This book is going to be perhaps the most lethal weapon in the arsenal against the so-far partially successful attempts (thanks to social media) to tout the 20-year Marcos era (January 1966 to February 1986) as a “golden age” in Philippine history. Specifically, JC Punongbayan relentlessly examines every one of 43 claims that have been made regarding that period—from the faintly ridiculous (that Imelda Marcos did not use public funds to build her “bopis” hospitals) to the utterly insane (that nobody was poor during the Marcos regime). And he debunks every one of them with a mountain of data and past studies, all footnoted, referenced, and acknowledged so anyone can check and see for themselves the accuracy of JC’s rebuttals. The joy of it is that he combines seven years of scholarly research with simple, clear, compelling writing. Bravo!
Smart people are just as susceptible to lies and deception as stupid people.
Only quibble for not giving the full rating is because the hard-hitting truths contained here would hardly reach the masses—they are the ones in dire need of illumination. I wish it were written in Filipino, but I understand how challenging that would be explaining economics.
The thing about history is that it leaves me with a starving feeling to know more (giddy feeling of being stuck in the Cebu City Library to borrow books, hehe). So much love for history!
Many of the consequences we experience in our economy, government, and society today can be traced back to events and decisions of the past. They say that we should forget what has already happened and simply move forward—but at what cost? At the cost of repeating the same mistakes? At the cost of romanticizing a past that was never as perfect as we remember it?
JC Punongbayan’s False Nostalgia centers on debunking myths and romanticized narratives surrounding the Marcoses, encouraging readers to examine the past through documented facts rather than nostalgia.
History demands that we remember not because we want to remain angry, but because forgetting can make us vulnerable to believing the same distortions again. If we erase the uncomfortable parts of our history, we also erase the lessons they carry.
The False Nostalgia is a deep-dive into dictator Ferdinand Marcos, Sr’s term as president of the Philippines from 1966 to 1986. JC Punongbayan lists 43 of the most widespread claims about the “Golden Age” during Marcos’ term, and debunks these myths expertly and relentlessly, providing only facts backed by years of evidence from science and data economics.
Having earned his PhD in Economics, Punongbayan says he is very well aware of the limit of using data, especially in nudging people “to think differently about their previously held beliefs,” and so he writes as an academic using scholarly research and intertwines this with a narrative data that keeps me hooked and ready for the next pages ahead.
This book is divided into three parts, and out of the 43 myths that Punongbayan debunked, here’s some of the most important:
1. Only 1 person was executed by the regime – FALSE In 2018, the Human Rights Victims’ Claims Board confirmed that there were 11,103 people who suffered human rights abuses (you can see the breakdown in the book)
2. Marcos added just USD 1 billion to the national debt – FALSE In 1965, the outstanding external debt of the PH is at USD 0.8 billion. But at Marcos’ last full term, this ballooned to USD 26.25 billion.
3. Marcos plundered to protect the economy - FALSE This one is too funny. How anyone could think this way, I have no idea.
At a glance, this book is definitely data-driven and at times, heavy. But I would like to encourage you to keep reading because every number and every word in all these pages are vital in keeping our history, our identity, and the truth alive.
Excellently written, depressing, and utterly haunting.
This book inspired me to immerse myself in learning economics further -- both focused on the topic of Martial Law and outside of it. Punongbayan writes it in a very accessible way; you need not have a comprehensive knowledge of economics to understand how dire the situation was in that moment of Philippine history.
Wonderful writing. Occasionally, the text is written in an economic perspective but it's to be expected given the author's professional background. I would recommend this to friends!
The introduction of this book was a back track or rather a background check of Marcos Jr.’s win as the 17th President of the Republic of the Philippines. Punongbayan elaborated Bongbong Marcos’s family history had made significant impressions of the return of the Marcoses in the highest seat of power since the 1986 People Power Revolution and after their exile in Hawai’i.
