What do you think?
Rate this book
Logic of Demons #2
Breaking the Devil's Heart
Praise for Breaking the Devil's Heart...It will linger long in your thoughts and force you to look at life (and the afterlife) from a different perspective. I must say the book is unique and something I have not read before. Hell as a corporate bureaucratic institution… brilliant.-Fantasy Book ReviewA thoughtful spin of faith and the nature of good and evil, Breaking the Devil's Heart is a strongly recommended pick for fantasy fiction collections.-Midwest Book ReviewYou’ll just have to read it to believe it.-Rabid ReadsTo say that this book is one of a kind, is an understatement. Breaking The Devil’s Heart, is such a unique, imaginative and thought provoking premise for a story, that it is difficult to know where to start. For a fantasy enthusiast, be prepared to be blown away by this story and to have all your preconceived ideas about Heaven, Hell and the afterlife shattered.-Fiction Books UKIt was a fabulous book that I absolutely couldn't put down... Breaking the Devil's Heart is unlike any other book I've read before. It has a unique plot and plenty of action to keep readers turning pages all day (or night) long. I absolutely could not put this book down. I recommend this to anyone simply looking for a fantastic new world to step into.-The BookshelfPerfect for anyone who wants to read about how different the afterlife could be.-SF Book ReviewsI thoroughly loved Breaking the Devil's Heart. Yes, that's right. I loved this book. Breaking the Devil's Heart is one of the most unique, exciting, and thought-provoking books I've read in awhile. It's equal parts action and heart and would be fabulous on the big screen. I highly recommend you dive into this world!-Shooting Stars Magazine Want to read something unique, compelling, and thought provoking? I recommend picking up a copy of Breaking The Devil’s Heart, you won't be disappointed! H.A. Goodman, I am definitely looking forward to the next installment in the Logic of Demon's series!-Moonlight Gleam’s Bookshelf
- GenresFantasy
352 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 5, 2012
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews
October 10, 2012
Book Info: Genre: Fantasy
Reading Level: Adult
Recommended for: those who question and seek, those with ideas rather than beliefs
Disclosure: I received a free copy from the author in exchange for an honest review.
Synopsis: When Stewart and Layla recruit a demon to spy on the Devil, their decision takes them on whirlwind ride through the afterlife. Journey alongside this young couple in H. A. Goodman’s new novel, Breaking the Devil’s Heart, and join forces with a teenage Angel outcast to bankrupt Satan's underground Company and save Heaven from civil war. H. A. Goodman's Breaking the Devil’s Heart is a rollercoaster afterlife experience that tests a young couple's love, their grasp on reality, and the essence of human nature. What happens when Stewart and Layla tour Hell’s Marketing Department and Stock Exchange? What happens when their relationship is tested by Satan? This book is unlike anything you’ve ever read, or ever thought the afterlife might be like. Breaking the Devil’s Heart is an enlightening look into an alternate world, a new afterlife, and a profound journey inside the human conscience
My Thoughts: This is actually the second book in the Logic of Demons series, after Logic of Demons, but the author recommends reading it first.
I have to admit that the idea of Hell being a bureaucracy appeals to me at a deep level. The low-level drudgery not only appeals to the absurdist in me, but actually makes more sense than hellfire and brimstone. I’m sure more office drones would agree that some hellfire and brimstone would be a relief compared to some of the long days at work. I also liked the idea of the Observers, or (as Stewart sometimes calls himself) naughty Angels.
The author really delves deeply into human behavior, often turning a quite unflattering spotlight upon our preconceptions. One demon says something that really sums up The Formula perfectly: “Think about it: it's easier to shoot up a McDonalds (sic) than it is to feed starving people in some remote part of the globe. With one pull of a trigger or one too many glasses of cognac behind the wheel, unspeakable damage can occur. But tremendous goodness and altruism takes a great deal more work and far more effort. The system is skewed in one direction – ours.” Yet Stewart and Layla just can’t seem to get past their somewhat naïve idealism that humans are essentially good.
There are some great twists toward the end, but I don’t want to spoil those for you. This is a fairly quirky story, but very deep and delving into the darkest corners of the human psyche. With this book it is hard to say who will like it – I think I can pretty safely say that most agnostics will like it, most people who have questions about the afterlife, those people who have ideas instead of beliefs. There are some parts that are quite funny, especially to someone like me who finds the whole idea sort of absurd and amusing, but the overall book is fairly serious. I enjoyed it, and I recommend it.
Reading Level: Adult
Recommended for: those who question and seek, those with ideas rather than beliefs
Disclosure: I received a free copy from the author in exchange for an honest review.
Synopsis: When Stewart and Layla recruit a demon to spy on the Devil, their decision takes them on whirlwind ride through the afterlife. Journey alongside this young couple in H. A. Goodman’s new novel, Breaking the Devil’s Heart, and join forces with a teenage Angel outcast to bankrupt Satan's underground Company and save Heaven from civil war. H. A. Goodman's Breaking the Devil’s Heart is a rollercoaster afterlife experience that tests a young couple's love, their grasp on reality, and the essence of human nature. What happens when Stewart and Layla tour Hell’s Marketing Department and Stock Exchange? What happens when their relationship is tested by Satan? This book is unlike anything you’ve ever read, or ever thought the afterlife might be like. Breaking the Devil’s Heart is an enlightening look into an alternate world, a new afterlife, and a profound journey inside the human conscience
My Thoughts: This is actually the second book in the Logic of Demons series, after Logic of Demons, but the author recommends reading it first.
I have to admit that the idea of Hell being a bureaucracy appeals to me at a deep level. The low-level drudgery not only appeals to the absurdist in me, but actually makes more sense than hellfire and brimstone. I’m sure more office drones would agree that some hellfire and brimstone would be a relief compared to some of the long days at work. I also liked the idea of the Observers, or (as Stewart sometimes calls himself) naughty Angels.
The author really delves deeply into human behavior, often turning a quite unflattering spotlight upon our preconceptions. One demon says something that really sums up The Formula perfectly: “Think about it: it's easier to shoot up a McDonalds (sic) than it is to feed starving people in some remote part of the globe. With one pull of a trigger or one too many glasses of cognac behind the wheel, unspeakable damage can occur. But tremendous goodness and altruism takes a great deal more work and far more effort. The system is skewed in one direction – ours.” Yet Stewart and Layla just can’t seem to get past their somewhat naïve idealism that humans are essentially good.
There are some great twists toward the end, but I don’t want to spoil those for you. This is a fairly quirky story, but very deep and delving into the darkest corners of the human psyche. With this book it is hard to say who will like it – I think I can pretty safely say that most agnostics will like it, most people who have questions about the afterlife, those people who have ideas instead of beliefs. There are some parts that are quite funny, especially to someone like me who finds the whole idea sort of absurd and amusing, but the overall book is fairly serious. I enjoyed it, and I recommend it.
July 31, 2012
When the author first wrote me about possibly reviewing this book, I was immediately interested. However, it said it was a Logic of Demons novel and I figured that meant it was part of a series. When I inquired about reading it without having read the first, I was assured this was a stand-alone novel. After finishing the novel, I now understand that the books might be part of a similar universe, but they are able to be read and enjoyed as their own novels. I'm also quite curious to check out Logic of Demons now that I thoroughly loved Breaking the Devil's Heart.
Yes, that's right. I loved this book. I don't normally rate books because it's hard for me to figure out just what number a book falls under. With this, though, I'd happily rate it a 5/5 and tell you to BUY. Buy it now!
Breaking the Devil's Heart is an intellectual, yet exhilarating, ride through the afterlife. Stewart and Layla were wonderful people in their life, but after they suffer a horrific death, they must make a choice: become an Angel or go another route and be an Observer. They both choose the latter as they feel they can more easily fight evil and the Demons that peddle said evil (via the Formula) in the Hell known as The Company. Goodman has created a unique premise for how the afterlife works, basing it on very real premises like the Stock Exchange and a Ponzi Scheme. The Boss, in this case though, is Satan (and Satan is a woman, despite most people depicting a red male with horns and a tail).
Stewart and Layla are in love and they believe in the basic goodness of human nature among others, but their faith is tested in many ways throughout the novel. They come face to face with demons that have done reprehensible things to people while they were living and they even venture into the past to witness crimes against Freedom Riders and even the Jews during the Second World War. Breaking the Devil's Heart is filled with historical and philosophical references, but it never reads like a history book and I believe most readers would easily connect and relate to Stewart and Layla's very human personalities.
It's obvious that Goodman brought in many of his own life experiences to the world he created and it made reading the book that much more interesting. Breaking the Devil's Heart is one of the most unique, exciting, and thought-provoking boks I've read in awhile. It's equal parts action and heart and would be fabulous on the big screen. I highly recommend you dive into this world!
Yes, that's right. I loved this book. I don't normally rate books because it's hard for me to figure out just what number a book falls under. With this, though, I'd happily rate it a 5/5 and tell you to BUY. Buy it now!
Breaking the Devil's Heart is an intellectual, yet exhilarating, ride through the afterlife. Stewart and Layla were wonderful people in their life, but after they suffer a horrific death, they must make a choice: become an Angel or go another route and be an Observer. They both choose the latter as they feel they can more easily fight evil and the Demons that peddle said evil (via the Formula) in the Hell known as The Company. Goodman has created a unique premise for how the afterlife works, basing it on very real premises like the Stock Exchange and a Ponzi Scheme. The Boss, in this case though, is Satan (and Satan is a woman, despite most people depicting a red male with horns and a tail).
Stewart and Layla are in love and they believe in the basic goodness of human nature among others, but their faith is tested in many ways throughout the novel. They come face to face with demons that have done reprehensible things to people while they were living and they even venture into the past to witness crimes against Freedom Riders and even the Jews during the Second World War. Breaking the Devil's Heart is filled with historical and philosophical references, but it never reads like a history book and I believe most readers would easily connect and relate to Stewart and Layla's very human personalities.
It's obvious that Goodman brought in many of his own life experiences to the world he created and it made reading the book that much more interesting. Breaking the Devil's Heart is one of the most unique, exciting, and thought-provoking boks I've read in awhile. It's equal parts action and heart and would be fabulous on the big screen. I highly recommend you dive into this world!
July 5, 2012
A uniquely imaginative read the likes of which I've never read before, Breaking The Devil's Heart is a thought provoking read for the individual reader and would make a great read for any readers group such is its potential for discussion.
The story of two Observers (Stewart and Layla) who, neither angels nor demons but something in between, join forces with both the demon Franklin in the hope of eradicating evil by infiltrating hell (or The Company as it is known) and the flamboyant tattooed angel Adrian whose goal is to find an antidote to evil. Our 'heroes' along the way coming to realise that neither good nor evil are necessarily as straight forward as they might at first seem. Yes, even Heaven is not without its problems in this story of the afterlife.
A difficult novel to review without giving too much away. On one level this is a humorous read in that I loved the idea of hell being the not traditionally depicted pit of fire and brimstone but ....... well, lets just say you'll never think of advertising, call centres or the stock market the same again. And yet on a totally different level the flashbacks to the atrocities carried out by mankind over the decades, many of them very topical, though a very necessary part of the story were very harrowing, the author obviously not afraid of exploring some of humanities most darkest moments.
Peopled by a numerous cast of characters, it is the vulnerability shown by even the 'worst' of them that really appeals to me as anything.
Too many to name let alone discuss, funnily enough it was the demonic somewhat psychotic thoroughly English Franklin that I liked best whilst it was Stuart that I found most intriguing in that I found just how far he would go to justify the outcome of his actions interesting stuff.
My only real criticism. The fact that the narrative did not always flow as well as it perhaps could have done meant that at times the book felt like a chain of events as opposed to a story.
An enjoyable enough read though it was marred for me by the fact that I just couldn't help but feel that there was some underlying agenda that I just wasn't getting.
DISCLAIMER: Read and reviewed on behalf of the author Hal Goodman, I was merely asked for my honest opinion, no financial compensation was asked for nor given.
The story of two Observers (Stewart and Layla) who, neither angels nor demons but something in between, join forces with both the demon Franklin in the hope of eradicating evil by infiltrating hell (or The Company as it is known) and the flamboyant tattooed angel Adrian whose goal is to find an antidote to evil. Our 'heroes' along the way coming to realise that neither good nor evil are necessarily as straight forward as they might at first seem. Yes, even Heaven is not without its problems in this story of the afterlife.
A difficult novel to review without giving too much away. On one level this is a humorous read in that I loved the idea of hell being the not traditionally depicted pit of fire and brimstone but ....... well, lets just say you'll never think of advertising, call centres or the stock market the same again. And yet on a totally different level the flashbacks to the atrocities carried out by mankind over the decades, many of them very topical, though a very necessary part of the story were very harrowing, the author obviously not afraid of exploring some of humanities most darkest moments.
