Sita, detective Lalli’s niece—and occasional Watson—runs into former classmate Anais at Mumbai airport. Even as the friends catch up, Anais hands over a cardboard box she is carrying to a waiting woman, nonchalantly informing the traumatized lady that the box contains her son’s ashes. Some days later, Anais herself turns up dead in the slimy Mithi River, a pink nylon rope wrapped ritually around her neck. What does the cardboard box with human remains have to do with Anais’s murder? And what significance do the peculiar knots round her neck have? Lalli must find answers, fast, if she is to prevent more deaths.
Too many disjointed characters. Nobody for whom I could feel any sympathy. And I'm, frankly speaking, disgusted with Sita, Lalli's niece and the narrator. Plus, the plot was fool of irrelevant observations, information and backstory. Overall, didn’t enjoy the book at all, despite the usual wit and charm of the author lacing each page, in her signature style.
This book had more knots than the RACE franchise. The plotting was terrible. A good mystery is like the perfect game, following a logical path albeit with some steps in shadow or invisible, keeping the reader always feeling like they’re just one step behind. This one was more like being thrown about on an Andheri road.
I’ve liked an earlier Lalli book which was a collection of short stories. However, in this one, she comes off as obnoxious, deliberately withholding information simply for personal glory. The other characters blur too and there are just too many of them who serve no purpose. Sita (but apparently you can hear how it’s different from Seeta), Savio, Shukla, Mhatre, Hilla, Lucy, Marcelle, Perreira, Caroline, Annie, Suhail, some angry useless brother, a different spiteful moral policing man, some Rassiwalla, some Immortals, some Sada Suhagan.
Yet, the moments outside the story when the author’s wisdom of life is espoused in Lalli’s words - her truths about human behaviour and folly - these are pretty great. They are the only reason I give this book 2 stars.
After reading about this author in the newspaper and after coming to know that she writes mystery novels, I picked this book. The plot was ok and the story was not too bad. But could have been edited better.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Kalpana Swaminathan weaves a rich tapestry that is a joy to read. But the problem is, at the end of it, I am still wondering if only the current mystery was solved or even the historical ones connected to the current one. Somehow leaves me gasping for breath - both in good and bad ways.
Complicated plot, too many characters and the English quite complicated. Kalpana Swaminathan needs the (I'm guessing) sobering influence of Ishrat and as a duo, they are way better than her solo book.