Maybe it wasn't your mom who baked your amazing birthday cake after all. Maybe it was created by a delicious cast of characters from your favorite nursery rhymes!
"We make a cake / We bake a cake / And send it on its way!" Beloved characters from classic nursery rhymes --- everyone from Humpty Dumpty to Little Bo Peep to Old King Cole --- collaborate to bake the most perfect, towering, delicious cake . . . and roll it along to its special recipient --- the birthday boy or girl! Mark Sperring's spare but sweet text combined with Jonathan Langley's bright, timeless artwork make for a fun, read-aloud book that allows readers to pick out their favorite nursery rhyme characters in the illustrations. Ideal for birthdays . . . or any occasion!
The basic premise and the story are fine, not incredible but not bad either. It's the way in which brown people are included that really sours this one for me...like, in the first few pages POCs are repeatedly depicted in service positions (musicians, a peasant sweeping in a ragged dress...). Then, when POCs start to show up in slightly better positions, they are nonetheless always depicted as solitary in a sea of white people, never with families around them or a sense of actually rich diverse communities. And never connected to any particular fairy tale/nursery rhyme either, which is odd because that's the whole premise.
Fun for kids to try to figure out which characters are which. It's nice that they're all explained in the inside of the front/back of the book. The story itself is not super interesting, but kids don't mind.
SUMMARY: Dozens of fairytale characters have gotten together to make a birthday cake for someone special. On the journey to the birthday boy's house, you are invited to spy and name the many characters.
ILLUSTRATIONS: The illustrations are very colorful and full of details. They are too busy for the age group this book was written for. There are dozens of people on a page making it more difficult to find and name the characters.
THE GOOD: This story invites you to learn fairytale characters and to find them among the pages. This is fun. This book can be a springboard for other fairytale stories. There are some nice prepositions for the little ones to learn such as up the hill, down the hill, and across the bridge. Because there are so many characters, this book can be looked at over and over to spy the characters. THE NOT AS GOOD: There is really no storyline here other than a cake is made and then brought to the birthday boy.
This is a cute book concept. However, for younger kids who aren't familiar with fairytale characters, the book can be pretty boring. My Storytime kids knew only a few fairytale characters and therefore didn't enjoy the book to its fullest
Our whole family loved this book. The words are simple, but my 2 year old LOVES to talk about the birthday cake and find parts of the fairytales. I couldn't even locate them all. Fun book.
This book is definitely geared towards younger children. The words are short and simple, but the pictures are detailed.This could be a good, fun Ispy book.
The story or words could be better, but they weren't annoying. The pictures are adorable and really fun. As a little girl, I would have stared at this book for hours.
Very cute, very British, short story, with a birthday theme, suitable for a pre-school story time. The illustrator packs in lots of fairy tale and nursery rhyme characters along the way.
There's just not a lot going on with this story. It's a little interactive, but there's not a whole lot to do. The kids kept yelling "now do we eat it?".