Peopled by a numerous cast of characters, it is the vulnerability shown by even the 'worst' of them that really appeals to me as anything.
Too many to name let alone discuss, funnily enough it was the demonic somewhat psychotic thoroughly English Franklin that I liked best whilst it was Stuart that I found most intriguing in that I found just how far he would go to justify the outcome of his actions interesting stuff.
My only real criticism. The fact that the narrative did not always flow as well as it perhaps could have done meant that at times the book felt like a chain of events as opposed to a story.
An enjoyable enough read though it was marred for me by the fact that I just couldn't help but feel that there was some underlying agenda that I just wasn't getting.
DISCLAIMER: Read and reviewed on behalf of the author Hal Goodman, I was merely asked for my honest opinion, no financial compensation was asked for nor given.
September 25, 2012
An original fantasy concept that promised a lot, but failed to deliver.
When I was sent this book to review, I was warned that it was "a bit wild, out of the ordinary story" and it defiantly delivered on that promise. This original and highly creative production of heaven, hell and the dimensions in between was something that appealed to my fantasy radar.
I did at times enjoy Goodman's concept of Hell being run as a 'company' to reek havoc on people's lives. Eternal punishment on damned souls was having to meet impossible sales targets. The reward for doing well was a short break to torture another soul for fun. I can only assume a representation of the author's opinion of the corporate world as a former Financial Advisor.
The 'formula' these pinstripe suit clad demons was considerably less clear. Possibly due to the intolerably long chapters that appeared to cover very little ground, the concept never really clicked. Inter-mingled with sickening romance scenes between protagonist Stewart and his life long love I failed to grasp what Goodman was trying to say.
The writing style was often very awkward and difficult to read. Stewart's train of thought was erratic at times, and painfully slow at others making it hard to pace as a reader. I have been assured by other reviews the dialogue improves in the second half of the book, yet I failed to pass the half way point.
It is very rare that I fail to finish a book, but after 150 pages I still felt as in the dark as the first chapter. It felt more like an opinion piece on corporate culture and human nature as a whole badly wrapped up as a fantasy novel.
This book does have some saving graces. I did enjoy the quotes that headed each chapter. Angels, Observers and Demons and their dynamics within the after life was an interesting concept, and learning how Stewart came to be within the afterlife, and his noble decision to become an Observer was a sad, but creatively told tale.
What the story really lacked, that would have made me read on was a solid explanation. A clearer description of what the 'formula' was and what Stewart was trying to achieve would have left me possibly wanting to read on to find out how he does it.
On my blog I gave this just 3/10
Love Rie x
When I was sent this book to review, I was warned that it was "a bit wild, out of the ordinary story" and it defiantly delivered on that promise. This original and highly creative production of heaven, hell and the dimensions in between was something that appealed to my fantasy radar.
I did at times enjoy Goodman's concept of Hell being run as a 'company' to reek havoc on people's lives. Eternal punishment on damned souls was having to meet impossible sales targets. The reward for doing well was a short break to torture another soul for fun. I can only assume a representation of the author's opinion of the corporate world as a former Financial Advisor.
The 'formula' these pinstripe suit clad demons was considerably less clear. Possibly due to the intolerably long chapters that appeared to cover very little ground, the concept never really clicked. Inter-mingled with sickening romance scenes between protagonist Stewart and his life long love I failed to grasp what Goodman was trying to say.
The writing style was often very awkward and difficult to read. Stewart's train of thought was erratic at times, and painfully slow at others making it hard to pace as a reader. I have been assured by other reviews the dialogue improves in the second half of the book, yet I failed to pass the half way point.
It is very rare that I fail to finish a book, but after 150 pages I still felt as in the dark as the first chapter. It felt more like an opinion piece on corporate culture and human nature as a whole badly wrapped up as a fantasy novel.
This book does have some saving graces. I did enjoy the quotes that headed each chapter. Angels, Observers and Demons and their dynamics within the after life was an interesting concept, and learning how Stewart came to be within the afterlife, and his noble decision to become an Observer was a sad, but creatively told tale.
What the story really lacked, that would have made me read on was a solid explanation. A clearer description of what the 'formula' was and what Stewart was trying to achieve would have left me possibly wanting to read on to find out how he does it.
On my blog I gave this just 3/10
Love Rie x
July 24, 2012
Synopsis: When Stewart Willoughby was murdered, he wasn’t only surprised to find there was an afterlife but to find out Heaven and Hell aren’t as clean cut as people expect. Heaven seems to be more at war with itself than with the Devil and Hell acts more like a claustrophobic office run by a psychopathic boss with demons dressed in suits. The last thing Stewart planned was to become a vigilante for a secret service type group called the Observers, who are determined to save human souls whether Heaven or Hell agree with their tactics or not. Joining Stewart on his quest to end evil is his girlfriend Layla O’Toole, who’s got a blunt mouth and an attitude to back it up.
Stewart and Layla join forces with Franklin, Demonic Sales Manager for Satan’s army of soul hungry minions, to seek out a way to destroy Satan once and for all. But Stewart soon realizes that trusting demons comes with a price and good and evil aren’t as straight forward as one would think.
Between kidnapping demons for information, dodging attacks from Satan’s misfits, being thrown back in time and being sought after by an all too familiar angel, Stewart and Layla get thrown into an oncoming war with a vengeance. Why is Satan so determined to stop them? Why is Heaven is so silent on the issue? And what will happen to the balance between good and evil if the ultimate depiction of evil is taken out of the equation?
That’s what Stewart would like to know.
If he can survive long enough to find out that is.
Review: John Milton once wrote, “The mind is its own place, and in itself can make a heaven of hell, a hell of heaven,” and there isn’t a quote, I think, that captures the world of Breaking the Devil’s Heart quite so well. A world casted in fantasy and supernatural characters, the book is driven more by the grand idealisms we have as humans and the intimate fears and regrets that can destroy us. A book fraught with action, love, betrayal, pain, and the desperate need to believe in what is right above all else, readers are thrown into a story as thought provoking as it is moving.
As per usual with Goodman, he jumps head long into a massive plot without holding back in his opinions of both religion and society. The cast set to play the roles of teachers as well as villains are richly colorful and incredibly terrifying. There’s also a sense of vulnerability with each of the characters, even with the villains, which is no small feat to accomplish.
One of the big elements that differentiate the second installment in Goodman’s Logic of Demon Series, is the fact that the story is told from the perspective of one character instead of multiple ones. It’s one of the elements I really loved about the book because it gives readers the chance to bond closely with the male lead, Stewart. Stewart approaches his journey with zeal and naiveté, ready to take on whatever comes with a mixture of nerdness and sarcasm. He became my favorite character right off the bat.
There are numerous characters that make an appearance throughout the book so I won’t name them all but each character is developed well with strong and relatable qualities, even the sinister ones of the bunch. Three of my favorites were Franklin, Teddy, and Adrian. Franklin and Ted McNally are demons, each with his own agenda and with a need to prove himself. Franklin is British, polished, and sophisticated. Between worrying about his attire, mocking Stewart every chance he gets, and delivering his own blows to Stewart’s plan, I was either laughing or wanting to take down Franklin myself. It was a love/hate relationship between us. Teddy is way too chipper it’s scary, he’s optimistic, and positive but deep down it’s really just a mask for how unstable he actually is. Adrian is sweet, charismatic, and laid back. I love the way he was portrayed in the book. He isn’t the way a person would normally expect an angel to look like and that made his character even more relatable.
The subject matter is heavy and dark, Goodman isn’t afraid to explore the hard hitting truths a lot of people usually shy away from. The message presented through the book—evil cannot be blamed on an invisible hand as much as on our own actions and we have to learn to take responsibilities for said actions—is a constant through the scenes as the plot progresses. Goodman showcases universal flaws within religion, culture, and individuals. The message is heartbreaking, inspiring, and bold.
One of the aspects I love about the Logic of Demons books is the presentation of Hell as a massive office echoing the craziness of a stock exchange and the mind-numbing boredom that comes with working in one. Also, the fact that demons look and act so human. Heaven isn’t exactly bothering to stop Satan as one would expect and is apparently undergoing some crazy mutiny. The story is engaging from the moment you start reading and is solid.
Even though Goodman’s opinions presented throughout the book aren’t written with a judgmental attitude but painted with history and wisdom, there are moments they can feel a bit repetitive. The dialogue in the second installment flows much better than its predecessor but still has some moments where it comes off feeling awkward and doesn’t fully sit well.
Whatever the flaws though of Breaking the Devil’s Heart, they can be overlooked because the story is authentic and real, the concept is original, and the world is executed well. Underneath the power, the time travel, the supernatural characters, is a heartbeat and a story that will stay with you long after you finish.
Stewart and Layla join forces with Franklin, Demonic Sales Manager for Satan’s army of soul hungry minions, to seek out a way to destroy Satan once and for all. But Stewart soon realizes that trusting demons comes with a price and good and evil aren’t as straight forward as one would think.
Between kidnapping demons for information, dodging attacks from Satan’s misfits, being thrown back in time and being sought after by an all too familiar angel, Stewart and Layla get thrown into an oncoming war with a vengeance. Why is Satan so determined to stop them? Why is Heaven is so silent on the issue? And what will happen to the balance between good and evil if the ultimate depiction of evil is taken out of the equation?
That’s what Stewart would like to know.
If he can survive long enough to find out that is.
Review: John Milton once wrote, “The mind is its own place, and in itself can make a heaven of hell, a hell of heaven,” and there isn’t a quote, I think, that captures the world of Breaking the Devil’s Heart quite so well. A world casted in fantasy and supernatural characters, the book is driven more by the grand idealisms we have as humans and the intimate fears and regrets that can destroy us. A book fraught with action, love, betrayal, pain, and the desperate need to believe in what is right above all else, readers are thrown into a story as thought provoking as it is moving.
As per usual with Goodman, he jumps head long into a massive plot without holding back in his opinions of both religion and society. The cast set to play the roles of teachers as well as villains are richly colorful and incredibly terrifying. There’s also a sense of vulnerability with each of the characters, even with the villains, which is no small feat to accomplish.
One of the big elements that differentiate the second installment in Goodman’s Logic of Demon Series, is the fact that the story is told from the perspective of one character instead of multiple ones. It’s one of the elements I really loved about the book because it gives readers the chance to bond closely with the male lead, Stewart. Stewart approaches his journey with zeal and naiveté, ready to take on whatever comes with a mixture of nerdness and sarcasm. He became my favorite character right off the bat.
There are numerous characters that make an appearance throughout the book so I won’t name them all but each character is developed well with strong and relatable qualities, even the sinister ones of the bunch. Three of my favorites were Franklin, Teddy, and Adrian. Franklin and Ted McNally are demons, each with his own agenda and with a need to prove himself. Franklin is British, polished, and sophisticated. Between worrying about his attire, mocking Stewart every chance he gets, and delivering his own blows to Stewart’s plan, I was either laughing or wanting to take down Franklin myself. It was a love/hate relationship between us. Teddy is way too chipper it’s scary, he’s optimistic, and positive but deep down it’s really just a mask for how unstable he actually is. Adrian is sweet, charismatic, and laid back. I love the way he was portrayed in the book. He isn’t the way a person would normally expect an angel to look like and that made his character even more relatable.
The subject matter is heavy and dark, Goodman isn’t afraid to explore the hard hitting truths a lot of people usually shy away from. The message presented through the book—evil cannot be blamed on an invisible hand as much as on our own actions and we have to learn to take responsibilities for said actions—is a constant through the scenes as the plot progresses. Goodman showcases universal flaws within religion, culture, and individuals. The message is heartbreaking, inspiring, and bold.
One of the aspects I love about the Logic of Demons books is the presentation of Hell as a massive office echoing the craziness of a stock exchange and the mind-numbing boredom that comes with working in one. Also, the fact that demons look and act so human. Heaven isn’t exactly bothering to stop Satan as one would expect and is apparently undergoing some crazy mutiny. The story is engaging from the moment you start reading and is solid.
Even though Goodman’s opinions presented throughout the book aren’t written with a judgmental attitude but painted with history and wisdom, there are moments they can feel a bit repetitive. The dialogue in the second installment flows much better than its predecessor but still has some moments where it comes off feeling awkward and doesn’t fully sit well.
Whatever the flaws though of Breaking the Devil’s Heart, they can be overlooked because the story is authentic and real, the concept is original, and the world is executed well. Underneath the power, the time travel, the supernatural characters, is a heartbeat and a story that will stay with you long after you finish.
