What do you think?
Rate this book


160 pages, Hardcover
Published March 31, 2023
Reading this to my five-year-old granddaughter Ily was a bit of a challenge. Apparently she picked up the book at a book fair because of the cover artwork. When a kid hands you a book, you read it; when they want to wander, you can’t lasso them.
Ily liked the drawings inside, but she isn’t quite at the age where she can go for three pages of prose without a break.
I, on the other hand, cannot break mid-rising action. As it turns out, Amara, the 11-year old’s conflict——was one I had at 8-years old.
While I’m tempted to write my own story, it would have none of the magic Linda Chapman’s Midnight Riders: Fire Horse has.
My four stars has nothing to do with getting Ily through the book. She would always come back to it, so the rough part was more about her attention span than the writing. The lost star came from my feeling that Moonlight Stables was Gryffindor and that Storm Stables was Slytherin. Certainly Rowling has no trademark on magic, but I thought the complications could have another layer of complication. Perhaps that will come as the series trots along.