The 1973 U.S. Supreme Court decision that legalized abortion was one of the most stunning and far-reaching decisions the high court ever made. This fascinating and important book re-creates the case that prompted the decision . . . and shows the difference it has made in American life since.
The story of Roe V Wade, the court case, told from a pro-choice perspective. I was struck by how unprepared those arguing against legal abortion were – the first time Roe was argued before the Supreme Court, assistant prosecutor Floyd made a stupid, sexist joke aimed at the two women lawyers. He then failed to answer any of the court's questions about fetal development or statistics on abortion. Flowers, who argued in the second court appearance, was even worse – according to the book, he didn't even prepare an outline for what he was going to say in his opening statements. He didn't know the date that abortion was made illegal in Texas, he knew nothing about fetal development, and he stumbled through his arguments. It is sad that the state in such a poor job in countering the arguments Weddington and Coffee put forth. Even though the judges have probably made up their minds before the court case even happened, I can't help but wonder if better counsel would've led to a different outcome. The court transcripts are painful to read.
This book changed my mind on the issue, solidifying my previous lukewarm support of choice into a full-blown hardcore choice supporter. In America, it boils down to a legal matter of privacy and fundamental rights, not a moral philosophical issue of life and death. Read the book and try to change my mind.
Detailed history of the Roe v Wade case. The book is written from a pro choice viewpoint. In depth discussions on the legal, historical, political, and ethical issues regarding abortion. A core concept is the debate regarding women making an independent morally responsible decision regarding their pregnancy.