July 22, 2012
H.A. Goodman's Breaking the Devil's Heart is a fast-moving urban/contemporary fantasy novel following the exploits of recently deceased 'Observers' (think Angels with more questionable morals) Stewart and Layla as they attempt to overthrow the corporation that is Hell and rid the world of evil. In this almost playful take on humanity's view of the afterlife, Satan has decided souls would be corrupted much more efficiently if Hell were a bureaucratically run company and the demons wore pinstripe suits while attempting to sell humans 'the Formula'.
I firstly have to say a little bit about the context in which I review this book. This is the first fantasy novel (other than the likes of Harry Potter and Twilight) I've read that isn't epic or traditional fantasy. I gave it a go at the author's request and because I was a little curious to see how I would feel about the sub-genre. Keep in mind also that this read has been book-ended by A Storm of Swords and A Feast for Crows - not an enviable position indeed!
The first paragraph of this novel is an absolute winner (as is the opening chapter really) and it is clear from the onset that the novel has an excellent handle on the essentials - humour, wit, a good flow, a great vocabulary and a flowing structure. I was instantly engaged as the story was swiftly set up.
Things then began moving a little too fast for my liking as Goodman wastes no time getting to the crux of the story; Stewart and Layla's quest to figure out how exactly Hell is corrupting humans with their sales of the Formula. In saying that however I must clarify that while we plow right in there, some elements immediately become repetitive and tiring.
My biggest problem with Breaking the Devil's Heart was that it was essentially written like one of my grant applications for funding. Through exposition and dialogue Goodman explains the details, the benefits and the outcomes to every little thing as if it were being presented to a panel for consideration, and they needed everything spelled out explicitly. Rather than letting the reader figure out that Stewart has particular knowledge of abductions and torture from his work at the CIA (which isn't hard), Stewart/Goodman had to give us every detail of his motivations and reasoning, which became very droll and unimaginative. While there was still a lot of passion in the writing, I felt it was quite bare bones and lacked subtlety. It could really benefit from being a lot more organic and from allowing the reader to experience the story, rather than have it being forcefully told to them.
Another frustrating element was how repetitively obtuse and unhelpful all the demons were that Stewart and Layla experienced. Even though every demon claimed they were being completely forthright and clear, it was obvious to all involved that they weren't and that it was a thinly veiled device to keep the story going for longer. Stewart actually said it best in this excerpt:
"I was losing my patience with what seemed to be a never-ending stream of hideous symbolic messages."
Well said Stewart! My only concern is that if the author recognised it through the inner dialogue of a character, why was it allowed to stay that way?
There are some great characters though in Breaking the Devil's Heart. The demons, in particular Franklin and Market Maker, are quite strong and give the story some robustness and some relief from Stewart and Layla's constant altruism.
The concept of the story itself is also quite interesting and well conceived, even though the delivery is hampered by the things I mentioned above.
What I enjoyed the most, which was quite unexpected, was the ethical theory addressed in the book. I studied a variety of religions and ethics in college (including the notion of 'evil') and was surprised by the depth of the material covered and, in fact, the fresh ideas on evil that I had not come across yet - such as identification with a particular cultural group actually creating divisiveness and 'pride' which leads to evil. Goodman has obviously done the research and has a great analytical mind and eye for reasoning. While this is a definite strength in the book, it does however come at the price of the success of the more creative elements.
All in all, I think Breaking the Devil's Heart would be much more suited to a younger audience than myself, and probably for ones who are fans of the sub-genre, rather than die-hards of Brandon Sanderson et. al.
I firstly have to say a little bit about the context in which I review this book. This is the first fantasy novel (other than the likes of Harry Potter and Twilight) I've read that isn't epic or traditional fantasy. I gave it a go at the author's request and because I was a little curious to see how I would feel about the sub-genre. Keep in mind also that this read has been book-ended by A Storm of Swords and A Feast for Crows - not an enviable position indeed!
The first paragraph of this novel is an absolute winner (as is the opening chapter really) and it is clear from the onset that the novel has an excellent handle on the essentials - humour, wit, a good flow, a great vocabulary and a flowing structure. I was instantly engaged as the story was swiftly set up.
Things then began moving a little too fast for my liking as Goodman wastes no time getting to the crux of the story; Stewart and Layla's quest to figure out how exactly Hell is corrupting humans with their sales of the Formula. In saying that however I must clarify that while we plow right in there, some elements immediately become repetitive and tiring.
My biggest problem with Breaking the Devil's Heart was that it was essentially written like one of my grant applications for funding. Through exposition and dialogue Goodman explains the details, the benefits and the outcomes to every little thing as if it were being presented to a panel for consideration, and they needed everything spelled out explicitly. Rather than letting the reader figure out that Stewart has particular knowledge of abductions and torture from his work at the CIA (which isn't hard), Stewart/Goodman had to give us every detail of his motivations and reasoning, which became very droll and unimaginative. While there was still a lot of passion in the writing, I felt it was quite bare bones and lacked subtlety. It could really benefit from being a lot more organic and from allowing the reader to experience the story, rather than have it being forcefully told to them.
Another frustrating element was how repetitively obtuse and unhelpful all the demons were that Stewart and Layla experienced. Even though every demon claimed they were being completely forthright and clear, it was obvious to all involved that they weren't and that it was a thinly veiled device to keep the story going for longer. Stewart actually said it best in this excerpt:
"I was losing my patience with what seemed to be a never-ending stream of hideous symbolic messages."
Well said Stewart! My only concern is that if the author recognised it through the inner dialogue of a character, why was it allowed to stay that way?
There are some great characters though in Breaking the Devil's Heart. The demons, in particular Franklin and Market Maker, are quite strong and give the story some robustness and some relief from Stewart and Layla's constant altruism.
The concept of the story itself is also quite interesting and well conceived, even though the delivery is hampered by the things I mentioned above.
What I enjoyed the most, which was quite unexpected, was the ethical theory addressed in the book. I studied a variety of religions and ethics in college (including the notion of 'evil') and was surprised by the depth of the material covered and, in fact, the fresh ideas on evil that I had not come across yet - such as identification with a particular cultural group actually creating divisiveness and 'pride' which leads to evil. Goodman has obviously done the research and has a great analytical mind and eye for reasoning. While this is a definite strength in the book, it does however come at the price of the success of the more creative elements.
All in all, I think Breaking the Devil's Heart would be much more suited to a younger audience than myself, and probably for ones who are fans of the sub-genre, rather than die-hards of Brandon Sanderson et. al.
October 5, 2012
This is a deeply original novel, in more ways than one. Not only is the plot different, but the writing style and the message behind it are as well.
Let me start with the plot, because this is where the book is particularly strong. The main idea behind it is to make us really think of what good and evil truly mean. We, the readers, are asked to examine our own thoughts as we follow Stewart and his quest to destroy Hell and its “Formula”. This is what makes the book so interesting to read. We are thrown head first into the scenarios and forced to think what we’d do.
Stewart is an interesting character, though at times he comes off a bit too one-dimensional. He seems wholly intent on his objective, so that he doesn’t really read as authentic and real as I would have liked. I wanted to see more hesitation, more of his own demons coming to play.
But it is a good book, with fascinating ideas propelling the story forward. I do recommend it to all lovers of paranormal mysteries and thrillers, and even to those of you who like to read things that are just a bit different.
Let me start with the plot, because this is where the book is particularly strong. The main idea behind it is to make us really think of what good and evil truly mean. We, the readers, are asked to examine our own thoughts as we follow Stewart and his quest to destroy Hell and its “Formula”. This is what makes the book so interesting to read. We are thrown head first into the scenarios and forced to think what we’d do.
Stewart is an interesting character, though at times he comes off a bit too one-dimensional. He seems wholly intent on his objective, so that he doesn’t really read as authentic and real as I would have liked. I wanted to see more hesitation, more of his own demons coming to play.
But it is a good book, with fascinating ideas propelling the story forward. I do recommend it to all lovers of paranormal mysteries and thrillers, and even to those of you who like to read things that are just a bit different.
August 23, 2021
`To say that this book is one of a kind, is an understatement'
`Breaking The Devil's Heart', is such a unique, imaginative and thought provoking premise for a story, that it is difficult to know where to start. There is definitely no formulaic or predictable storyline on offer here!
The action is fast paced, moving at a phenomenal speed, as the two main protagonists, Stewart and Leyla romp around Heaven and Hell, searching for an alternative afterlife, one where Satan has been defeated and Heaven does not have to endure a civil uprising. It is just as well that Hal sticks to a single character narrative and we get the whole story told to us by Stewart, as it would otherwise be all too easy to become lost and confused in this highly energised and exhilarating race against time.
The plot has more twists and turns than enough, as we discover that good and evil are not straightforward concepts, when we are dealing with Heaven and Hell! The lines become very blurred, as Stewart and Leyla discover that, not all bad people are all bad and not all good people are all good!
When a tragic accident sees them depart this human life, we discover that choosing their future direction, becomes as seemingly a difficult decision for them to make, as it had been when they were mortal. Personally, I believe that Stewart and Leyla are the embodiment of any average, living human entity. Trying to be good, `do the right thing' and maintain their belief in the basic goodness and kindness of human nature, whilst all the time vulnerable, having their faith tested to its limits and having to fight the myriad temptations which life and `the little devil on their shoulder' throws at them, on an almost constant basis.
It is therefore not a surprise that the pair can't really decide whether they want to become fully paid up angels, or not. The idea of residing in Hell permanently, doesn't have much real appeal. However, after realising that many of their earthly traits are not so easily left behind or able to be controlled, living forever in Heaven might also have its drawbacks, especially when it seems that there are those who have made it to Utopia, only to be hell-bent on causing trouble and strife from within. The pair begin to feel just as vulnerable in death, as they did in life.
The characters are all complex, seemingly confused by their individual roles in the bigger picture and all posturing for position in the hierarchy of their respective domains. I didn't find that any of them were particularly likeable individuals, even though I could visualise them all only too clearly, so Hal has done a great job on the descriptive writing here.
There is great maturity, passion and perceptiveness in Hal's writing and he freely uses historical, religious and philosophical references to illustrate a point. The book is particularly rich with words, with Hal paying meticulous attention to detail when forming sentences and paragraphs, every one of them having a distinct and definite message, which comes across very strongly in the reading. However, there were a couple of occasions when I felt that he wasn't really connecting with me personally, the reader, in a very fluid or conversational way. Despite the interesting analogies, it began to feel more like a history or philosophy lesson, as the examples of referential material seemed to take over the narrative exponentially and almost became too intellectual for my poor little brain to cope with! Overall, I felt that the reliving of some of the darkest moments of humanity's flawed history and of our seeming ineptitude at not making the same mistakes over and over again, could have been a little more succinctly illustrated.
The humour is there .. heavy and dark, satirical and brooding, yet often just downright funny! .... The concept that Stewart and Leyla are `naughty Angels', is one that I loved and could easily relate to .... The premise that Hell is known as `The Company', with the CEO represented by Satan, who just happens to be female, is thought provoking and quite satirical .... The notion that `The Company' is basically just one huge Stock Market, although the only commodity being traded, is that of the human soul, is downright dark and and full of foreboding. More especially so, when you consider that `The Company' doesn't always need to influence humans about which way to choose to live in the afterlife, as greed and self-preservation is already lending a helping hand in the decision making process right here and now, in real-life time.
Given recent world events and the negative and catastrophic impact which has been wreaked upon ordinary individuals by the institutions so clearly implicated and designated as `Hell' in this story, I can quite see that the trade in human souls would be a very lucrative market indeed, although the question which then arises, is one of ... Can we really blame others for our situation, or is it time to start taking personal responsibility?... If we carry on down this same pathway, what is the future for humanity? and if we were all forced to see the means and consequences of our own demise and passing, would we live our lives any differently? ... There is plenty of pause for thought!
I came away with the distinct impression that Hal was using the book to express some of his own personal frustrations with the Hell that he sees as life here on Earth and the messages that I took away from the experience were:
Man's unceasing and unrelenting inhumanity towards his fellow man
You should choose your friends with care
Hell is possibly what we are living right now, here on Earth
We should stop trying to atone for the past and try to change the future for the better
The book has great potential for a discussion document and would be ideally suited to a group read.
This was compelling and compulsive reading, even for someone like myself, who reads from the fantasy genre sporadically and infrequently. For a fantasy enthusiast, be prepared to be blown away by this story and to have all your preconceived ideas about Heaven, Hell and the afterlife shattered. All other superlatives, such as; honour, respect, determination and even compassion, are all irrelevant and are by far outstripped by that one little word that really matters and can defeat Satan every time .... CONSCIENCE!