Just simply reading and understanding Imelda R. Marcos’ comment in “the Kingmaker”, made so much sense. Imelda herself said that “perception is real, the truth is not”, revealing the prevailing lies of her husband’s Martial law regime and distorting the facts of Martial law after 1986.
On the other hand, the observation of Punongbayan’s research regarding the various surveys before the elections even point out the popularity wise and percentage of winning of then Senator Bongbong Marcos Jr. to win the seat of presidency of May, 2022 National Elections. He noted the visible and useful popularity of the Marcos family could be seen over the years since their return to the Philippines.
Cited chronologically, in 1992, Imelda R. Marcos ran for president but was only placed 5th in the rankings. After her was Jovito Salonga, who wrote the “Presidential Plunder” that goes after the ill-gotten wealth of the Marcoses, he had the 6th place in the presidential race. On the other hand, the only son of the dictator Bongbong Marcos won the seats as representative of Ilocos Norte 2nd district from 1992-1995, Ilocos Norte’s governor from 1998-2007 and as a congressman from 2007-2010. These traces of the political background of Bongbong Marcos Jr. was a similar trace of his father Ferdinand Marcos Sr.’s race to the presidency in 1965. Back then, Marcos Sr. was a member of the House of Representatives (1949–59) and of the Senate (1959–65), serving as Senate president (1963–65). With clear distinction of Bongbong Marcos Jr.’s political campaign especially in social media and the internet, the Marcosian lies once again were used to its maximum extent and has an intent to disrupt the natural discourse of political matters of the country.
Punongbayan also considers the underlying factors that affected the run of the 2022 elections in favor of the Marcos family against the other running candidates like Atty. Leni Gerona Robredo, considered his ‘biggest rival’ since the 2016 President and Vice-presidential elections when Robredo won the seat as Vice-president against him. The power of social media as a new means of political campaigning was the biggest factor in effectiveness until today in another Marcos administration. As noted by Punongbayan, the Marcosian lies have been in the internet for a long period of time, but what is more important is its effectiveness or even so, believable to people who read or share the information about the Marcoses.
Debunking Marcosian lies
The 1st part of the book really captures the behemoth of Marcosian lies & mythmaking swarming on the internet today. To think that Punongbayan arranged these myths according to its topic, depth and is regarded as widely seen online while being corrected upon the discussion of the chapter deserves a raise to debunk these myths.
From the acclaimed “richest country” in Asia during Marcos dictatorship down to the “golden age of agriculture and infrastructure”, it raises the questions of validity & half-baked truths to be perceived as a factual narrative, more so to even be considered as “the true history of Martial law”, according to Marcos loyalists. Therefore, these myths in its function offer the existence of a utopian society, that Martial law is a “compassionate society” as Imelda Marcos described it herself. The strong causation of these lies along with various scholarly sources explains that these myths are programmed propaganda. A weapon of structure that could be used from generation to generation of loyalists or Marcos followers.
However, statistical data and significant effects on the economy begs to disagree with these myths.
Just from the agricultural sector alone, according to Punongbayan, the amount of economic damage of Martial law to rice production and allocation of food resources allowed a massive influx of social unrest among the populace. Such disaster like the famine of Negros in its sugar industry, locally known as “Tiempo Muerto” for Negrenses brought by the large monopoly & capitalist policies of Marcos Sr. himself (especially his cronies) allowed for such “famine” to exist during his term as a president. It is a shame and a big slap to these Marcosian lies while loyalists are disregarding the suffering and economic hardship of Negrenses during the 1980s.
Even more, understanding society through literacy rates and education in order to address certain social issues is another thing to confront, especially in the Philippines where the polarized setting of social media was often used to spread these “golden age” myths, free to roam whenever it is posted, reposted or re-shared online. It is also with a good note that Punongbayan also uses comparative statistical data from various sources to discuss the literacy rate of the Philippines during Martial law.
