2/5
This was my first Andre Norton, and boy was it middling.
It really does have an interesting concept: what if all mythical creatures, and human disappearances are from/go to the same alternate dimension of earth? Cool right? Well, Norton takes that decent start and does nothing much with it at all. Most of the time, she spends time about writing either lots of dialogue or internal monologue between the humans lost in the alternative realm, as they wring their hands about what they can do to save themselves. Little to no effort is put into descriptions of these fantastical places, the action that ensues, or on a decent plot.
Whats worse is the not so subtle subtext of christian allegory. The humans who lose themselves to 'The People" are redeemed, safe, and presumed a part of some greater collective. They gain powers that protect them from the horrors of the world, where those humans who refuse salvation stay and suffer because of their individual sins. Heaven and hell. Bleh.
There's also a weird YA tinge to the whole story, while the emotion and tone change wildly throughout. I did appreciate the mysterious/dream like quality that she was able to imbue the story with, but it's a little to tiny of a consolation prize.
Overall, it's not abhorrent, but it's nothing special either. I have a feeling the memory of this one will slip out of my mind within the next few weeks, hopefully to be replaced by something more deserving.