"Conscience saves you from regret"
"... and now it was time to create a silver bullet - made from the foundation of the human conscience - that could destroy evil forever"
`Breaking The Devil's Heart', is such a unique, imaginative and thought provoking premise for a story, that it is difficult to know where to start. There is definitely no formulaic or predictable storyline on offer here!
The action is fast paced, moving at a phenomenal speed, as the two main protagonists, Stewart and Leyla romp around Heaven and Hell, searching for an alternative afterlife, one where Satan has been defeated and Heaven does not have to endure a civil uprising. It is just as well that Hal sticks to a single character narrative and we get the whole story told to us by Stewart, as it would otherwise be all too easy to become lost and confused in this highly energised and exhilarating race against time.
The plot has more twists and turns than enough, as we discover that good and evil are not straightforward concepts, when we are dealing with Heaven and Hell! The lines become very blurred, as Stewart and Leyla discover that, not all bad people are all bad and not all good people are all good!
When a tragic accident sees them depart this human life, we discover that choosing their future direction, becomes as seemingly a difficult decision for them to make, as it had been when they were mortal. Personally, I believe that Stewart and Leyla are the embodiment of any average, living human entity. Trying to be good, `do the right thing' and maintain their belief in the basic goodness and kindness of human nature, whilst all the time vulnerable, having their faith tested to its limits and having to fight the myriad temptations which life and `the little devil on their shoulder' throws at them, on an almost constant basis.
It is therefore not a surprise that the pair can't really decide whether they want to become fully paid up angels, or not. The idea of residing in Hell permanently, doesn't have much real appeal. However, after realising that many of their earthly traits are not so easily left behind or able to be controlled, living forever in Heaven might also have its drawbacks, especially when it seems that there are those who have made it to Utopia, only to be hell-bent on causing trouble and strife from within. The pair begin to feel just as vulnerable in death, as they did in life.
The characters are all complex, seemingly confused by their individual roles in the bigger picture and all posturing for position in the hierarchy of their respective domains. I didn't find that any of them were particularly likeable individuals, even though I could visualise them all only too clearly, so Hal has done a great job on the descriptive writing here.
There is great maturity, passion and perceptiveness in Hal's writing and he freely uses historical, religious and philosophical references to illustrate a point. The book is particularly rich with words, with Hal paying meticulous attention to detail when forming sentences and paragraphs, every one of them having a distinct and definite message, which comes across very strongly in the reading. However, there were a couple of occasions when I felt that he wasn't really connecting with me personally, the reader, in a very fluid or conversational way. Despite the interesting analogies, it began to feel more like a history or philosophy lesson, as the examples of referential material seemed to take over the narrative exponentially and almost became too intellectual for my poor little brain to cope with! Overall, I felt that the reliving of some of the darkest moments of humanity's flawed history and of our seeming ineptitude at not making the same mistakes over and over again, could have been a little more succinctly illustrated.
The humour is there .. heavy and dark, satirical and brooding, yet often just downright funny! .... The concept that Stewart and Leyla are `naughty Angels', is one that I loved and could easily relate to .... The premise that Hell is known as `The Company', with the CEO represented by Satan, who just happens to be female, is thought provoking and quite satirical .... The notion that `The Company' is basically just one huge Stock Market, although the only commodity being traded, is that of the human soul, is downright dark and and full of foreboding. More especially so, when you consider that `The Company' doesn't always need to influence humans about which way to choose to live in the afterlife, as greed and self-preservation is already lending a helping hand in the decision making process right here and now, in real-life time.
Given recent world events and the negative and catastrophic impact which has been wreaked upon ordinary individuals by the institutions so clearly implicated and designated as `Hell' in this story, I can quite see that the trade in human souls would be a very lucrative market indeed, although the question which then arises, is one of ... Can we really blame others for our situation, or is it time to start taking personal responsibility?... If we carry on down this same pathway, what is the future for humanity? and if we were all forced to see the means and consequences of our own demise and passing, would we live our lives any differently? ... There is plenty of pause for thought!
I came away with the distinct impression that Hal was using the book to express some of his own personal frustrations with the Hell that he sees as life here on Earth and the messages that I took away from the experience were:
Man's unceasing and unrelenting inhumanity towards his fellow man
You should choose your friends with care
Hell is possibly what we are living right now, here on Earth
We should stop trying to atone for the past and try to change the future for the better
The book has great potential for a discussion document and would be ideally suited to a group read.
This was compelling and compulsive reading, even for someone like myself, who reads from the fantasy genre sporadically and infrequently. For a fantasy enthusiast, be prepared to be blown away by this story and to have all your preconceived ideas about Heaven, Hell and the afterlife shattered. All other superlatives, such as; honour, respect, determination and even compassion, are all irrelevant and are by far outstripped by that one little word that really matters and can defeat Satan every time .... CONSCIENCE!
"Conscience saves you from regret"
"... and now it was time to create a silver bullet - made from the foundation of the human conscience - that could destroy evil forever"
August 25, 2012
Stewart and Leyla are Observers, having turned down their chance to become angels. Not because they aren’t good and don’t want to fight evil – far from it. But angels labour under far too many rules and restrictions – they intend to take down Hell by any means necessary.
Hell has restructured, gone are the fiery brimstone pits and halls of the damned – now it’s cubicles, rows and rows of cubicles and officers – a corporate Hell where souls are bought and sold on the trading floor, where demonic telemarketers infect the brains of humanity
And teams of sales demons go to all parts of the world to peddle their Infernal Formula.
For Stewart and Leyla to bring down the Company, they need to find out what this Formula is and how to defeat it, along with the mysterious demonic Ponzi scheme. It’s a task that takes them into the depths of the Company and draws them to witness scenes of human evil – and hope – throughout history as they try to discover what drives humanity to such evil, trying to discover the very nature of evil and, through that, the antidote to it.
But not only are the answers far deeper – and more frightening – than they imagined, but we’re quickly plunged in the middle of plots within plots and a conspiracy far more cunning than I ever imagined.
This book is fascinating in so many ways, in particular in the way it makes you think.
Layla and Stewart’s quest to bring down The Company and end evil altogether leads them through scenario after scenario that truly does explore the nature of good and evil. We have some truly excellent consideration of the effect of time and place and culture on evil, raising uncomfortable questions about whether we, if we were brought up at that time, in that place, would commit the atrocities that so shock us through history. It raises nuanced and detailed questions about our white washed views of history – how the atrocities of our enemies often stand up starkly in our memories, but the atrocities we have committed, our culture and our society has inflicted, are so often justified, excused or brushed over as somehow less damaging and less atrocious.
It also has a deeply unflinching examination of the atrocities of the past. It’s graphic and it’s often disturbing – but if you’re going to examine human history, a history filled with war and torture and genocide and hatred, it should be graphic and disturbing. Not being graphic and disturbing is to ignore just how graphic and disturbing history actually is.
It’s also fascinating to see how this book examines the role of culture – and intolerance of other cultures – as the foundation of evil behind so much genocide. It has a very telling line about the only way to stop it is to “make apple pie taste bad” as generations of people fight, kill and slaughter in the name of their own cultural symbols. A person’s way of life being dominant is more important than someone else’s actual life.
And, of course, it very very powerfully presents the idea that there is absolutely no need for demons to make people do bad things. We see demons urging people to evil, but we see equal – or worse – evil acts perpetuated by people who have no demonic urging at all. From the lowest level selfish crimes to massive scale atrocities – humanity is the source of evil acts and the whole “Ponzi scheme” relies on that
I think it fails a little more on the question of “ends justifies the means”, there’s some attempt to label this as questionable and wrong including pointing at the various ways it leads to evil. But at the same time the protagonists repeatedly engage in “ends justifies the means” behaviour, excusing and using torture when necessary. They may feel guilty and questionable about it afterwards, before or during, but they still do it and it still pays dividends for them – even as they chant “torture doesn’t give accurate information” they still do it. However, when they do do it is often for emotive and revenge purposes rather than information gathering – I don’t think at any point torture is used to effectively extract information, which is something.
Read More
Hell has restructured, gone are the fiery brimstone pits and halls of the damned – now it’s cubicles, rows and rows of cubicles and officers – a corporate Hell where souls are bought and sold on the trading floor, where demonic telemarketers infect the brains of humanity
And teams of sales demons go to all parts of the world to peddle their Infernal Formula.
For Stewart and Leyla to bring down the Company, they need to find out what this Formula is and how to defeat it, along with the mysterious demonic Ponzi scheme. It’s a task that takes them into the depths of the Company and draws them to witness scenes of human evil – and hope – throughout history as they try to discover what drives humanity to such evil, trying to discover the very nature of evil and, through that, the antidote to it.
But not only are the answers far deeper – and more frightening – than they imagined, but we’re quickly plunged in the middle of plots within plots and a conspiracy far more cunning than I ever imagined.
This book is fascinating in so many ways, in particular in the way it makes you think.
Layla and Stewart’s quest to bring down The Company and end evil altogether leads them through scenario after scenario that truly does explore the nature of good and evil. We have some truly excellent consideration of the effect of time and place and culture on evil, raising uncomfortable questions about whether we, if we were brought up at that time, in that place, would commit the atrocities that so shock us through history. It raises nuanced and detailed questions about our white washed views of history – how the atrocities of our enemies often stand up starkly in our memories, but the atrocities we have committed, our culture and our society has inflicted, are so often justified, excused or brushed over as somehow less damaging and less atrocious.
It also has a deeply unflinching examination of the atrocities of the past. It’s graphic and it’s often disturbing – but if you’re going to examine human history, a history filled with war and torture and genocide and hatred, it should be graphic and disturbing. Not being graphic and disturbing is to ignore just how graphic and disturbing history actually is.
It’s also fascinating to see how this book examines the role of culture – and intolerance of other cultures – as the foundation of evil behind so much genocide. It has a very telling line about the only way to stop it is to “make apple pie taste bad” as generations of people fight, kill and slaughter in the name of their own cultural symbols. A person’s way of life being dominant is more important than someone else’s actual life.
And, of course, it very very powerfully presents the idea that there is absolutely no need for demons to make people do bad things. We see demons urging people to evil, but we see equal – or worse – evil acts perpetuated by people who have no demonic urging at all. From the lowest level selfish crimes to massive scale atrocities – humanity is the source of evil acts and the whole “Ponzi scheme” relies on that
I think it fails a little more on the question of “ends justifies the means”, there’s some attempt to label this as questionable and wrong including pointing at the various ways it leads to evil. But at the same time the protagonists repeatedly engage in “ends justifies the means” behaviour, excusing and using torture when necessary. They may feel guilty and questionable about it afterwards, before or during, but they still do it and it still pays dividends for them – even as they chant “torture doesn’t give accurate information” they still do it. However, when they do do it is often for emotive and revenge purposes rather than information gathering – I don’t think at any point torture is used to effectively extract information, which is something.
Read More
September 15, 2015
When two Observers from heaven try to recruit a demon to spy on Satan, their decision has ramifications that affect not only their own fates in the afterlife but possibly the fates of everyone else in heaven and on earth. Stewart and Layla could have been Angels, but they prefer to work with less uptight rules--hence their roles as Observers, fighting in the war of good vs. evil. They work to infiltrate Hell in order to take down The Company and end evil on earth, but the tactics they use could instead ignite a civil war in Heaven.
I don't really know where to start with this book, except to say that it's really different from anything else I've ever read. It's kind of a blend of fantasy, horror and philosophy, which makes it sounds much more intimidating than it really is; it's not overly long and the pacing is decent, so it's not like you're picking up War and Peace or anything.
That said, I do recommend reading this in chunks. At its core, the novel is about the nature of evil, and how the actions or traits we might justify as "good" can be surprisingly bad when viewed from another angle. I really didn't know what to expect from the philosophical side of the story, but it really makes you rethink your conceptions of good and evil. I think this book is best for someone who's open to mulling over an idea, rather than starting out with a set belief, because it really does take some thinking and digesting. I picked it up and put it down again a few times just because I didn't want to blitz through it without digesting the thoughts and arguments made by the different characters.
If that sounds ponderous, it's really not: it's packaged up with a whirlwind of a story involving two Observers (like Angels, but with more of a morally grey tone) who attempt to infiltrate Hell in order to shut it down once and for all. Goodman presents Hell as a giant corporation, complete with a Stock Exchange that trades in human souls. If you've ever joked about having a soulless job or working in Hell, then you'll appreciate this grim idea of Hell as a never-ending series of sales quotas and deadlines. Our Observers, Stewart and Layla, want to figure out how the demons are selling The Formula, which prompts people to evil, so that they can concoct a counter-potion and put evil out of business.