This perhaps would allow professionals, scholars & experts to take a look and assess the origins of these myths affecting the susceptible sectors of Philippine society. In an instance, delivered through the use of textbooks from basic education down to our primary education, a student finds it difficult to assess or analyze the texts of information regarding Martial law as the textbook lacks context about it. But this alone cannot answer the question of how or why to such extent the loss of critical thinking of our students today allowed these massive use of disinformation materials and alternative narratives to completely eradicate the blatant lies of the dictatorship.
For a point, Punongbayan expressed his concern that Filipinos were continuously fed up with wrong information as time progressed because we were succumbed by these myths, believable enough to make us act blindly in the middle of a social issue.
At that time, the populace weren’t also allowed to think or act freely leaving acts of blind obedience from Filipinos, and as to how this particular Marcosian myth is organized or boasted as the “most literate” country in Asia during Martial law is a complete fallacy.
And instead of improvement for educational institutions, it worsened the crisis of a society that wants to question, disagree or criticize the government for its actions and demand accountability only to be dispersed, jailed or brutally killed immediately by the military. So little yet so fragile that during Marcos years, criticisms against the government were put down as an act of subversion & rebellion. Ultimately, the unquestionable unrest of Filipinos produced mass protests that served as an act of defiance against Martial law.
Philippines, the richest country in Asia during the Martial Law period?
While the 1st part captures the imagery of Marcosian lies, here comes the part where it tackled the economic mismanagement of the Marcos regime. Myths surrounding the economic situation of the country at that time were solely dedicated to the factors that affected the Philippine economy during Martial law. As stated by Punongbayan, it was not the “golden age” for local industries and business competition were even absent or in disarray because of crony capitalism. More so, the debts that were meant for the significant projects, mostly social services, are affected due to massive accumulation of wealth by his cronies. Signature after signature, Marcos Sr.’s policies perpetuated capital flight in the country during the 1980s while splurging so much in irrelevant programs like monumental brutalist infrastructures and massive spending for personal gain. Loan on the other hand, left a traumatic mark in the Philippine economy. In 1983, a debt moratorium was announced because we couldn’t pay our debts anymore, but before that, there was a continuous loan borrowing abroad by the Marcos regime. Meanwhile, it sends an enigmatic or sometimes “nostalgic” message to Filipinos that the period of Martial law is the best period in Philippine history where a lot of infrastructures were built, jobs are sufficient & there is a real development happening in the country. In argument, borrowing isn’t just as bad as we thought, according to Punongbayan, “as long as the budget was justifiable and spent” but this comes in to terms of how much there is to spend and is there a transparency report coming in from Marcos himself or the administration while spending this borrowed loans justifiably? Note that these loans were acquired from international financial institutions like IMF (International Monetary Fund) and government financial institutions (Philippine National Bank & Central Bank; now Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas). Its purpose was for economic alleviation and basic social services like electricity, food & health etc. but only a handful of technocrats that managed these funds or loans got the most of it & was never delivered in the public’s domain. To this day, this comes into practice when such investment was made or a deal somehow with other countries presented yet again as a “promise” by the new Marcos administration, the question is; is there such a thing or secured investment when the world knows what happened during his father’s regime? However, there is so much more than to believe in these myths regarding statistical data pertaining to the Philippine economy, as the Martial law period was considered the “lost decades of development” or economic growth.
Crazy Rich Marcoses
More cunning as they are, the Marcoses weren’t solely responsible for bringing the worst economic crisis that has ever happened in the history of the Philippines. Marcos Sr. himself was devoted to taking down the oligarchy consisting of the old/traditional Philippine elite and wished to eradicate it to “revolutionize” the Philippine society did the inevitable at the time which is to place his own line of partners/friends/families especially the Romualdez’s clan of Imelda. Along the line were the brackets of technocrats and Marcos “cronies”, allowed by the dictator himself to plunge the Philippine economy and the country to its ultimate demise.
