Last year, I was on the fence about whether to start this series. I love the setting as we vacation in Maine frequently (albeit in the lakes region, not the coast) and I love food. The 1st set of reviews weren't what I would call, warm and fuzzy. A solid series start but definitely not as warm as some of the other cozy series out there.
That being said, I got the 1st one out of the library and liked it well enough. When I had the chance to get the 2nd one via NetGalley, I was all over it. I have to say, Barbara Ross is a good writer. She writes better than a lot of the other published cozy authors out there.
I do agree with some of the reviewers that the timeframe back and forth was a bit choppy and it wasn't necessary. I have been reading a few books (non-cozies too) that do the lookback to another month or year or whatnot and I have to say, many of them don't do it well. Here is no exception. I don't think the story gains anything with this. If anything, the segue way between the time periods wasn't done well and was too abrupt for my taste.
Julia is a likeable enough charater, a little on the arrogant side given that she knows she's headed back to NYC. There is no way she could 'possibly' want to stay in Busman's Harbor. Even for love. If I were Chris, I probably would've dumped her. You could tell, from the way she acted, she wasn't 100% committed to him. She seems to always be thinking of her life being somewhere else and not where she currently is. And she spent way too much time in this book mooning over what to do. Or speculating on why her family doesn't like Chris instead of either 1, ignoring them or 2, asking them why. She just hems and haws and it dragged on lot longer in this book than it should have. The book could've been about 50 pages shorter without all of this back and forth drivel.
I also wasn't a fan of incorporating the history of Busman's Harbor in the book. Maybe I'm beyond the point where I want to know more about the area's origins. To me, it felt a lot like school and it went on for pages and pages (I'm not dumb or unintelligent. I have a fairly serious job so in my off hours, I like to read fun stuff, not history).
The mystery was well thought out and put together and there was a surprise twist at the end exactly when you thought things were settled. I did enjoy that because I was feeling a little letdown with the way it was going to end, a little too predictable.
I don't love the supporting characters. Julia's mother is a wet noodle with no real place in the story, her brother in law Sonny is a total ass, no really, he's a total ass, and her sister is content to sit around and follow Sonny adoringly. Gus is ok and he runs his diner the way he wants but he seems to forget, as do most people who live in vacation areas (even the one where I go) that our money helps keep your town alive. Our money enables you to have a decent school system and road repairs and all those other things that non-vacation towns in Maine don't have. Remember that. I'm curious whether the author feels the same way as her character or if she feels that she needs at least one stereotypical character in the book that doesn't like people from 'away.'
Overall, it was a good mystery but there might not be enough, as I'm writing this, to make me want to keep reading and trying to like these characters.