In Undoing Suicidism, Alexandre Baril argues that suicidal people are oppressed by what he calls structural suicidism, a hidden oppression that, until now, has been unnamed and under-theorized. Each year, suicidism and its preventionist script and strategies reproduce violence and cause additional harm and death among suicidal people through forms of criminalization, incarceration, discrimination, stigmatization, and pathologization. This is particularly true for marginalized groups experiencing multiple oppressions, including queer, trans, disabled, or Mad people.
Undoing Suicidism questions the belief that the best way to help suicidal people is through the logic of prevention. Alexandre Baril presents the thought-provoking argument that supporting assisted suicide for suicidal people could better prevent unnecessary deaths. Offering a new queercrip model of (assisted) suicide, he invites us to imagine what could happen if we started thinking about (assisted) suicide from an anti-suicidist and intersectional framework.
Baril provides a radical reconceptualization of (assisted) suicide and invaluable reflections for academics, activists, practitioners, and policymakers.
despite agreeing with every point alexandre has made so far, this is chalking up to be one of the most performative books i've ever read
over and again, he repeats every ism in the leftist toolbox, saying we must be wary of classism, racism, colonialism, sizeism, ableism, sexism, cisgenderism, sanism, cognitivism, and it feels so disingenuous
if your analysis is intersectional it will speak for itself
like there are queer women of colour who don't fucking beat around the bush, and when they talk about intersectionality they give examples from their lives, because they live it every day
if you want to be an ally, actually say something meaningful. fuck virtue signalling, your actions should signal enough
my partner made a point that trans men tend to emerge from tumblr, so their need to quality every single statement reflects the toxic space they were in, the sea of leftist cops who will tear you to shreds for not considering every petty intersection pertinent to their lives
and i get it, when you've been through invalidating bullshit you lash out, but also fuck those people, they're vampires who want to tear things down, including their own allies, rather than build things up and actually change the world
and it's like, alexandre, babe, you need to heal, you owe these fuckers nothing, they're the ones who went out of their way to misunderstand you, and it is not up to you to cover every single one of your bases for their sakes
because the consequence is terrible writing and pointless abstractions, when what we need are concrete fucking analyses of the material oppressions we face
and it's a fucking shame because the book begins with a haunting sequence where alexandre talks about his medical bracelet with DO NOT RESUSCITATE engraved on it and i wish he'd just kept writing about his personal experiences
but instead he starts talking about foucault and it all goes downhill from there
because you don't need to talk about governmentalities, and somatechnics, and biopower, to say 'suicidal people are being imprisoned and gaslit and kept alive against their will, and this makes them more suicidal'
like, who are you trying to reach? who are you writing for? do you really think foucault scholars need more material on madness and imprisonment? they've had fifty years of that
no, it's suicidal people that need these thoughts. it's their loved ones who think selfishness is wanting to die, rather than forcing someone to live in agony for their benefit. it's suicide preventioners who don't see the inhuman suffering they cause by surveilling, medicating, imprisoning, and invalidating the experiences of suicide survivors
maybe my anger is misplaced, but i swear to god I've seen the best minds of every generation destroyed by critical theory rot, where instead of elucidating experience, it obfuscates it in a semiotic morass, a vertiginous death spiral of references bereft of vitality and power
how many hours wasted editing a chapter that could have been spent educating and organising? how many students needed their voices heard, stuffed dead on the mantelpiece of academia?
In Undoing Suicidism Baril writes from his lived experience as a queer, trans, and suicidal person, as well as through queer, crip, Mad, biopolitical and affect theoretical frameworks to argue for a new approach to assisted suicide. He argues, controversially, and in opposition to the majority of his colleagues in critical disability, Mad, and critical suicidology movements and academic disciplines, for a suicide-affirmative approach where suicidal people are supported in their choices about life and about death.
