Twelve-year-old Tommy Gorman goes missing. With his mother watching his sister’s softball game at the Little League complex, Tommy seeks to find his friend and is lured into the woods by a man holding a turtle. Following the softball game, neither Tommy’s frantic mother nor anyone else can find him. Only thing found is a dead painted turtle.
When a search party discovers the grave of a murdered boy, killed four months earlier, Detective Benny Fidalgo believes he has only days to find Tommy alive. In investigating, he focuses on Little League officials, a film crew, and residents and employees of a nearby psychiatric facility. However, Fidalgo, eager to solve his first major case, prematurely arrests a suspect who sues the town. As a result, Blacksburg’s Police Chief suspends Fidalgo and regrets hiring him as a favor to a friend. Undeterred, Fidalgo pushes forward…able to do so with the support of two seasoned detectives who believe their new colleague has what it takes to ensnare the serial killer operating under their noses for years.