I think there must be something wrong with me. Why do I so vehemently disagree with so many people who read children's books on Goodreads?
Is it that I read them on a different level? Is it that I don't have children sitting next to me to temper my reactions? I don't know what it is, but more often than not I seriously disagree with the Goodreads community.
Take this book, it has nearly a 5 star rating...why?
Yes, it's cute. It has a nice little rhyme that teaches counting. Adorable. But it doesn't make sense!!!! Why, when every other word is short, nice, easily pronounceable, and utterly transparent in its orthographic representation, does she shove in the name Alexandersson? The number of syllables throws off the rhythm of the poem, it doesn't rhyme with anything, so why?! Surely we could have found a name that was easier to spell, read, that matched the rhythm, I don't know like Marley or something, then you could have had some nice alliteration too. The choices of diction are not the only things that don't make sense. We go from having a hedgehog that is lonely in her house to a troop of animals off to see the movies. Did they plan to go to the movies? Or do people just randomly show up at lonely people's houses and then decide as a group to go to the movies? Am I weird that I usually plan my movie trips? I mean, I want to know what's showing and what time it's showing, not just spontaneously show up at a movie theatre....
The whole premise of the book is weird, hedgehog is sitting at home and hoping someone visits her. Does she invite someone over? Nope. Does she reach out to anyone? Nope. People just randomly show up. I think there is a lesson here. That probably there are a lot of people that don't reach out but are still up for being visited and want to hang out with other people and are actually lonely when they are home alone with no plans to see people. It is incumbent on those that care for them to reach out to them. At the same time, don't be someone who just sits at home waiting for someone to reach out to you! Be the one to reach out! I don't like this enabling of self-isolation making it the responsibility of others to be the ones to be the first to take action, that's just passing the buck. You are the person in charge of how you live your life, if you are alone and lonely and sad, it's more often than not because you have made those choices yourself. I should know, I am the absolute queen of making choices that result in loneliness, I don't get to blame others or wallow in self-pity because my choices resulted in a predictable outcome.
Nope. Didn't like this one.
Story: Counting poem
Art: Cute
Price: $15.00