He first makes an argument for the existence of suicidism - the systemic oppression of suicidal people - linked to sanism and ableism, but a distinct form of oppression, in which suicidal people are denied certain freedoms (e.g. may be subject to violent police intervention, forced treatment) because they are suicidal. Suicidism means suicidal people are also deemed irrational and thus excluded from speaking about suicide or informing policy ("epistemic injustice").
Our current sucidist responses to suicide and suicide attempts mean that people experiencing suicidality cannot be honest with people in their lives about their suicidality. Alone with these feelings, and afraid of judgement and/or forced intervention, they are more likely to attempt or complete suicide. If they do choose to complete suicide, they are alone when they die. Or, if they are not successful, they may live with grave costs (e.g. long-term physical health impacts, trauma, stigma) related to the unsuccessful attempt.
Many in the critical disability/disability justice and Mad communities see suicide (including medical assistance in dying - MAiD - in cases where death is not reasonably foreseeable) as a permanent solution to temporary, structural problems. But as Baril points out, even if poverty or sanism or ableism or racism, or lack of accessible housing or employment - structural problems - underlie one's desire to die, structural change happens very slowly, and in the meantime, we are asking someone to live based on a better future that may or may not ever manifest. (Affect theorist Lauren Berlant calls this "cruel optimism").
This "injunction to live and to futurity" and "compulsory aliveness," Baril argues, makes the desire to die abnormal and unintelligible, except in select circumstances, such as when someone is disabled, ill, in pain, or old. Here Baril agrees that MAiD where death is not reasonably foreseeable (Track 2 in Canada) as currently conceptualized in jurisdictions where it is available, is ableist and ageist, in that only disabled and old lives are considered acceptable losses, based on the idea that lives involving disability, illness or pain are inherently undesirable - that people living in these conditions are better off dead. (In Foucauldian terms they are "let to die").
Where the book is likely most controversial is that Baril argues that to truly undo suicidism, we would need to establish a positive right for suicidal people (an informed consent model of assisted suicide) not just a negative right (non-interference). He is, however, critical of existing MAiD for mental illness programs in the limited number of jurisdictions where they currently exist, because of their aforementioned ableist premise, as well as the intense gategeeping of these programs, which means in practice, only a minisule number of people can access assisted death with mental illness as the sole underlying reason. Although critical of current MAiD paradigms, Baril does not see working towards a more expansive vision of assisted death, or abolition of oppressive institutions and improved conditions for oppressed groups, as mutually exclusive with making gradual improvements to the current MAiD system in the interim, including improving access for people deemed mentally ill.
In making his argument for assisted death, Baril likens it to harm reduction services for people who use substances. While in an ideal world, we might not want people to use substances that harm them, people will use substances, and we can eliminate many of the harms associated by improving the conditions in which they do them. Similarly, we don't want anyone to die by suicide. But some people will die by suicide even when conditions are ideal, so if they're going to, wouldn't we rather they are supported in the decision making, in preparing for their deaths, and in having a peaceful death, accompanied by people who care about them? Baril notes that although saving lives is not the goal, being able to talk through the decision would likely actually lead more people to feel supported and unashamed, and decide to live after all, even if they continue to experience suicidality.
In the final chapter, Baril details 10 principles for assisted suicide. I appreciated this section, rare in a what is mostly a theory text. It provides a practical thinking through of what assisted death could look like. These principles need to be fleshed out were they actually to become policy. For example, it's unclear to me what level of gatekeeping, exactly, would be involved. Baril mentions that competence could still be assessed (226) but we'd have to re-vamp our currently suicidist understandings of competence, since, as he notes, Mad and suicidal people are frequently seen as irrational. That's obviously a big philosophical and practical undertaking in and of itself.
I had a few quibbles with some minor points of Baril's argument (e.g. contrary to his repeated claims, at least in Canada, where he and I live, you can't access MAiD just for being old), but overall, he's preaching to the choir with me in this book.