However, the actions they take have far-reaching ramifications that impact not only their own destinies, but the fates of both the souls on earth and in heaven. There were some good plot twists toward the end of the book that I didn't anticipate, and I felt like the ending was satisfying without being smarmy. I appreciated that the book wasn't pitched directly from the viewpoint of Christianity, atheism, or any other single viewpoint; it's kind of an all-encompassing approach to the moral issue of good vs. evil that asks you to think for yourself instead of pinning everything on a cut-and-paste doctrine.
The only thing that really bugged me about this book, and I suspect might bug other people as well, is the assertion that people gain access to Heaven or Hell based on the number of good or bad deeds they commit during their lifetime. It's an integral part of the plot as it relates to the Stock Exchange in Hell, but it's such an old trope and I think we've all heard it trotted out way too many times in real life to embrace it in a book. Also, just my personal opinion, it seems kind of at odds with the liquid state of good vs. evil. If you do a "good" action for a selfish reason, is it good or bad? If you do a "bad" thing to achieve a better end, is it good or bad? How does this affect the "point balance" (or what have you) that determines where you end up in the afterlife? This is probably a minor sticking point but just one that's been rolling around in my mind since I finished the book.
Overall, if you're looking for something really different to read and want to get a little mental challenge out of your book while you're at it, I recommend giving this title a try. It's creative, original, and thought-provoking, and it's certainly never boring!
I don't really know where to start with this book, except to say that it's really different from anything else I've ever read. It's kind of a blend of fantasy, horror and philosophy, which makes it sounds much more intimidating than it really is; it's not overly long and the pacing is decent, so it's not like you're picking up War and Peace or anything.
That said, I do recommend reading this in chunks. At its core, the novel is about the nature of evil, and how the actions or traits we might justify as "good" can be surprisingly bad when viewed from another angle. I really didn't know what to expect from the philosophical side of the story, but it really makes you rethink your conceptions of good and evil. I think this book is best for someone who's open to mulling over an idea, rather than starting out with a set belief, because it really does take some thinking and digesting. I picked it up and put it down again a few times just because I didn't want to blitz through it without digesting the thoughts and arguments made by the different characters.
If that sounds ponderous, it's really not: it's packaged up with a whirlwind of a story involving two Observers (like Angels, but with more of a morally grey tone) who attempt to infiltrate Hell in order to shut it down once and for all. Goodman presents Hell as a giant corporation, complete with a Stock Exchange that trades in human souls. If you've ever joked about having a soulless job or working in Hell, then you'll appreciate this grim idea of Hell as a never-ending series of sales quotas and deadlines. Our Observers, Stewart and Layla, want to figure out how the demons are selling The Formula, which prompts people to evil, so that they can concoct a counter-potion and put evil out of business.
However, the actions they take have far-reaching ramifications that impact not only their own destinies, but the fates of both the souls on earth and in heaven. There were some good plot twists toward the end of the book that I didn't anticipate, and I felt like the ending was satisfying without being smarmy. I appreciated that the book wasn't pitched directly from the viewpoint of Christianity, atheism, or any other single viewpoint; it's kind of an all-encompassing approach to the moral issue of good vs. evil that asks you to think for yourself instead of pinning everything on a cut-and-paste doctrine.
The only thing that really bugged me about this book, and I suspect might bug other people as well, is the assertion that people gain access to Heaven or Hell based on the number of good or bad deeds they commit during their lifetime. It's an integral part of the plot as it relates to the Stock Exchange in Hell, but it's such an old trope and I think we've all heard it trotted out way too many times in real life to embrace it in a book. Also, just my personal opinion, it seems kind of at odds with the liquid state of good vs. evil. If you do a "good" action for a selfish reason, is it good or bad? If you do a "bad" thing to achieve a better end, is it good or bad? How does this affect the "point balance" (or what have you) that determines where you end up in the afterlife? This is probably a minor sticking point but just one that's been rolling around in my mind since I finished the book.
Overall, if you're looking for something really different to read and want to get a little mental challenge out of your book while you're at it, I recommend giving this title a try. It's creative, original, and thought-provoking, and it's certainly never boring!
June 17, 2012
When I say this book is original, it’s quite an understatement. H.A. Goodman has recreated the afterlife as we know it in Breaking the Devil’s Heart. It’s so unique, I had a hard time picking a genre for it, since it doesn’t fit nicely into any category. While it does have some romantic elements, I wouldn’t consider it a paranormal romance. It’s not an urban fantasy either. It’s literally a book about life after death and trying to eliminate all evil from the world and the underworld.
Imagine Hell as a corporate company. Not very hard, I know, but in this book, hell is literally called The Company by everyone who works there (A.K.A. demons). The Company even has its own Stock Exchange and Marketing Department, but its true crowning achievement is the invention of The Formula. Ultimately, demons sell this Formula to unsuspecting human in the real world. Working like a hardcore drug, it has the ability to turn humans into evil beings with tainted souls, which, overall, is good for the Stock Exchange of The Company.
The protagonist of the story, Stewart, isn’t exactly an Angel, nor is he a Demon. He’s an Observer and that enables him to get the best of both worlds. Both him and his Observer girlfriend Layla, have dedicated their afterlives to eradicating evil. Stewart’s main goals in this novel was to infiltrate The Company, find out how The Formula works and put an end to it all. As he infiltrated The Company we were able to learn more and more about the inner working of hell and The Boss’s ultimate goals. Personally, I found the description of hell long and arduous. After lengthy descriptions, I’m still very confused about how The Formula works. There’s nothing tidy and clean cut about this world building but that might have been intentional since it does leave an air of mystery to the underworld. Somewhere in the grand tour of hell, the author lost me in the whirlwind of scene changes and fragmentary explanations of The Formula.
One thing I did enjoy were the flashbacks on humanity’s darkest moments where we met men and women that came out shinning with compassion and honor. It made me see the good in humanity and made me realize how much we can learn from history, in order to prevent the repetition of our errors. The idea of blaming genocides and wars on The Formula gave Stewart some hope in finding a cure to this “drug”. His quest sometimes felt overwhelming but you kept cheering him on because of the awful (and wonderful) historical characters that we met.
I wanted to love this book. I really did. I did end up enjoying it, however with some inner reservations. I think is was a little too philosophical for my tastes. Goodman’s unconventional approach to many topics enable him to breach many subject, like history, sociology, psychology and criminology. His complicated theoretical explanations of good vs. evil were brilliant but personally, I found it lacked some story-telling in between. Although Breaking the Devil’s Heart wasn’t exactly for me, I’m glad I read it because it did make me think about our history and the future of humanity. You can find glowing reviews of the book on the author’s website.
Imagine Hell as a corporate company. Not very hard, I know, but in this book, hell is literally called The Company by everyone who works there (A.K.A. demons). The Company even has its own Stock Exchange and Marketing Department, but its true crowning achievement is the invention of The Formula. Ultimately, demons sell this Formula to unsuspecting human in the real world. Working like a hardcore drug, it has the ability to turn humans into evil beings with tainted souls, which, overall, is good for the Stock Exchange of The Company.
The protagonist of the story, Stewart, isn’t exactly an Angel, nor is he a Demon. He’s an Observer and that enables him to get the best of both worlds. Both him and his Observer girlfriend Layla, have dedicated their afterlives to eradicating evil. Stewart’s main goals in this novel was to infiltrate The Company, find out how The Formula works and put an end to it all. As he infiltrated The Company we were able to learn more and more about the inner working of hell and The Boss’s ultimate goals. Personally, I found the description of hell long and arduous. After lengthy descriptions, I’m still very confused about how The Formula works. There’s nothing tidy and clean cut about this world building but that might have been intentional since it does leave an air of mystery to the underworld. Somewhere in the grand tour of hell, the author lost me in the whirlwind of scene changes and fragmentary explanations of The Formula.
One thing I did enjoy were the flashbacks on humanity’s darkest moments where we met men and women that came out shinning with compassion and honor. It made me see the good in humanity and made me realize how much we can learn from history, in order to prevent the repetition of our errors. The idea of blaming genocides and wars on The Formula gave Stewart some hope in finding a cure to this “drug”. His quest sometimes felt overwhelming but you kept cheering him on because of the awful (and wonderful) historical characters that we met.
I wanted to love this book. I really did. I did end up enjoying it, however with some inner reservations. I think is was a little too philosophical for my tastes. Goodman’s unconventional approach to many topics enable him to breach many subject, like history, sociology, psychology and criminology. His complicated theoretical explanations of good vs. evil were brilliant but personally, I found it lacked some story-telling in between. Although Breaking the Devil’s Heart wasn’t exactly for me, I’m glad I read it because it did make me think about our history and the future of humanity. You can find glowing reviews of the book on the author’s website.
August 31, 2012
This is a sequel to the Logic Of Demons, but the book can be read as a stand-alone. I did not read the first book before diving into this one.
The first thing to stick out to me was the writing. It felt a bit forced at first, as if H.A. Goodman sat with a thesaurus next to him the entire time. However, as the story progressed, I got used to his writing and so it didn’t bother me anymore. The writing was very thorough but did use some cliches and the segments describing romance seemed a bit cheesy. But overall, the writing was decent.
The idea behind the story is the strongest part of the novel. Our protagonists are Observers – potential Angels that have decided to work closer to Satan in order to rid the world of evil instead of spending an eternity in Heaven. I liked how Goodman made the afterlife seem like a seamless pass from life to death, and just how similar the two dimensions are. What is your idea of Hell? How about being an overworked, under-appreciated employee of a corporation? That is Goodman’s idea of Hell, and although the environment does get more intricate, the concept behind it all is very easy to relate to. Some of it felt very tongue in cheek, but I liked it. Demons/Devils should be sly and quick with the tongue – which is exactly what I found.
The biggest theme of the novel is philosophical – what is human nature? Are humans inherently born good or bad? What is the power of persuasion? What is it like to be under the influence of someone or something else? Our protagonists, Stewart and Layla, go on an adventure layered with eggshells through the depths of Hell and the human conscience. The imagination behind the more “Angelic” scenes of the book, in which a character enters another person’s memory or similar, were creative but still felt very philosophical. The methods of transmission are topics that readers could easily discuss.
There are some scenes that are suitable for mature readers because they deal with violence and crimes. Some of the topics are unsettling, but it is key to remember that we are dealing with a story with characters that are in Hell. The reason why a few of them ended up there is slipped out here and there, but some readers may find that uncomfortable. Personally, I found it to really heighten that theme of human nature.
Overall, I liked this book because I felt it did a great job at exploring some philosophical issues for those of us that aren’t too crazy about philosophy in general. The situations are easy to relate to and imagine. Sure, there is a bit of fantasy thrown in, but the book does get you to think. It also deals with the relationship between Stewart and Layla, showing that they are both just regular people caught up in this whirlwind of justice.
This book did not get a 5/5 rating because the writing wasn’t my style (some bits too wordy, some parts cheesy), some parts felt like it dragged, and the plot felt a bit slow in some parts.
The first thing to stick out to me was the writing. It felt a bit forced at first, as if H.A. Goodman sat with a thesaurus next to him the entire time. However, as the story progressed, I got used to his writing and so it didn’t bother me anymore. The writing was very thorough but did use some cliches and the segments describing romance seemed a bit cheesy. But overall, the writing was decent.
The idea behind the story is the strongest part of the novel. Our protagonists are Observers – potential Angels that have decided to work closer to Satan in order to rid the world of evil instead of spending an eternity in Heaven. I liked how Goodman made the afterlife seem like a seamless pass from life to death, and just how similar the two dimensions are. What is your idea of Hell? How about being an overworked, under-appreciated employee of a corporation? That is Goodman’s idea of Hell, and although the environment does get more intricate, the concept behind it all is very easy to relate to. Some of it felt very tongue in cheek, but I liked it. Demons/Devils should be sly and quick with the tongue – which is exactly what I found.
The biggest theme of the novel is philosophical – what is human nature? Are humans inherently born good or bad? What is the power of persuasion? What is it like to be under the influence of someone or something else? Our protagonists, Stewart and Layla, go on an adventure layered with eggshells through the depths of Hell and the human conscience. The imagination behind the more “Angelic” scenes of the book, in which a character enters another person’s memory or similar, were creative but still felt very philosophical. The methods of transmission are topics that readers could easily discuss.
There are some scenes that are suitable for mature readers because they deal with violence and crimes. Some of the topics are unsettling, but it is key to remember that we are dealing with a story with characters that are in Hell. The reason why a few of them ended up there is slipped out here and there, but some readers may find that uncomfortable. Personally, I found it to really heighten that theme of human nature.
Overall, I liked this book because I felt it did a great job at exploring some philosophical issues for those of us that aren’t too crazy about philosophy in general. The situations are easy to relate to and imagine. Sure, there is a bit of fantasy thrown in, but the book does get you to think. It also deals with the relationship between Stewart and Layla, showing that they are both just regular people caught up in this whirlwind of justice.
