“Question authority”: Pin worn by a lot of people in the late sixties, and many people took this invocation to heart
“What the fuck do you even think America is? You think it had the name carved into the fucking bedrock? Nothing about this place is real. It’s all just people.”
On the one hand, The Department of Truth (DoT) is the perfect book for the times we live in, as it speaks to the politics of the time, the media-advanced conspiracy theories that, embraced by more and more extreme right folks, are moving us closer and closer to chaos. On the other hand, DoT in this “history and background’ volume makes it clear that we have always had with us as a human race fictions/lies--some of them useful, as in mythology and some spiritual beliefs--and many of them crazy and self-destructive (such as that climate change is anti-biz socialist myth?) and some just mildly entertaining as such as BigFoot/Yeti and the Loch Ness Monster. Some of them just as ridiculous but maybe more scary such as put forth by the likes of Breitbart and Q-Anon.
We have always had the belief in the supernatural with us, as scholars of, for instance, Japanese Yokai, tulpas, and as the organizers of multiple religions, make clear. We have our share of fictions, our histories, and we have our share of myth-busting projects, from Howard Zinn’s The People’s History of the United States, The X Files and various movies about the supposedly true or supposedly faked moon landing.
The Department of Truth, Volume 3: Free Country collects issues 6-7, 14-17 of the comics series written by James Tynion with art by guest artists Elsa Charretier, Tyler Ross, John J. Pearson, David Romero, Alison Sampson, and Jorge Fornes. The first volume had issues 1-5, the second volume 81-3, so you can see the team is trying to create a better sense of coherence in this ambitious, wide-ranging series.
The focus in this volume is largely on Lee Harvey Oswald’s tenure at the DoT : Oh, you say you saw him killed--as I did--on live network tv?--oh, sure we did! You really think that’s real?! How convenient that they immediately killed the killer Jack Ruby, problem of a criminal investigation solved! I saw it! Or did I?
In this volume we have four basically separate back stories that help deepen and historicize the work of the Department of Truth: UFOS, the moon landing, The Men in Black, and Mothman.
What is the tipping point when mass belief in some lie turns to destruction? When did it happen in Hitler’s Germany? When can it happen here (or in any alt-right extremist location)? Watch what happened to the parents and teachers and administrators of Sandy Hook and tell me we are going to be “all right.” I am sure Uvalde is already experiencing this treatment from the crazy nihilist alt right.
The art in this volume is wonderful, scary, nightmare beautiful, hallucinatory, powerful. The downside of this volume is that it tends to be very expository instead of advancing the overall narrative. But I’m okay with a backstory volume, deepening the world-building. All comics do one or more of those. But it’s not very much story. It’s mostly people talkin’ at ya. Minimal action, wide angle. But still very, very good!
I liked very much the meeting between Lee Harvey Oswald, Frank Capra (the creator of positive visions of America) and Nixon at the White House, talking about how someone as talented as Stanley Kubrick created a plausible fake of the Moon Landing (go ahead, google that, Tynion didn’t make up that theory). Why do that? Go figure: Space race, Nixon needed some feel good news for his tenure as President, and so on.
Who is the Lady in Red?
There are in this volume even more current crazy theories such as put forward by science fiction writer and then purveyor of his own “religion” (Scientology) L Ron Hubbard are sprinkled throughout.
What’s the point? I mean, you do have to believe in something, but you should also question everything you hear and read and think you see. But I do not recommend you read this series about the nature of truth if you are paranoid schizophrenic or have just dropped acid.