As someone who spent 30 years of my life with suicidality as a constant background hum in my life (and sometimes a foreground cacophony), who survived multiple suicide attempts, and who occasionally still gets a whisper of such thoughts and feelings pop up, Baril's work touched me on a deep personal level. He speaks what I think many suicidal people are afraid to because of the intensely reactionary response to admitting suicidal thoughts/feelings. It would be so liberating and de-isolating to be able to talk about the desire for death in present tense without figurative - and sometimes literal - sirens going off. Furthermore, as someone who has lost people to suicide, I wish they had not died alone. I want autonomy and accompaniment in life and in death. I doubt he'd ever read this, but if he does, thank you Alexandre, for this book. I fear you are much ahead of your time, but I hope you are heard.
Edit to add: I would actually say my biggest quibble, as another reviewer points out, is that Baril says in the intro he will write plainly to be accessible, and then, well, it's an academic text full of theory and jargon. It's clearly written and accessible for an academic text, but if you don't have any background in critical theory, good luck. This makes the text inaccessible to the majority of suicidal people, although I am sympathetic to the reality of academic publishing. He can't just write a memoir making the same points and get respected and heard.
You can read Baril's 2020 article in DSQ and get all the arguments of this book in about 5% of the effort. That's my recommendation.
This text is interesting, but largely abstract and unnecessarily dense. There are many other critical sociologists and Mad Justice activists saying these things without all the jargon and repetition. However, Baril discounts much of their work and dismisses it in favor of saying that what he offers is totally new. That tone is off-putting and shows a lack of deep engagement in extant literature. These are interesting ideas, but saying that others aren't doing this work is frankly incorrect. Reviewers should've been on this before publication.
This is a quality academic work on the subject to which I was serendipitously drawn through a favorite youtuber's story highlight.
I must thank the author for putting this intricate work of research and original thought for free readership. Suicidism, as Baril suggests, is a culture which opposes one's will to suicide, silences the suicidal person's voice, forcibly intervenes to stop the person from enacting on their will through a litany of 'help-lines' and 'circles', functions on 'compulsory aliveness' through its injunction to life and futurity thereby completely denying the autonomy of the individual. This culture gets exacerbated as it co-opts with the other -isms like ableism/sanism/sexism/racism/hetereosexualism/cisgenderism/neo-liberalism etc. Baril critiques a huge body of literature around suicide and proposes four models (medical model, public health model, social model and social justice model) through which suicide is normally perceived. He shows how each model in its isolated functioning does not address the complex nature of suicidality and on the contrary exacerbates Suicidism. He critiques even the right to die movements and the medically assisted deaths that a few countries offer. The medically assisted deaths which refrain from calling themselves medically assisted suicides are gate-kept and are firmly rooted in ableism /ageism /sanism where they declare the degree of disposability of these bodies. The culture of disposability is in itself ingrained in a neo liberal capitalist items culture where bodies are valued on the basis of their productivities. Similarly, the right to die movements, even if they recognize the individual will, still work around the principle that suicide is the 'last resort' of a person who has been 'failed' by the society. In the same measure, Baril talks about the over-representation of queer/trans /disabled people in the suicide figures which exacerbate the idea of 'being failed by an oppressive unaccepting society'. This narrative thus erases the other complexities surrounding a queer/ trans/disabled suicidal person. He talks about how the help-lines and other emergency services invade into the suicidal person's agency , often subjecting them to violence, coercion detention and other oppressive somatotechnologies to 'save' them while the individual will is rescinded.
He therefore proposes a holistic model where suicidal people can freely talk about their desire where their narratives are heard and acknowledged, their will and identities respected and they are assisted to build an informed decision, where suicidal people will not be abandoned while treading on perhaps the most difficult trajectory, where they will be with their loved ones or in a space of empathy and compassion. A model that centers on harm reduction both for the suicidal person and the people who care about them.
Baril does not romanticize this idea but offers a very pragmatic solution which he knows will require much more deliberations to implement. The implementation part although comes much later. For that, the culture of Suicidism has to be erased. Undoing Suicidism can possibly lead to saving more lives (though that's not what Baril's goal is) but the suicidal person definitely deserves to be informed and assisted. He talks not just of negative rights (the non intervention of the somatotechnologies) but of positive rights where the state assists suicidal people through a space of compassion.
