As featured on BBC Radio 4 (Woman's Hour, Start the Week), Times Radio, in the Telegraph (also as a bestseller), The Times, and at theRoyal Institution.
A DAILY TELEGRAPH BOOK OF THE YEAR A diagnosis is supposed to give us certainty, our first step on the road to recovery.
But what if your diagnosis is inflected by a doctor's bias, swayed by Big Pharma, or designed to protect the police? What happens when you are -- or your child is -- refused a diagnosis for a condition the establishment will not recognise?
As a consultant neurologist, Dr Jules Montague saw the relief a diagnosis could bring, but she also came to see its limitations. In this eye-opening and humane account, Montague meets with the patients and families who have had their lives turned upside down by a diagnosis they never deserved.
She speaks to parents fighting for recognition of their children's symptoms; men and women whose bodies have been stigmatised by society; and to the families of young black men who are being diagnosed posthumously with a condition that could exonerate their killers.
Through these stories of heartbreak and resilience, Montague shines a light on the troubled state of diagnosis, and asks how we might begin to heal.
THE IMAGINARY PATIENT: May 12th 2022. As featured on BBC Radio 4 (Start the Week, Woman's Hour), Times Radio, in the Telegraph and Times, and at the Royal Institution. Telegraph Bestseller. Times Literary Supplement Shop Best New Books
LOST AND FOUND: as featured on BBC Radio 4, BBC Radio 3, Sky News, and in the Guardian, Telegraph, Sunday Times, The Scotsman, Independent, and the Irish Times. Published internationally.
THE IMAGINARY PATIENT
The Imaginary Patient: How Diagnosis Gets Us Wrong (Granta 2022) explores how the practice of diagnosis is tainted by the forces of imperialism, politics, discrimination and Big Pharma. She speaks to parents fighting for recognition of their children’s symptoms; men and women whose bodies have been stigmatised by society; and to the families of young black men who are being diagnosed posthumously with a condition that could exonerate their killers. Through these stories of heart-break and resilience, Montague shines a light on the troubled state of diagnosis, and asks how we might begin to heal.
Praise for The Imaginary Patient:
'The Imaginary Patient is a great stride forward in the way medical stories are told. Nobody who reads it will experience a doctor's appointment the same way again. Montague's writing is empathetic, surprising and forensic all at once.' Caroline Crampton, author of The Way to the Sea.
A shocking history of the many ways in which medical diagnoses have "shown themselves to be a form of obfuscation"... Heartbreaking... [it] will make you see doctors differently. Telegraph ****
A compelling basis for change... A richly researched book that provides ample food for thought and ammunition for change in the way diagnosis is done Medical Journalists' Association
Press for The Imaginary Patient: as featured on Times Radio, BBC Radio 4 (Woman's Hour, Start the Week) and in the Telegraph and Times.
LOST AND FOUND: Why Losing Our Memories Doesn't Mean Losing Ourselves (Sceptre 2018), explores what remains of the person when the pieces of their mind go missing - from dementia and brain injury to sleep disorders and multiple personality disorder. Lost and Found, a bestseller, has featured on BBC Radio 4, BBC Radio 3, Sky News and in the Sunday Times Daily Mail, and Telegraph.
Praise for Lost and Found:
‘Montague is turning traditional thinking on its head in her beautifully written book about memory and identity’ The Times
‘Montague takes the reader on an exquisite journey into the human brain and beyond that. She does this with a humanity rich in tenderness and a beguiling reverence for the unknown. Occasionally we come across a physicist or economist who, despite their subject matter, can stop you in your tracks. They reel you in without you realising. Montague is a neurologist who does exactly that. She has a rare gift: she makes her craft look simple.’ Irish Times
‘A profoundly moving, revelatory book’ Daily Mail
Other press for Lost and Found below
BIO:
Doctor Jules Montague is a neurologist and author.
Originally from Ireland, Jules Montague studied Medicine at Tri
"The Imaginary Patient: How Diagnosis Gets Us Wrong” delves into the complex interplay of colonialism, politics, societal biases, and pharmaceutical interests in shaping diagnostic practices. Montague presents a multi-faceted view, recounting the experiences of parents seeking validation for their children's conditions, individuals marginalised by society due to their physical states, and families of young black men who posthumously receive diagnoses that could vindicate their killers. Through these emotionally charged stories, she scrutinises the fraught landscape of medical diagnosis while probing potential avenues for reform.
Maintaining a balanced tone throughout, Montague avoids the customary tirade against psychiatry often found in books critiquing diagnosis. Instead, she shifts the focus to the wider sociopolitical mechanisms that mould our understanding of what a diagnosis is. She acknowledges that diagnoses, despite their flaws, can sometimes serve a beneficial role—for instance, assigning a PTSD diagnosis to a refugee may provide a measure of validation for their ordeal, even if the label may not be culturally apt. Montague also emphasises the plurality of viewpoints on any given diagnostic issue, illustrating this with examples such as parents who fiercely advocate for a diagnosis for their child, despite scant scientific evidence to validate that particular diagnostic category.
Through my work on transdiagnostic features of brain development, I have been critical of psychiatric diagnoses for some time. However, I had mostly considered the historic legacy that bestowed the current diagnostic system on us. This book provided me with a much richer appreciation of all of the different forces that influence how we conceptualise diagnoses. I’m certain the book will prove illuminating for professionals in any healthcare sector, but particularly for those engaged in psychology, psychiatry, or mental health fields.