matt marries Isabella, even though their initial reaction to each other is not love at first sight. The children, however, love Izzy. The cabin is pristine. She’s is a fantastic cook (thanks to the tavern) and a great "mother.” Unfortunately she is not a great wife as Izzy is terrified of having sex. As a child, she lived with a woman who (before leaving her to fend for herself at the age of 12) told her to beware of men and made her cut her hair off to be less appealing. Izzy is then forced by circumstances to work in a tavern. She fended off the owner unwelcome advances and kept him and his obnoxious clients at bay with a knife given to her by the owner's son. Still, many customers were cruel to her (she has a slight limp) and angered that she would not bed them. This leads her to believe all men are cruel and untrustworthy. Her instense fear of sex, even when passion is overwhelming her, is over the top.
Matt reacts as if her fear is a rejection of him and leaves in anger to go sleep in the barn on several occasions. (God forbid he just sleep with her and let he slowly acclimatize herself to him.) This causes a lot of tension in the home where Matt takes his temper out on everyone.
When selling his mustangs to the army, one of them recognizes Izzy from the tavern and disparages her infront of the family and the army’s other representatives. Matt is enraged by this and at the man's treatment of one of his horses. A fight ensues and Matt, although badly beaten, wins.
Izzy admits she has lied to him since she met him and she is actually an orphan. Her life long dream has been a family. Although Matt has been brutally beaten and Izzy is a virgin they manage to make love all through the night. One wonders at their tolerance for pain, even when mixed with pleasure.
After that life is good.
Then our enraged army madman comes back to exact revenge for the beating that humiliated him. He's going to rape both Isabelle and Matt's young daughter but Izzy talks him into taking her away instead. He plans to rape, torture and kill her. Matt trails them (he's ex-army) but upon finding them does not have a plan. Shooting him in the back while he's on top of his wife sounded like a good one to me but no...Izzy saves the day. Izzy has burned her hands badly (they are black) but seems to be in little pain and heals quickly. “Fourth degree burns extend through the entire skin and as well as the underlying fat, muscle and bone. The skin will turn black and look charred. Fourth degree burns are the most serious and require immediate medical attention and treatment.Dec 8, 2013” It is one thing to write fiction. It is another to totally ignore facts.
Shortly after this episode, Matt's ex-whore-wife, Grace, shows up and Izzy (shocked that his wife is not dead as she thought) gets in a huff and leaves.
The family follows Izzy to town, Grace and a coffin in tow on the stage. (Why they the didn’t just leave the body for scavengers and send a note and maybe the man’s pistol to the marshal is beyond me.)
And then the kicker happens. The scene that really ruined the book for me. Defying all logic, not to mention threatening his family’s future, instead of giving Grace just enough money to get to the next town, Matt gives Grace ALL the much needed remaining money from the sale of the mustangs. They are divorced. She cheated on him and deserted the children (three of whom may be from affairs). This scene does not show Matt as kind. It shows him as a patsy who puts his ex-wife’s welfare above the welfare of Izzy and he children. Who does that? It clearly states in the book that the money was needed to make it through the winter, add to the farm and start breeding cattle. I thought this was absolutely appalling. I absolutely hate when bad people are rewarded, especially at the expense of others.
The three stars is mainly for the wonderful interactions between Izzy and Matt’s children.