I wanted to get to it last week but got delayed. But here it is, 3 of 4 of the Bruce Coville Teacher Alien saga! When we last left off, Bully Duncan got smart and then Peter showed up along with Broxholm to wrap him up in a voyage to space to show Earth is worth saving. This time Peter is our narrator.
We start whee we last left off, but Susan wants to know what Peter has been doing in the few months he's been gone, as he hitched a ride out of here at the end of the first book. With that, we flash back at this story is basically just a mid-quel for most of it. We go back to when he first hitched the ride and what he was up to between books 1 and 2, as well as during and up to the end of book 2. Bruce has said the last two books were meant to be 1 at first but split it up and it does show.
This is basically Part 1 of the finale, and it doesn't have much of a plot. It's mostly about him learning about these aliens and all that, not much in the way of action or the big stuff from the other ones. That's the main thing people could take issue with, it's mostly just exposition.
But honestly, I quite liked it. I tend to not care for more lax stories when done badly but this is a good example of it. We get a lot of world building stuff as we meet various aliens and see a lot of cool tech. The pacing is good as we don't spend too long on certain things. There's only a couple bits I'd say are pure filler here and there.
There's creativity in the descriptions and fun sci-fi ideas. Character wise, Peter works as our narrator as it he again shows how tragic he is. We get why he left Earth but by the end he sees he must vouch for it as well. He strikes a friendship with an alien named Hoo-lan. He's not super deep but it's hinted we'll find out more next time and their whole thing is nice, especially when we get to the end with what goes on.
He plays the teacher role, and the way the title and cover comes in is a bit forced but not a big deal. As for the deeper stuff, we mainly repeat what we got before as they go over how this alien UN is figuring out how to deal with Earth given how it is. They go into our crimes and yeah it's pretty real. I can only imagine what the last book will do as that will have the big debate.
Granted, I have a hard time buying every other alien is amazing in perfect, I mean some have to be some kind of warrior race. Sure, anyone who thinks of possibly genociding a planet isn't super great but in other regards there's none of our problems.
Either way it is interesting stuff. It ends on a solid cliffhanger as we get back to the present. It's the most well rounded of these so far, and I quite enjoyed seeing all these details. The plot may be lax but the rest makes up for it. The other were stronger in their plots but this still worked in a lot of ways.
It's only half of a story, but it's a solid half. Overall, a good setup for our finale of this saga. How will it go down? Are we doomed? Will the teacher flunk the planet? Find out whenever I get to it, which will hopefully be sooner than later.
See ya then. Oh and next random read will be closing out the ripoff series cycle I think.