These cronies are carefully documented and studied by other scholars like Manapat’s Some are Smarter than Others: The Story of Marcos Crony Capitalism and Presidential Plunder by Jovito Salonga that explained the treasure-like hunt or quest for the ill-gotten wealth accumulated by the Marcoses after they fled to Hawai’i in exile and years later after the democracy was restored.
Punongbayan extensively explained in this last chapter that most of this ill-gotten wealth got into the hands of various associates, technocrats, cronies, businessmen, and even the personal secretary of Mrs. Marcos was found guilty of stealing art pieces & tax fraud, after she received lost art pieces or paintings as a gift for her by Imelda. To put this into question, what is ‘enough’ for a family entrenched in a dynasty? That is so hungry for power, it boasted that they owned practically everything back then in the Philippines. The truth is, while we are paying off their debts since 1986, the massive spending of people’s money by the Marcoses and their cronies was laid waste to their personal agenda/s, interest, extravagance & comfort. Laughable as it may seem, the myths about the “gold bars” of the Marcoses are repeatedly shared online, making people vulnerable to its shining promise to be alleviated from poverty. Deemed crazy enough for others, this is far more believable to most loyalists or followers and apologists of the Marcoses.
What’s in it for the Filipinos?
One of the main goals of this book is to give the people a chance to correct these upright lies in front of their very own gadgets or devices. The enthusiasm of various groups in the Philippines to fight disinformation including the simple verdicts of this book as false, lack of context, misleading or rather has a grain of truth may be the best steps to reach towards a factual historical narrative, studied and even understood by our fellow Filipinos. In contemplating this work, the chapters of this book are a continuous rundown of what the previous generations had endured during the martial law period which would be relevant for years to come. Adjusted with recent times, the swarm of Marcosian lies revolving in the Philippine media today has ultimately led to the creation of a utopian society, a golden past that didn’t exist.
Admittedly, the long road ahead of us will bring forth various challenges to confront the past and to fix the problems that the dictatorship has left in the Philippine society & psyche but no matter how long it may take us to clear the sea of lies, the light of truth will always prevail. Never Again. Never Forget.
Picked this book up because my Economics teacher recommended Punongbayan's work as a crash course on macroeconomics. I finished this book not only with a crash course on basic macroeconomic concepts but also a new perspective on the Marcos dictatorship.
The book excellently synthesizes various sources and statistics on the Philippine economy during the Marcos Sr. administration to explain a simple narrative: the Marcos Sr. era was not a golden age. The main point of this book is that the Philippine economy worsened during his dictatorship largely because of crony capitalism and outright plunder which lead to economic mismanagement. I was hooked at every detail that this book has shown me.
Not only that, but this also made me appreciate Economics as a discipline more. I applied the concepts I learned in school in understanding what's presented in this book about economics during the Marcosian rule. In turn, it made me understand more the economic concepts I'm currently learning.
I can't help but think how lucky I am to have read and appreciated this book (I borrowed it from my school library). Paano kaya 'yung mga ordinaryong Pilipino na hindi nagbabasa ng mga libro? Paano kaya nila matututuhan ang narito sa librong ito? I appreciate Punongbayan's efforts to spread awareness and fight the disinformation related to the Marcos dictatorship, but I wish for a more accessible version of this book readily available to the ordinary Filipino. Not all Filipinos are inclined to pick up any book.
Overall, it's one of the books that left a huge impact on me. If you haven't read this book, why?
I knew the Marcoses were such diabolical and heartless people but reading about the extent of their atrocities was just incredibly disheartening. I was shocked, furious, and depressed. I hope more Filipinos will wake up and realize the power resides in the people and that we have the power to hold the Marcoses to account.
The saddest takeaway I can get from the book are two things:
1. Marcos Sr.'s downfall might have been more to do when he and his cronies can no longer get any aid or loans from the international bodies they leeched off from for decades and not so much the bloodless revolution that the People Power movement was renowned for.
