What do you think?
Rate this book
The Ballad of Karla Faye Tucker
On a June night in 1983, twenty-three-year-old Karla Faye Tucker and her boyfriend, fueled by a sinister cocktail of illicit drugs, broke into a Houston apartment. “We were very wired,” Tucker later testified, “and we was looking for something to do.” Though they later claimed they entered the premises with no murderous intent, they ended up slaughtering two people―one a sworn enemy, the other an utter stranger. The weapon: a pickax they found in the apartment.
Fourteen years later, in early 1998, Tucker was facing lethal injection. But after her religious conversion in prison, Texas would be executing a different woman than the one who’d committed the murders. Her change was so dramatic that the most powerful and influential voices in American televangelism―Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell among them―were urging viewers to contact Texas's governor, George W. Bush, and plead for clemency. One follower was author Mark Beaver’s father, a devout Southern Baptist deacon who asked Beaver to put his fledgling literary ambitions to work by composing a letter on his behalf to Governor Bush.
Through a merger of true crime, social history, and memoir, The Ballad of Karla Faye Tucker illustrates how a seemingly distant news story triggers a national reckoning and exposes a growing divide in America’s evangelical community. It’s a tale of how one woman defies all conventions of death row inmates, and her saga serves as an unlikely but fascinating prism for exploring American culture and the limits of forgiveness and transformation. It’s also a deeply personal reflection on how a father’s request leads his son to struggle with who he was raised to be and who he imagines becoming.
Fourteen years later, in early 1998, Tucker was facing lethal injection. But after her religious conversion in prison, Texas would be executing a different woman than the one who’d committed the murders. Her change was so dramatic that the most powerful and influential voices in American televangelism―Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell among them―were urging viewers to contact Texas's governor, George W. Bush, and plead for clemency. One follower was author Mark Beaver’s father, a devout Southern Baptist deacon who asked Beaver to put his fledgling literary ambitions to work by composing a letter on his behalf to Governor Bush.
Through a merger of true crime, social history, and memoir, The Ballad of Karla Faye Tucker illustrates how a seemingly distant news story triggers a national reckoning and exposes a growing divide in America’s evangelical community. It’s a tale of how one woman defies all conventions of death row inmates, and her saga serves as an unlikely but fascinating prism for exploring American culture and the limits of forgiveness and transformation. It’s also a deeply personal reflection on how a father’s request leads his son to struggle with who he was raised to be and who he imagines becoming.
226 pages, Paperback
Published August 10, 2023
32 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
July 30, 2024
A fascinating read? Yes. Hard to classify? Also yes but who cares?
The case of Karla Faye Tucker captivated many in the evangelical community to question capital punishment. Why? What was unique about her case?
The author provides a lot of information to flesh out many issues around the death penalty. Why do some condemned to die garner lots of media attention and others do not? Is redemption and forgiveness possible for even the most brutal and vile crimes? If so, who decides who is worthy? What impact does the death penalty have on each of us? As individuals, collectively?
While much has been written by individuals and groups opposed to the death penalty, they often focus on data showing the ineffectiveness as a deterrent or the arbitrary and often racist nature of sentencing etc. While important, such accounts rarely get at other fundamental questions. Can a person truly change? If they do, should their punishment change as well? What role do the relatives of victims play in such assessments?
Mark Beaver is not making a case against capital punishment per se. He is neither pedantic nor prescriptive in what we should do. What he does is a masterful job in weaving his personal perspective on why many evangelicals rallied to Karla Faye Tucker’s cause.
Key figures such as Pat Robertson, Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker, Jerry Falwell and then Texas governor George W Bush played important roles in the discussion about Tucker’s religious conversion and her punishment. Even the Indigo Girls wrote a song about Tucker. What’s astonishing, in many ways, is that this was not a case of doubt about guilt or a case of a battered woman acting in self defense. Tucker’s crimes were truly heinous and she admits having done exactly what she was charged with. These factors makes her subsequent conversion especially surprising. Can people really change so drastically? Is that harder to believe if you are not Christian with that religion’s concept of redemption? (I realize redemption is not solely Christian but for this case the role of evangelicals was critically important)
Our book club was very fortunate to have Mark attend our discussion and we all agreed (rare!) that Mark’s treatment of this topic was really unique and effective. While some readers may be puzzled by strands of the book that appear tangential on the surface, a careful read reveals that these “asides” help us to reflect more deeply in the many issues around capital punishment.
The case of Karla Faye Tucker captivated many in the evangelical community to question capital punishment. Why? What was unique about her case?
