Lady Fieldhurst is supposed to be mourning her late husband, but all she feels is bored and confined by the lack of Society in London. Her best friend encourages her to remove to Brighton with everyone else, but Julia wishes to go where no one has heard of her scandal. She accepts an invitation to a house party in Yorkshire, but quickly comes to regret her decision. She's been invited not for her company, but to convince the daughter of the house that a London Season is a grand and exciting affair. Julia does not look fondly on her Season or her marriage and refuses to encourage Emma. The other house guests include the local Justice of the Peace Lord Kendall and his family; Mr. Carrington, a nabob; the younger Hollingshead children and a boring clergyman, Mr. Danvers. Mr. Danvers is engaged is writing a history of the village and will bore any listeners with his stories. A rainstorm brings the departed guests back, but Mr. Danvers is nowhere to be found. His charred remains are found among the burned vicarage, a sad tragedy. Julia suspects it was more than lightning that burned the vicarage. She sends for John Pickett to investigate. John can not resist Julia and is eager to help. Can he catch a killer again?
This is another light mystery/light romantic story. It doesn't spoil events of the first book so you can skip that one if you wish. The plot is more engaging than the first book. I could not put the book down until I found out the truth. I never guessed how it would end. I was really surprised even at the moment of truth. I suspected something else entirely though I was right about one secret that comes to light. John and Julia's romance really begins in this story. They tease each other, share secrets and suppositions, and keep each other company. I really like watching the budding romance unfurl. It's all so very sweet! My only complaint is that the story is a bit too long. There are too many characters and it was hard to keep them all straight and remember who was where when.
John is a very nice young man. He's so sweet and innocent. I love his interactions with women. He must be the most innocent man in London! He's such a kind friend to Julia when she needs one most and she relies on him now. She is also very kind and thoughtful and despite her curiosity, she always lets John do the investigating.
New characters include the Hollinghursts. Sir Gerald is an amiable, likable man. He has simple needs and is a loving family man and good landlord. Everyone loves him and it's not hard to see why. His wife, on the other hand, is as aristocratic as they come. Lady Anne, the daughter of an Earl, is not very kind at all. Given her history, she should have been more sympathetic but all she cares about is status. Their eldest daughter Emma is of firm mind. She appears to be an intelligent young lady and knows her own mind. Her younger sister Susannah, is very young and silly. She provides the comic relief and some very sweet moments with John. The Hollinghust heir, Philip, is a dissipated youth who feels he is bullied by his father. We don't get to know him very well, only his actions.
The clergyman, Mr. Danvers and Mr. Merriweather are not fleshed out too much. They both seem nice and Merriweather is intelligent and firm in his principles. However, he doesn't confide in his true love and he suspects her of something horrible which I don't think he should if he truly loves her. (She also suspects him). Perhaps the young lovers would not be so interested in each other if her parents agreed to let them marry. Mr. Danvers may seem boring but he has a good heart and is a clergyman because he has a calling. He appears to do good works and wants to see justice done.
The Hollinghurst servants pretty much round out the cast of characters. They're fairly stereotypical, especially the maid. I don't really get why the housekeeper was so hard on John.
Content: A prostitute friend of John's who tries to proposition him; one maid who tries to seduce John; one kiss.