This book did not get a 5/5 rating because the writing wasn’t my style (some bits too wordy, some parts cheesy), some parts felt like it dragged, and the plot felt a bit slow in some parts.
October 8, 2012
*Genre*
*Rating* 3.0
*Review*
Breaking the Devil’s Heart is a ditty about two Observers – Stewart Willoughby and Layla O’Toole– who turned down the opportunity to become Angels in an attempt to rid the world of evil. The idea is that Demons are peddling a product called The Formula to unsuspecting humans, manipulating them to the dark side of their psyche where they then end up in Hell for the rest of eternity. It’s also a statement on the fact that God appears to be a non-entity when it comes to preventing some of history’s most violent acts of murder and devastation since he basically gave humans free will to do what they please.
The story is told mainly from the POV of Stewart and we get a look at the so called inner workings of Hell from its Marketing Department, and Telemarketing Department to its Stock Market where souls are bought and sold by the acts of the particular human being. It’s a place where Satan is really a female Fallen Angel who controls Hell with an Iron grip.
Stewart and Layla have the ability to travel throughout time and space and visit different planes of existence. Stewart is an interesting character to review. He was a part of the CIA for a time, before becoming a teacher where he met Layla and later was brutally murdered by so called friends. He really believes that there is a way to prevent acts of evil against humans by finding out and exposing the truth behind Hell’s nefarious schemes.
As for Layla, she is probably the most interesting character in that she is given a particular storyline and you have to guess whether or not she's actually who she wants you to believe she is. She is also Stewart's conscious in many ways. I believe Stewart would have been a lot more devious in his attempts at thwarting Hell without Layla around.
Breaking the Devil’s Heart could be considered a philosophical one in that Goodman explores what it means to be human and have free will. Are there really good and evil beings whispering in our ears on a daily basis telling us to do things that go against our very nature? Is Hell really selling a Formula to evil groups to do their bidding and thus gaining more souls? Why hasn’t God or the Angel’s in heaven stood up and fought back against Hell’s minions and attempts to control humanity by planting sweet evil into their ears?
I received this book from the author H.A Goodman in lieu of an honest appraisal and opinion of his work. Breaking the Devils’ Heart is intriguing and you will find yourself debating the ideas behind this book if you are faithful to your religion. I found the idea that there are different faiths in Heaven interesting. The subject matter is also dark at times and really exposes the reality behind the ongoing war between Heaven and Hell for our very souls.
*Rating* 3.0
*Review*
Breaking the Devil’s Heart is a ditty about two Observers – Stewart Willoughby and Layla O’Toole– who turned down the opportunity to become Angels in an attempt to rid the world of evil. The idea is that Demons are peddling a product called The Formula to unsuspecting humans, manipulating them to the dark side of their psyche where they then end up in Hell for the rest of eternity. It’s also a statement on the fact that God appears to be a non-entity when it comes to preventing some of history’s most violent acts of murder and devastation since he basically gave humans free will to do what they please.
The story is told mainly from the POV of Stewart and we get a look at the so called inner workings of Hell from its Marketing Department, and Telemarketing Department to its Stock Market where souls are bought and sold by the acts of the particular human being. It’s a place where Satan is really a female Fallen Angel who controls Hell with an Iron grip.
Stewart and Layla have the ability to travel throughout time and space and visit different planes of existence. Stewart is an interesting character to review. He was a part of the CIA for a time, before becoming a teacher where he met Layla and later was brutally murdered by so called friends. He really believes that there is a way to prevent acts of evil against humans by finding out and exposing the truth behind Hell’s nefarious schemes.
As for Layla, she is probably the most interesting character in that she is given a particular storyline and you have to guess whether or not she's actually who she wants you to believe she is. She is also Stewart's conscious in many ways. I believe Stewart would have been a lot more devious in his attempts at thwarting Hell without Layla around.
Breaking the Devil’s Heart could be considered a philosophical one in that Goodman explores what it means to be human and have free will. Are there really good and evil beings whispering in our ears on a daily basis telling us to do things that go against our very nature? Is Hell really selling a Formula to evil groups to do their bidding and thus gaining more souls? Why hasn’t God or the Angel’s in heaven stood up and fought back against Hell’s minions and attempts to control humanity by planting sweet evil into their ears?
I received this book from the author H.A Goodman in lieu of an honest appraisal and opinion of his work. Breaking the Devils’ Heart is intriguing and you will find yourself debating the ideas behind this book if you are faithful to your religion. I found the idea that there are different faiths in Heaven interesting. The subject matter is also dark at times and really exposes the reality behind the ongoing war between Heaven and Hell for our very souls.
October 7, 2012
Mon avis en Français
My English review
This book seemed very unique with such a cover and summary, and I was curious to see how it really was. I was afraid it might be a little too philosophical for me and to not understand what would happen in the story. So yes, this book is really original, I don’t think I can make any comparisons with other novels I've read before, but it was a great pleasure to discover the H.A. Goodman ideas. Indeed, the book makes us think about many points, what is right or wrong, and a lot of things according to that. It also shows the cruelty of people, the things they can do when they’re selfish or when they don't realize the impact of their acts on others. It's pretty amazing.
The author wrote about many famous wars we know about, showing us what people had been able to do, destroying lives in such a short time with only a bad choice. This book really makes us think about the aspects of the world while following the story of a couple very different from others, Layla and Stewart. They are both observers, who refused to become angels to fight the company of Satan. Stewart is indeed also very determined to find a solution and everything is good for him, even the torture of demons if it means he can have the answers he wants. But this change in tactics makes us wonder about what he could do or not in order to destroy Satan. To know if what he does is really different from what the demons do. Layla will follow him in his ideas although she sometimes doesn’t agree with him. But we will understand with them the problems of society and the mankind. Sometimes humans make their own choices and the demons only start them.
There were also some nice surprises throughout the novel and I must say I was totally surprised by the twists that happen at the end of the book for our little couple. I did not expect that at all. It’s also touching to follow both of them, to see their love for each other. It’s so strong that they always manage to overcome the doubts they have.
All this to say that I enjoyed this novel and I recommend it if you are looking for something different. The book is interesting and we try to understand throughout the chapters how our heroes will manage to succeed in their quest. And I must say it was quite impressive. I haven’t had the opportunity to read the first book but as this book shows us something very different, there really is not a problem to start with this one.
My English review
This book seemed very unique with such a cover and summary, and I was curious to see how it really was. I was afraid it might be a little too philosophical for me and to not understand what would happen in the story. So yes, this book is really original, I don’t think I can make any comparisons with other novels I've read before, but it was a great pleasure to discover the H.A. Goodman ideas. Indeed, the book makes us think about many points, what is right or wrong, and a lot of things according to that. It also shows the cruelty of people, the things they can do when they’re selfish or when they don't realize the impact of their acts on others. It's pretty amazing.
The author wrote about many famous wars we know about, showing us what people had been able to do, destroying lives in such a short time with only a bad choice. This book really makes us think about the aspects of the world while following the story of a couple very different from others, Layla and Stewart. They are both observers, who refused to become angels to fight the company of Satan. Stewart is indeed also very determined to find a solution and everything is good for him, even the torture of demons if it means he can have the answers he wants. But this change in tactics makes us wonder about what he could do or not in order to destroy Satan. To know if what he does is really different from what the demons do. Layla will follow him in his ideas although she sometimes doesn’t agree with him. But we will understand with them the problems of society and the mankind. Sometimes humans make their own choices and the demons only start them.
There were also some nice surprises throughout the novel and I must say I was totally surprised by the twists that happen at the end of the book for our little couple. I did not expect that at all. It’s also touching to follow both of them, to see their love for each other. It’s so strong that they always manage to overcome the doubts they have.
All this to say that I enjoyed this novel and I recommend it if you are looking for something different. The book is interesting and we try to understand throughout the chapters how our heroes will manage to succeed in their quest. And I must say it was quite impressive. I haven’t had the opportunity to read the first book but as this book shows us something very different, there really is not a problem to start with this one.
July 1, 2012
As seen on Rabidreads.ca:
This is an odd read with a quick start. The author clearly knows how to get the ball rolling.
I was drawn in by the cover and for awhile I could not piece out why it was there. It remains a colorful and spicy cover.
The book ranges from sprawling worlds to highly accurate historical events. There is a lot of talk about morality and the root of all evil and how it should be filled.
I think one of the bigger questions I have while writing this review is how to sell it (a remarkably funny pun because the entire book is about figuring out "The Formula" that the Hellish company is selling to earthlings). The book does a lot of things, some unfamiliar, some incredibly ordinary. Take our main character for instance against his demonic opponent in the first chapter. Franklin, a demon, is surrounded by all the riches in the world while Stewart, an Observer (basically the book’s designation for those in between Heaven and Hell), appears powerless with hair coiffed. He is a former CIA agent who investigated the root of evil while alive and then quit to become a teacher of criminals before he died. What is ordinary here is where they came from and the riches they have. What is extraordinary is the fact that this is happening in Hell which for some reason is structured like a bureaucracy.
Stewart’s determination is winning although it can be a little tiresome. His entire gang is all go-go-go which I think is the right speed for the book. Some of their decisions, however, are not entirely winning which I think is the point.
The book’s strong points are in its conglomeration of otherwise uncombined events. How about interrogating a demon inside your mind where you can summon sharks at any time to chomp at him, and then to show you his scheme he has you visit a Hiroshima landscape in black and white? Pretty crazy. My major complaint lies in the romance. I think Layla gets short shrift. There is a very tender and interesting love “event” (trust me it’s pretty weird) at the start but it quickly falls to the wayside under the brunt of Stewart’s determination. I think people will like this book if they don’t mind wonky, enjoy reliving history, and have a hankering to ferret out the root of all evil (hint: it’s not simple). The ending also is far from a conclusion. What they ultimately achieve is left a little too open. All in all, the side characters shine the most whether it be the over giddy demon seeking promotions, the Wall Street demon, or the break-dancing angel. You’ll just have to read it to believe it.
This is an odd read with a quick start. The author clearly knows how to get the ball rolling.
I was drawn in by the cover and for awhile I could not piece out why it was there. It remains a colorful and spicy cover.
The book ranges from sprawling worlds to highly accurate historical events. There is a lot of talk about morality and the root of all evil and how it should be filled.
I think one of the bigger questions I have while writing this review is how to sell it (a remarkably funny pun because the entire book is about figuring out "The Formula" that the Hellish company is selling to earthlings). The book does a lot of things, some unfamiliar, some incredibly ordinary. Take our main character for instance against his demonic opponent in the first chapter. Franklin, a demon, is surrounded by all the riches in the world while Stewart, an Observer (basically the book’s designation for those in between Heaven and Hell), appears powerless with hair coiffed. He is a former CIA agent who investigated the root of evil while alive and then quit to become a teacher of criminals before he died. What is ordinary here is where they came from and the riches they have. What is extraordinary is the fact that this is happening in Hell which for some reason is structured like a bureaucracy.
Stewart’s determination is winning although it can be a little tiresome. His entire gang is all go-go-go which I think is the right speed for the book. Some of their decisions, however, are not entirely winning which I think is the point.
The book’s strong points are in its conglomeration of otherwise uncombined events. How about interrogating a demon inside your mind where you can summon sharks at any time to chomp at him, and then to show you his scheme he has you visit a Hiroshima landscape in black and white? Pretty crazy. My major complaint lies in the romance. I think Layla gets short shrift. There is a very tender and interesting love “event” (trust me it’s pretty weird) at the start but it quickly falls to the wayside under the brunt of Stewart’s determination. I think people will like this book if they don’t mind wonky, enjoy reliving history, and have a hankering to ferret out the root of all evil (hint: it’s not simple). The ending also is far from a conclusion. What they ultimately achieve is left a little too open. All in all, the side characters shine the most whether it be the over giddy demon seeking promotions, the Wall Street demon, or the break-dancing angel. You’ll just have to read it to believe it.
October 28, 2012
Initially, I found this book to be a tiny bit reminiscent of A Christmas Carol, the author H.A.Goodman, takes the reader on a trip through heaven and hell, complete with demons and angels. That is where the comparison ends. It combines fantasy/paranormal with actual factual events. The result is thought provoking, to say the least. This is a different type of fiction, that you definitely need to be in the mood for. I really can't assign a genre to this one. It makes the reader think and question. This isn't a light, entertaining tale, although I found quite a bit of fun within the very serious message. Warning: Religious fundamentalist probably won't see the humor in this one and should give it a pass.
The world building was very well done. In this case, the fantasy world is the afterlife, specifically heaven and hell. The author presents a truly unique picture of his version of the afterlife. He includes tremendous amounts of detail within his narration, giving the reader a vibrant picture of this world.