The author provides a lot of information to flesh out many issues around the death penalty. Why do some condemned to die garner lots of media attention and others do not? Is redemption and forgiveness possible for even the most brutal and vile crimes? If so, who decides who is worthy? What impact does the death penalty have on each of us? As individuals, collectively?
While much has been written by individuals and groups opposed to the death penalty, they often focus on data showing the ineffectiveness as a deterrent or the arbitrary and often racist nature of sentencing etc. While important, such accounts rarely get at other fundamental questions. Can a person truly change? If they do, should their punishment change as well? What role do the relatives of victims play in such assessments?
Mark Beaver is not making a case against capital punishment per se. He is neither pedantic nor prescriptive in what we should do. What he does is a masterful job in weaving his personal perspective on why many evangelicals rallied to Karla Faye Tucker’s cause.
Key figures such as Pat Robertson, Jim and Tammy Faye Bakker, Jerry Falwell and then Texas governor George W Bush played important roles in the discussion about Tucker’s religious conversion and her punishment. Even the Indigo Girls wrote a song about Tucker. What’s astonishing, in many ways, is that this was not a case of doubt about guilt or a case of a battered woman acting in self defense. Tucker’s crimes were truly heinous and she admits having done exactly what she was charged with. These factors makes her subsequent conversion especially surprising. Can people really change so drastically? Is that harder to believe if you are not Christian with that religion’s concept of redemption? (I realize redemption is not solely Christian but for this case the role of evangelicals was critically important)
Our book club was very fortunate to have Mark attend our discussion and we all agreed (rare!) that Mark’s treatment of this topic was really unique and effective. While some readers may be puzzled by strands of the book that appear tangential on the surface, a careful read reveals that these “asides” help us to reflect more deeply in the many issues around capital punishment.
January 10, 2024
This isn't the usual type of book I'd pick up to read, but since I enjoyed Mark Beaver's other book, Suburban Gospel, I decided to pick this one up too - and I'm glad I did. This book is well-researched and I love the way Mark Beaver writes; he dives in and out of the story, adding useful tidbits and side stories as necessary in order for the reader to grasp a broader narrative.
While there are some amusing lines here and there, the story isn't a happy one... so fair warning for those going into it blind (like I did). There are also horrible events, described in detail, so if you're squeamish or highly emotionally susceptible, you may want to hold off on reading it (or just read it in little snippets).
Nevertheless, it's a well-written work that deserves a chance. Especially if you like true crime documentaries.
While there are some amusing lines here and there, the story isn't a happy one... so fair warning for those going into it blind (like I did). There are also horrible events, described in detail, so if you're squeamish or highly emotionally susceptible, you may want to hold off on reading it (or just read it in little snippets).
Nevertheless, it's a well-written work that deserves a chance. Especially if you like true crime documentaries.
August 15, 2023
I couldn’t put it down.
With every masterful twist and turn, Mark Beaver weaves a historically- grounded tale of death and heartlessness, religion and renewal, evangelical conflict, and the history of capital punishment, all told through a colorful parade of major and minor players. His reach is broad yet thorough, poking into every corner of this story, including his own surprising connection to it. Extraordinary. A pure pleasure to read— and learn from.
Barbara Rosenblit
With every masterful twist and turn, Mark Beaver weaves a historically- grounded tale of death and heartlessness, religion and renewal, evangelical conflict, and the history of capital punishment, all told through a colorful parade of major and minor players. His reach is broad yet thorough, poking into every corner of this story, including his own surprising connection to it. Extraordinary. A pure pleasure to read— and learn from.
Barbara Rosenblit
September 15, 2023
A wonderfully written book parallelling the author's southern Baptist roots and the rise and fall of Evangelism with a woman who murdered two people in a drug infused rage. Interesting and insightful look at a segment of the population is still with us today as we still struggle with the death penalty's appropriate place in out legal system.
June 5, 2024
“If Jesus spoke Karla’s name, nobody heard his voice.”
October 9, 2023
The story itself is based on true-life events. The delivery of the story is thorough and captivating. I ended up reading the entire book in one afternoon! A brutal murder that shakes the nation and faith, weighing redemption and compassion vs the brutality of the crime. Mark Beaver brilliantly walks you through each character, those that committed the crime, that investigated, that tried them, and ultimately that had to make the life or death decision.
Incredibly well researched and an engaging read.
Incredibly well researched and an engaging read.
February 11, 2025
I didn’t like that the author devoted a large portion of the beginning of the book to tell his own personal life story and mock Christianity. It made him sound narcissistic. Maybe there was a reason for it further along in the book, but I just wasn’t enjoying it enough to find out. I normally like true crime books, even ones that are poorly reviewed. DNF.
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews