Preface: I do really enjoy Jojo’s and am enjoying P4. However, for the sake of objective reviewing, I gotta be sincere in how I engage with it. When I read it as a complete story, it really lags. 130 chapters into a 170 chapter story, and the main cast has had one meaningful interaction with the bad guy. I’ll call Reimi a meaningful plot progression in the mystery of Kira. I think saying Jojo’s, when graded on the scale of a complete story without wasted pages, is subpar at best is a valid criticism.
As a pulpy, 70’s weekly villain-romp comic, Jojo’s is among the greatest of all time. Uncanny Tales, Eerie’s Weird, and Forbidden Worlds could not fathom the sharp, creative short stories that Araki weaves. When I grade Jojo on that scale, it’s a legitimate 1 of 1, a story that could not even be imitated by the highest caliber of writers.
Excuse my waxing on how I engage with Jojo’s. My enjoyment is great but still riddled with flashes of “what’s the point of this nonsense?”
I Am An Alien is one of those peaks of Jojo’s. If there’s gambling involved, there’s a Joestar in the plot and it’s gonna be phenomenal. Rohan and Josuke are a tremendous duo together, and I loved this chunk.
Highway Go Go was the best bad Jojo story yet for me. It takes too long with like 5 chapters of Josuke on a bike, repeats itself over and over with Shining Diamond’s destroy-rebuild scenes, and has one of the lamest Stands yet. However, Act Three’s “Let’s kill da hoe! Beeetch!” is an ALL-TIMER that I have to thank Highway Go Go for. The first destroy-rebuild of the bike was sick, and so was Josuke’s revival in the hospital. Best and worst short story yet.
Cats Love Yoshikage Kira is a really fun one, but again just feels long. 2 chapters of intro, 3 chapters of Kira standing off with the plant, 1 chapter where there’s literally zero payoff for all of it with Kira’s son. End with the intro to a new arc and character in a cell tower.
20 chapters and absolutely zero plot progression. Wouldn’t mind if all the stories hit, but this volume didn’t.