The feature of this novel that I liked the most was the time travel that the characters experience. They travel back in time to some of the most horrific events in history and re-examine the events. It made me ask- How have we allowed the victors to "spin" these events? What really happened and how did we/they justify these events? Although, these were some of the darkest moments in the novel, they were also the most dramatic and interesting points of the novel.
My only criticism is that this book could use some good objective editing. At time, I found some of the dialog tedious, bordering on corny. It detracted from the overall message of the novel. An experienced editor would really help tighten up the writing and make the plot flow seamlessly.
This is not a fast read. The plot is extensive and unexpected at times, and as I noted above can get somewhat slow. I found that I needed to read it in small installments and give myself time to digest and ponder the meaning of each portion that I had read. Trying to read this book too quickly, will result in missing out on some of the philosophical internal conversations that are really one of the best things about this book.
This is not a "feel good" type of story, but it is a refreshing change of pace from some of the plots I have read lately. This is one that stays with you for a long time.
Special thanks to the author for providing a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
The world building was very well done. In this case, the fantasy world is the afterlife, specifically heaven and hell. The author presents a truly unique picture of his version of the afterlife. He includes tremendous amounts of detail within his narration, giving the reader a vibrant picture of this world.
The feature of this novel that I liked the most was the time travel that the characters experience. They travel back in time to some of the most horrific events in history and re-examine the events. It made me ask- How have we allowed the victors to "spin" these events? What really happened and how did we/they justify these events? Although, these were some of the darkest moments in the novel, they were also the most dramatic and interesting points of the novel.
My only criticism is that this book could use some good objective editing. At time, I found some of the dialog tedious, bordering on corny. It detracted from the overall message of the novel. An experienced editor would really help tighten up the writing and make the plot flow seamlessly.
This is not a fast read. The plot is extensive and unexpected at times, and as I noted above can get somewhat slow. I found that I needed to read it in small installments and give myself time to digest and ponder the meaning of each portion that I had read. Trying to read this book too quickly, will result in missing out on some of the philosophical internal conversations that are really one of the best things about this book.
This is not a "feel good" type of story, but it is a refreshing change of pace from some of the plots I have read lately. This is one that stays with you for a long time.
Special thanks to the author for providing a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
March 5, 2013
This was a book like no other that's for sure. I found it to be a good read, but felt some of the parts were a bit too descriptive at times for me, but they didn't make it a bad read by any means for me. This story about the workings of the afterlife world was intriguing and interesting to read about. I came to love the characters and also the whole idea for the book. The plot was well written and thought out. I thought the writing was great as far as leaving me feeling like I was understanding the book and the thoughts of the author. It really is a book that makes you think about things while reading it. It makes you look at real life in a whole new way too. I found it to actually make sense to me and it made me feel as though I could see the inside of the afterlife and how it all works and what makes us, here on earth, make our life decisions; be them good or bad. How do we come to decide if we should help someone or how do people decide to cheat on their spouses? This book kind of makes you wonder and look at how we may really do these things as human beings. I loved that, even though this was a fictional book, it made me think about real life scenarios. I also liked how the characters of Stewart and Layla made many choices in their lives and afterlives that affected so many, but didn't go against what they were as their own beings. I liked their spunk and persistence to do what is right and what they feel strongly about. This may be a different type of book, but it was worth the read. I found it to be quite a unique book that left me wondering and thinking about my own life and ways things happen in it well after I was done reading the book. On another note, I must say that the cover of this book was the most amazing thing I have ever seen on a book. I usually don't get drawn in by covers, but I was simply in awe over this cover. The beautiful colors and artwork of it all was simply amazing to me and made me want to dive in all that much more to the book. Turned out that it wasn't just a beautiful cover, but a great book inside too. I would recommend it to anyone looking for something different in their reading that will turn out to be a great addition to books they have read.
4/5 Stars!
4/5 Stars!
August 11, 2012
After having really enjoyed H.A. Goodman's first novel in the Logic of Demon's series, The Quest for Nadine’s Soul, I knew without a doubt that I wanted to read the second installment, Breaking The Devil’s Heart. I was pleasantly surprised with the novel having just one narrator this time around. It was much easier to follow one character’s observations rather than having to follow many at once. Like H.A. Goodman’s first novel, Breaking The Devil’s Heart addresses strong subject matter such as core values, the afterlife, and religious implications of Heaven versus Hell. The author’s writing style has also developed, skillfully intertwining these subjects along with added elements of accurate historical events. It’s all these elements combined that truly brought the story all together for me and made the novel surpass my expectations.
My favorite element of Breaking The Devil’s Heart as well as the first installment in the Logic of Demon’s series, is H.A. Goodman’s unique concept of the way Hell works. Just under the earth’s surface lies a team of agents and salesmen from Hell who play significant roles in this large organization referred to as “The Company”. Their main objective is to sell “The Formula” to those who are still among the living. In order to lour them over to the dark side, these salesmen sell "The Formula" by convincing their customers to act on their negative impulses and create chaos. H.A. Goodman takes this simple idea and executes it brilliantly! I also appreciated the author's careful attention to detail as it is evident that he devoted a lot of time into not only creating a unique concept, but to also incorporate profound underlying messages.
Breaking The Devil’s Heart is a fast-paced action-packed thriller, with many relateable and engaging characters. Want to read something unique, compelling, and thought provoking? I recommend picking up a copy of Breaking The Devil’s Heart, you won't be disappointed! H.A. Goodman, I am definitely looking forward to the next installment in the Logic of Demon's series!
Must Read! Highly Recommended!
My favorite element of Breaking The Devil’s Heart as well as the first installment in the Logic of Demon’s series, is H.A. Goodman’s unique concept of the way Hell works. Just under the earth’s surface lies a team of agents and salesmen from Hell who play significant roles in this large organization referred to as “The Company”. Their main objective is to sell “The Formula” to those who are still among the living. In order to lour them over to the dark side, these salesmen sell "The Formula" by convincing their customers to act on their negative impulses and create chaos. H.A. Goodman takes this simple idea and executes it brilliantly! I also appreciated the author's careful attention to detail as it is evident that he devoted a lot of time into not only creating a unique concept, but to also incorporate profound underlying messages.
Breaking The Devil’s Heart is a fast-paced action-packed thriller, with many relateable and engaging characters. Want to read something unique, compelling, and thought provoking? I recommend picking up a copy of Breaking The Devil’s Heart, you won't be disappointed! H.A. Goodman, I am definitely looking forward to the next installment in the Logic of Demon's series!
Must Read! Highly Recommended!
May 31, 2015
Breaking the Devil's Heart was nothing like what I expected when I opened it up. This is a battle between heaven and hell like you've never heard of or imagined before. We get a brand new idea as to what happens after we die. Since no one really knows for sure, the ideas are really endless. But this one was well planned and thought out, really unique, and quite in depth.
Another thing I was not expecting was the darkness it contained. Of course when reading a book about hell and battles, you are expecting a certain level of evil and darkness. But at many times while reading this I was completely shocked, horrified, disgusted, even a little physically nauseous. Most of the time it was a good thing, that sounds weird I know, but it was just good writing and it played into the story so well that it made sense to be feeling that way. But there were points where it went just a little to far for me. But these moments were few and far between.
The book continued to surprise me. Even when I thought I had it figured it, I totally didn't. I love when a book can totally knock you off your feet and make you stop and think...wait...what?!...really!? Reading this book was like a good workout for the mind. It was very deep, incredibly thought provoking, as well as inspirational and motivating. On top of all that we got a few history lessons. Mostly of humanity's darker times. They were anything but boring though to say the least. More like giant eye openers.
In all, you can tell a lot of work and a mass amount of thought went into this story. It had it's lighter, happy moments, but mostly we walked in shadows and sadness. I do enjoy a dark story, but this one might have been borderline for me. It was full of unsuspecting plot twists, and lots of interesting, but also really sad, facts and information. I would probably recommend it, but I would definitely be wary of who I recommended it to, and I would definitely give a warning that they should be prepared to stomach some terrible things. but I did enjoy it, and i definitely respect the work put into the story!
Another thing I was not expecting was the darkness it contained. Of course when reading a book about hell and battles, you are expecting a certain level of evil and darkness. But at many times while reading this I was completely shocked, horrified, disgusted, even a little physically nauseous. Most of the time it was a good thing, that sounds weird I know, but it was just good writing and it played into the story so well that it made sense to be feeling that way. But there were points where it went just a little to far for me. But these moments were few and far between.
The book continued to surprise me. Even when I thought I had it figured it, I totally didn't. I love when a book can totally knock you off your feet and make you stop and think...wait...what?!...really!? Reading this book was like a good workout for the mind. It was very deep, incredibly thought provoking, as well as inspirational and motivating. On top of all that we got a few history lessons. Mostly of humanity's darker times. They were anything but boring though to say the least. More like giant eye openers.
In all, you can tell a lot of work and a mass amount of thought went into this story. It had it's lighter, happy moments, but mostly we walked in shadows and sadness. I do enjoy a dark story, but this one might have been borderline for me. It was full of unsuspecting plot twists, and lots of interesting, but also really sad, facts and information. I would probably recommend it, but I would definitely be wary of who I recommended it to, and I would definitely give a warning that they should be prepared to stomach some terrible things. but I did enjoy it, and i definitely respect the work put into the story!
November 4, 2012
Breaking the Devil's Heart isn't part of my usual YA shtick, but the originality and concept of this book drew me in.
Stewart and Layla, the protagonists of the novel, are "Observers"--basically angels who work in the gray--and they take on the corporation that is Hell in order to stop the sale of the mysterious "Formula," which demons have been selling to mankind to further the spread of evil on Earth.
I loved Goodman's creative take on angels and Hell. Especially the addition of Observers, because they had very cool abilities and I just have a weakness for morally ambiguous characters...For me, those are the best kind of characters! The idea that Hell is actually this huge, bureaucratic corporation was creatively constructed and thought-provoking. This idea was really brought to life by the world-building of this book, which was fantastic. From the actual offices of Hell to the dimensions created by Stewart and Layla's mind, I could really picture this twisted take on the afterlife.
Where this book fell flat for me was the characters. Stewart and Layla had an interesting back story, neat abilities, and an epic mission, but I found it hard to connect with them. Stewart's narration was very matter-of-fact, objective almost, and I had a hard time relating to him as a character. The characters came off as one-dimensional which detracted from my overall enjoyment of the book.
Rating: 3 stars*
All in all: This concept of this book was original and very thought-provoking, and I would recommend it for people who are usually into more fantasy/science fiction and favor plot-driven novels of character-driven ones. Overall, I think the story was well-executed; the religious aspect of this book is handled very well and it doesn't take over the actual plot of the story.
*I received a copy of this book for review purposes from the author. All opinions are my own.
Stewart and Layla, the protagonists of the novel, are "Observers"--basically angels who work in the gray--and they take on the corporation that is Hell in order to stop the sale of the mysterious "Formula," which demons have been selling to mankind to further the spread of evil on Earth.
I loved Goodman's creative take on angels and Hell. Especially the addition of Observers, because they had very cool abilities and I just have a weakness for morally ambiguous characters...For me, those are the best kind of characters! The idea that Hell is actually this huge, bureaucratic corporation was creatively constructed and thought-provoking. This idea was really brought to life by the world-building of this book, which was fantastic. From the actual offices of Hell to the dimensions created by Stewart and Layla's mind, I could really picture this twisted take on the afterlife.
Where this book fell flat for me was the characters. Stewart and Layla had an interesting back story, neat abilities, and an epic mission, but I found it hard to connect with them. Stewart's narration was very matter-of-fact, objective almost, and I had a hard time relating to him as a character. The characters came off as one-dimensional which detracted from my overall enjoyment of the book.
Rating: 3 stars*
All in all: This concept of this book was original and very thought-provoking, and I would recommend it for people who are usually into more fantasy/science fiction and favor plot-driven novels of character-driven ones. Overall, I think the story was well-executed; the religious aspect of this book is handled very well and it doesn't take over the actual plot of the story.
*I received a copy of this book for review purposes from the author. All opinions are my own.
August 6, 2012
(Edition I read from was provided by author in exchange for an honest review; paperback, isbn#9781432790585)
(3.5)
First thing that comes to mind about this book is telling of the author and that is that Mr. Goodman cannot be accused of lacking imagination! This story was genuinely creative. The characters were engaging and the plot simply extraordinary. You're going to need your cerebrum for this book because it can get confusing ..the good kind. The kind that will challenge you to think. We could use that from time-to-time and this book will absolutely do that. At least it did for me!