2. As good as the book is, I doubt this has any sway into the actual people who cling to the myths and stories surrounding the Marcos regime. There are times when it feels like reading a hybrid of history and economic textbooks - what chance does this have against a generation of people who get their information from the age of social media?
Actual rating: 4.5 stars. A must-read book. While I wish the style of certain parts of the book were more accessible to the masses, this is a very well-researched and educational book, with each myth dissected in this book's chapters. I wish a Filipino version (in layman's terms) of this could be made someday so that we would truly reach the target loyalists/misinformed Filipinos more.
My initial impression of the title of this book was that it would come off as too condescending. Do we really need to use the language of "debunking" and "dunking" to try and convince the masses that disinformation is real? Instead, I am wholly thankful that Dr. Punongbayan makes an incredible effort to do the opposite: work through these golden era myths patiently and then provide appropriate and grounded context for understanding what happened during martial law.
From an argument deconstruction perspective, I think that the book is excellent in separating the "value judgment" claims from the "factual" claims behind these myths. It is a very difficult balance to simultaneously unpack these assumptions and provide the cleanest representation of the truth. Furthermore, while there are portions of the book that forward sometimes an overly simplistic criticism against debt-driven economic growth, this shouldn't take away from the way in which this book masterfully unpacks concepts like inflation, currency exchange, and bailouts on terms that are sufficient enough to explain the sheer amount of economic mismanagement that happened during this time, which is the purpose of this book.
Having said this, by no means is this book a catch-all for everything on the Marcos regime. It doesn't claim to be authoritative and final in its overview. Instead, it serves as the best introductory compiling research material I have read on the Marcos regime so far, and the hope is that this book can encourage its readers to also learn more about history in a more nuanced lens. So many interesting stories that I never learned in school before!
It has been a long time since I wrote a book review but here I am now. This book is important as it is so understandable, I need not use extra sheets of paper in writing down notes because the information that this book bestows on the reader is digestible. Professor Punongbayan digs deep into the truth of the Philippine Economy under the Marcos regime that it is astounding to have first hand accounts of the documents of the era. To the reader of this review, if you happen to be reading the reviews of this book, please do read this book because it is so important now.
An essential book in these dark times of disinformation and misinformation. My only gripe is the heavy economic jargon (which is understandable given that the author is an economist and most of the atrocities of the Marcoses were related to the economy) which poses a problem if the goal is to disseminate the vast trove of information in this book to the general public. Still, a commendable effort and an eye-opener. I was already angry but I got angrier.
An essential read for every single Filipino out there and I great reminder to today's generation of the past, how it influenced our lives today, and how we can still fix the future to prevent it from happening again. I hope this will serve as a reference when we combat the Marcos myth disinformation because it is an unfortunate cancer that has spread for decades now. Never forget, never again.
very good read. I though I already knew a lot but this book made me realize how little I know during that time in PH history.
if I need to criticize something, it would be that nonfiction books can also be fun to read. This book though is tough to read, in the sense that it kept me want to go to sleep.
This is a brilliant weapon for us myth-busters. I will review this book before I go to a gathering with friends and relatives who support and defend the Marcoses, just in case I’ll see an opening to defeat lies with facts!
A great read dispelling a lot of myths propped up over the years. A minute point though is that the author tends to fall into anecdotes that made the same myths thrive. But he is able to build the case even prior to those episodes.
Before reading this, I know na maraming ninakaw ang mga Marcos sa bansa. But after reading this book, mas nakakagalit pala. Hindi lang basta galit kundi suklam. Hindi ko pala talaga alam kung gaano yung extent nang pagnanakaw nila pero ipinaintindi sa akin iyon ng book na ito.
Hindi pa ako gaanong kabihasa na magbasa ng non-fiction books pero madali kong nabasa itong libro. Interesting ang pagkakasulat, hindi boring. Kung tutuusin halos ayokong pigilan ang pagbabasa nito.
This book should be a required reading in school. I hope there is a book like this but for DDS claims naman.