You may find the arguments, on certain occasions, repetitive but it completely makes sense when Baril keeps on clarifying his position and defining his own situatedness. The book is an important resource and should be read with a receptive mind to grasp its complete potential.
WOW, fantastyczna książka. Naprawdę inspiruje do myślenia i przeanalizowania swoich przekonań. Myślę, że autor dosyć dobrze podzielił książkę na rozdziały/sekcje.
Jedna krytyka, która mi co jakiś czas przychodziła do głowy, to że pisze bardzo złożone zdania, z szykiem przestawnym. Szczególnie jak na aktywistę z dziedziny disability studies, który dużo miejsca w tekście poświęca na zwracanie uwagi problemom z mentalizmem i innymi -izmami. To nie powinno jednak dziwić, bo jak sprawdziłum później Alexandre Baril sporą część swojej kariery akademickiej poświęcił Butler.
Bardzo się cieszę, że trafiłum na tę książkę i tego autora, bo lubię, jak muszę się serio zastanowić, czy się z kimś zgadzam, albo - jeszcze lepiej - żeby autor w trakcie tekstu przekonywał mnie do swojego zdania. A nie często na takie trafiam.
Cieszy mnie też to, bo opisał on kilka z moich pomysłów, które nieudolnie próbowałum przekazać podczas rozmowy kwalifikacyjnej na studia. Myślę, że jeśli do nich wrócę, to będzie łatwiej, mogąc podeprzeć się źródłami.
Książka nie dla każdego, ja musiałum sobie robić wiele przerw w czytaniu, bo temat samobójstwa jest jednak dla mnie momentami trudny i nie zawsze mam przestrzeń, żeby się nad nim akademicko zastanawiać.
Undoing Suicidism is a high-quality book. Baril’s arguments throughout the book on positive rights for suicide are well-structured and well-supported with many different theoretical bases, scholarly literature, grey literature, and experiences of those who are suicidal or have died by suicide. While unable fully reach the level of plain language, Baril does a good job of explaining jargon and complex concepts to those who may be unfamiliar with the field. The book starts with a theoretical introduction that is extremely helpful in understanding the rest of the book, and each portion of the book flows well into the next.
I cannot say that Baril’s book changed my opinion on suicide. However, it’d be dishonest to say I walked away from the book unchanged. The description and discussion of suicidism and its effects, the critiques of current suicide prevention and active rescue compared to the successful, alternative approaches of the Trans Lifeline and DISCHARGED, and the introduction to critical theories with which I was unfamiliar has given me a lot to think about.
As a cisgender, old, white guy, I have no doubt that I come from a different place than Alexandre Baril in Undoing Suicidism: A Trans, Queer, Crip Approach to Rethinking (Assisted) Suicide. I’ve had the honor of sitting on a few diversity panels as an ally. Despite my honest attempts to understand, I recognize that I am falling short. The good news is that my friends – and fellow panelists – are often gentle in nudging me into a more understanding position.
At best, Undoing Suicidism is a cautionary example of how critical theory can go too far—losing sight of material reality in favor of ideological purity. At worst, it is an outright dangerous work that, if taken seriously, could cause real harm by undermining suicide prevention efforts and reinforcing fatalistic narratives among vulnerable individuals. Either way, it is a book that will not—and should not—stand the test of time.
The author proposes that our current support system for suicide is broken. The suicidal aren't likely to discuss their intentions because they will be deemed crazy and irrational, leading to them being locked up and drugged until they comply with agreeing to go on living. This results in people having no one to talk with honestly, leading to more deaths. A replacement system would be accompanying the suicidal and letting them determine if they want to live, or helping them die if they don't. Caution would be needed used to avoid pushing the oppressed to die for malevolent reasons. The book is well thought out, but feels repetitive.
I feel the author is correct, but we'll never find out if it would work because society cares more about optics than results.