This was a hard one to rate. I'd say it's a 4.6 for me. I'm going to do my best to keep this vague/spoiler free!
Let's talk about the reasons it's a five star read:
1. The world building and character intermingling is spectacular, and that runs through not only this book, but also through the Shadows of Synd series. Each character is flushed out, and even though they each go through their arcs, the characters stay true to themselves. Each one has a specific voice, and it was very apparent here in Chasing Darkness. I knew when Dante was speaking, vs Grant or Jenkins, and when Aelia was speaking, vs Avery.
2. These characters are easy to root for while also understanding and embracing that each one has flaws and doesn't always say or do the right thing. I had some annoyances with our protagonists (I'll mention below), but overall I could see how life's lessons and their upbringing could mould each one into their behavior and explain their actions and their reactions.
3. The story is engrossing. It's hard to put down because once you start reading, you need to know what's going to happen. This is also a detraction in a very minor way (I'll mention it below), but overall I wanted to know what was going to happen and how they were going to be able to figure out how to achieve their end goal (no spoilers!).
4. The spice is well written and fun!
This is why I almost rated it as a 4 star.
1. I'll start with the most major issue, and this is a personal thing, but we find out they want to do a second auction early enough into the book that for the remaining portion of the story, all I kept thinking about were the people in the pit who were going through what they were going through. I don't want to put spoilers in this review, but I was so distracted by this that I found it hard to be worried about whether our FMC and MMC were going to be able to find a few minutes to spend together or what their plans were because I was too worried about everyone else.
2. There is a lot of inner monologue, and I totally understand the need for it, but every once in a while I found myself skimming past it to get back to the dialogue and the action.
3. Dante could be a hard pill to swallow. Look, I get that not everyone is perfect, but there were a few instances in the book that I had to really try to see his perspective. (Reaaalllly try....) There's one scene where he's right next to her and she gets pretty beat up. I understand the tension and drama that's necessary so we can have that moment of "who hurt you, I will put them in the ground," but if he's standing two feet from her then it's hard to have that moment because all I'm thinking is you did, you giant ding dong.... Beyond that, there's all these threats of I'll kill him for hurting you, but then they keep hurting her. I really liked this FMC, and I felt that I could understand why she was the way she was, even after the first scene where we sort of have to question her motives and her values, and then you see that there are no choices in the life she's living. But Dante seemed to be unfeeling at times I expected more feelings, and then overly emotional when it seemed that logic was the more reasonable response. I do like Dante overall, and I loved his speech to her. I thought it was perfect.
4. This is something that is, again, a personal thing, but if a man (or anyone really) pisses me off, and they laugh over how cute I am when I get mad - they'd better RUN. This seemed like a common theme with Dante and Jag, particularly with Jag and Avery, and I just have a hard time with it. (I'm also significantly older than the characters in the book, so there's that.)
Overall, this book, and the entire series it comes from, is well written, is engaging, the pacing and tone are well done, and I am thrilled and grateful to have been an ARC reader. I can't wait for the next book to come out so I can find out what happens!