I'm a give-me-a-book-that-touches-the-heart kind of girl so the bits that mentioned historical good and evil deeds were what stood out for me. Mr. Goodman didn't sugarcoat the evil ones therefore those parts were difficult to read but enhanced the point to be made. The good ones of course were comfort acknowledgments of the deserving worth of a human soul and that is always heartwarming to me. Overall, there was a message of hope for defeating our inner demons if we but learn from history and it took a metaphorical-satire type of venue (see blurb) to get me there. Pretty clever, Mr. Goodman! It was a bizarre read but quite thought provoking.
Just because I'm lost for eloquency, I will throw in some words that came to mind about what was dealt in this book: human pscyhe, philosophies, love, cruelty, humor, surprising twists, fanciful metaphor, putting oneself in another's shoes/mind, true nature, instincts, betrayal, loyalty, etc. ..oh yeah, logic. ;)
This book is currently 99 cents for the Kindle and Nook editions. What a steal! It is well worth the price and if the blurb or my review intrigued you then go for it! :)
Jinky is Reading
(3.5)
First thing that comes to mind about this book is telling of the author and that is that Mr. Goodman cannot be accused of lacking imagination! This story was genuinely creative. The characters were engaging and the plot simply extraordinary. You're going to need your cerebrum for this book because it can get confusing ..the good kind. The kind that will challenge you to think. We could use that from time-to-time and this book will absolutely do that. At least it did for me!
I'm a give-me-a-book-that-touches-the-heart kind of girl so the bits that mentioned historical good and evil deeds were what stood out for me. Mr. Goodman didn't sugarcoat the evil ones therefore those parts were difficult to read but enhanced the point to be made. The good ones of course were comfort acknowledgments of the deserving worth of a human soul and that is always heartwarming to me. Overall, there was a message of hope for defeating our inner demons if we but learn from history and it took a metaphorical-satire type of venue (see blurb) to get me there. Pretty clever, Mr. Goodman! It was a bizarre read but quite thought provoking.
Just because I'm lost for eloquency, I will throw in some words that came to mind about what was dealt in this book: human pscyhe, philosophies, love, cruelty, humor, surprising twists, fanciful metaphor, putting oneself in another's shoes/mind, true nature, instincts, betrayal, loyalty, etc. ..oh yeah, logic. ;)
This book is currently 99 cents for the Kindle and Nook editions. What a steal! It is well worth the price and if the blurb or my review intrigued you then go for it! :)
Jinky is Reading
November 26, 2012
Going into reading this book I wasn't sure what to expect, and didn't know that it was the second book in a series. Therefore, I never read the first book in this series The Logic of Demons, that being said, I didn't even notice it was the second in a series, It read fine as a standalone and I didn't feel like I missed anything that was crucial to the second book.
H.A. Goodman created such a unique world with this book. I'm not partial to a certain religion, but do believe in God and heaven and hell, and I loved Goodman's version of what primarily hell is really like. It was an interesting world where demons are salesman trying to sell the formula to humans on earth which makes them made the wrong decision, whether it be driving away from a hit and run, or stealing, or lying whatever it is. I know religion is a touchy subject for many people, but this book was in no way preachy. It does discuss values, the afterlife, and religion but not in a way that it's opinions shoved down your throat.
This book read like a paranormal book with almost a sort-of of dystopian feel in the respect that the world-building was so well crafted that it felt otherworldly in a dystopian type way. I was pleasently suprised by this book and H.A. Goodman's writing. This book was so different then anything else i've read, so if your looking for something new and insightful without being preachy this is a book to check out.
H.A. Goodman created such a unique world with this book. I'm not partial to a certain religion, but do believe in God and heaven and hell, and I loved Goodman's version of what primarily hell is really like. It was an interesting world where demons are salesman trying to sell the formula to humans on earth which makes them made the wrong decision, whether it be driving away from a hit and run, or stealing, or lying whatever it is. I know religion is a touchy subject for many people, but this book was in no way preachy. It does discuss values, the afterlife, and religion but not in a way that it's opinions shoved down your throat.
This book read like a paranormal book with almost a sort-of of dystopian feel in the respect that the world-building was so well crafted that it felt otherworldly in a dystopian type way. I was pleasently suprised by this book and H.A. Goodman's writing. This book was so different then anything else i've read, so if your looking for something new and insightful without being preachy this is a book to check out.
November 3, 2012
Stewart and Layla gave up heaven so that they could find the root of evil and destroy it. Sure they could have been Angel’s and lived life in heaven, but that isn’t what they wanted to do. So now they are trying to find out, 1 – how the formula that the devil and the demons use to corrupt humankind works, and 2 – how to stop it.
Stewart is a smart man who does not give up. He is willing to do whatever it takes to take down evil and end human suffering. Layla is sweet and innocent, but you can see she is strong and just as determined. Together they are in a world of demons, angels, heaven and hell that is very fascinating!
I love how the story unfolds and the pace keeps a steady level of action. And the storyline is one of the most unique ones out there! The idea that we are offered a formula to commit evil deeds is fascinating and the ins and outs of the whole operation of hell is treat to read about.
I think the author did a lot of research to write this novel. There are a lot of historic occasions mentioned and I found it fascinating seeing it from the characters perspectives. The traveling and “flashbacks” of the characters was certainly a favorite aspect of mine. Not to mention the convoluted plot!
Definitely a novel to read if you like something different that makes you think.
Stewart is a smart man who does not give up. He is willing to do whatever it takes to take down evil and end human suffering. Layla is sweet and innocent, but you can see she is strong and just as determined. Together they are in a world of demons, angels, heaven and hell that is very fascinating!
I love how the story unfolds and the pace keeps a steady level of action. And the storyline is one of the most unique ones out there! The idea that we are offered a formula to commit evil deeds is fascinating and the ins and outs of the whole operation of hell is treat to read about.
I think the author did a lot of research to write this novel. There are a lot of historic occasions mentioned and I found it fascinating seeing it from the characters perspectives. The traveling and “flashbacks” of the characters was certainly a favorite aspect of mine. Not to mention the convoluted plot!
Definitely a novel to read if you like something different that makes you think.
August 8, 2012
When you die, the very good people become angels and the very bad people become demons, but if you're just mostly good you may be given the option of becoming an Observer. Contrary to their title, Observers are more like hands-on angels in the battle between good and evil. Stewart and Layla are two such Observers, on a mission to discover the secret behind the Formula, some sort of evil-making product demons peddle to conflicted humans. After touring parts of both heaven and hell and receiving rather puzzling answers to their queries, Stewart and Layla come upon what may be the answer they seek. And you know, I really enjoyed the story up to this point (save the intensely gooey relationship between Stewart and Layla, which often left me gagging). I love heaven versus hell stories in general, I like the concept of Observers, and the role of Time/Fate was intriguing as well. But then there was this strange twist ending. I really did not understand what happened. I'm willing to accept that maybe I just missed something obvious, because the lead-up was pretty good. Either way, I'll be curious to see what else Goodman cooks up for this universe. It certainly has a lot of potential.
August 23, 2012
Breaking the Devil’s Heart” is a creative, original, and intelligent novel. Mr. Goodman has given us a new definition of the afterlife – with demons, angels, Observers, and of course, the Devil. Hell has been remade as a corporation (The Company) where demons do their best to sell ‘The Formula’ to humans. Stewart and his girlfriend, Layla, were viciously murdered and when given a choice they chose to be Observers. Now Stewart is working on a plan to destroy Hell and The Formula, which includes infiltrating the inner workings of The Company. “Breaking the Devil’s Heart” is told exclusively through Stewart’s perspective as he fights to free humans from The Formula’s effects.
Mr. Goodman has written a thought-provoking novel about the nature of good and evil, the necessity of personal responsibility for our actions, and the deepest flaws and triumphs of the human race. Opening up the doors on religion, society, and the root of all evil, Mr. Goodman has created a unique look at both life and the afterlife. ”Breaking the Devil’s Heart” pulls no punches and is better for it – leaving the reader with a lasting impression and much to think about.
Logic of Demons Series: The Quest for Nadine's Soul (1), Breaking the Devil's Heart (2)
Mr. Goodman has written a thought-provoking novel about the nature of good and evil, the necessity of personal responsibility for our actions, and the deepest flaws and triumphs of the human race. Opening up the doors on religion, society, and the root of all evil, Mr. Goodman has created a unique look at both life and the afterlife. ”Breaking the Devil’s Heart” pulls no punches and is better for it – leaving the reader with a lasting impression and much to think about.
Logic of Demons Series: The Quest for Nadine's Soul (1), Breaking the Devil's Heart (2)
March 3, 2013
Wow... I really wasn't sure what I was getting into when I started this novel because up front, you're told it's different than anything you've ever read. Definitely true! At first, the novel started a little slow but then it built up more and more. The pace ended up moving at a steady speed. The novel is told through Stewarts POV so that's always a breath of fresh air for me. I'm so used to reading novels told from the female lead's perspective. Although, I have to admit, I enjoyed The female lead and would've been interested to see a lot more from her perspective to swap it up a bit. The author's new spin on hell as a corporation who sells the "formula" is pretty genius - totally the most creative spin on hell I've read in a while. There are a few places where the writing style felt more like I was reading a dictionary of sorts - pretty formal and felt almost apart from the novel, but overall, it wasn't a hindrance. Overall a really thought provoking read that I enjoyed but I'm not jumping up and down screaming get it, get it. If you like fantasy and enjoy something a little different then definitely get it. I think the ebook was only $.99 so definitely worth that plus a little more. Can I just say the cover is a work of art??! It's really pretty amazing.
June 25, 2012
I read Goodman's last book, which was a knockout of a Freshman novel of Wellesian proportions. It's not so much that I expected a Sophomore slump, but rather, I thought how could he even come close to topping the last effort? Well, he did. He beat it by a mile. Every page is delivered with a masterfully assured hand. Every character is layered, purposeful, and fully realized. The plot is a never-ending Cyclonic thrill. The prose leap of the page with a crisp, biting delivery. It's quite simply an ontological mind-fuck and a tour-de-force. A triumphant achievement and a leap forward in the genre. H.A. Goodman is fast out of the gate and in a commanding lead and I'm not sure if any his peers can catch him. This is a must read for anyone - not just for the lovers of the genre, but really for anyone that even knows how to put together a sentence.
October 22, 2012
Well the summary is right on the money when it says the book is unlike anything you've ever read! I couldn't agree more! At first I thought this would be more of a religious book, but it wasn't. HA Goodman takes the concept of Heaven and Hell and puts a spin on it different from anything I've ever read. It is definitely a unique and one of a kind story.
This story was very fast paced and sometimes I did get lost and had to re-read a passage or two. But it didn't bother me because I was not bored one bit throughout my reading. Stewart and Layla quickly became favorable to me because of their strong and determined personalities.
No spoilers in this post, but this story is FULL of twists, turns and surprises and it is not one of those stories you are able to call. You will have no earthly idea how it's going to turn out. Goodman is super talented and has a great imagination!
This story was very fast paced and sometimes I did get lost and had to re-read a passage or two. But it didn't bother me because I was not bored one bit throughout my reading. Stewart and Layla quickly became favorable to me because of their strong and determined personalities.
No spoilers in this post, but this story is FULL of twists, turns and surprises and it is not one of those stories you are able to call. You will have no earthly idea how it's going to turn out. Goodman is super talented and has a great imagination!
January 22, 2013
This was a very interesting look at human behavior. Of good versus evil. About why we choose to do good and why some of us choose to do bad.
Stewart and Layla's story was definitely unique and I can't say I have read anything else like it.
I admit at times this seemed to drag a little more than necessary and I found myself wanting to skim it. Some parts were a little too graphic for me and that might have contributed to it as well. Humanity isn't always kind to one another as the author likes to remind us by showing past crisis' wars and hardships.
I will say this, it definitely makes you think and take a second look at how choices will effect others and how gossip and other acts can be hurtful and deceiving.
Stewart and Layla's story was definitely unique and I can't say I have read anything else like it.
I admit at times this seemed to drag a little more than necessary and I found myself wanting to skim it. Some parts were a little too graphic for me and that might have contributed to it as well. Humanity isn't always kind to one another as the author likes to remind us by showing past crisis' wars and hardships.
I will say this, it definitely makes you think and take a second look at how choices will effect others and how gossip and other acts can be hurtful and deceiving.
August 18, 2012
What can I say about this book? There is so much going on and I do not want to give away anything. The first couple of pages I read in the train and I seriously could not stop reading. It was so good. The main characters Stewart and Layla are an incredible team. They both were teachers in the living world and I liked that. Yay, teachers! Unfortunately their lives ended well, tragically. I really liked the flashbacks. I also liked the plot. It was descriptive, fast paced and well researched. All in all, I liked it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews