As usual--reviews coming as I read the stories. Which means that it may take a long while before this is taken off the currently-reading list;-)
SEPTEMBER 4 (IRRC):
"Cold Print":
Hailed as one of the stories that takes the Cthulhu Mythos away from mere pastiche and into modern settings and storytelling. "Cold Print" lives up to this reputation (as well as being a sort of "modern classic" in the genre), no doubt about it, but the link to that sub-genre is rather meager, in my opinion. Sure, there is Campbell's contribution to the Mythos, The Revelations of Glaaki, but that's about it. It doesn't even have much of an important bearing on the plot, as far as I can tell.
That said, this story about an unsympathetic protagonist with, ahem, odd sexual preferences was interesting and with astute descriptions of that character's mood, personality etc. And with a bookshop as an important setting in the story, how can I not like it?;-) So, in brief, I liked the story on its own merits.
SEPTEMBER 11:
"The Return of the Witch":
According to Campbell's excellent foreword/introduction, "Chasing the Unknown," this story was suggested by two HPL notes. That alone of course makes it interesting for an HPL buff like me;-)
Unfortunately I found the actual execution rather lacklustre. Admittedly, Campbell's extraordinary sense of words, persons & atmosphere cannot be denied, but the story and the plot is too much like many other, classic witch/haunted house stories.
It was an all right read, but I had higher expectations.
SEPTEMBER 12:
"Blacked Out":
Not a Mythos tale, but certainly one that follows HPL's advices on how to craft a dark, creepy story. And even though I had flashbacks to HPL's "The Shadow Over Innsmouth" this is certainly Campbell's own story.
The fact that the story takes place in a country where the protagonist doesn't speak the language (German) sets the mood of alienation perfectly. And the things he see & experience in the small hamlet, first at a distance and later closer than he likes, are marvelously built upon each other, so there is a continuous rise of dread and expectations in the reader.
The best of it all is that nothing is ever revealed; all is only hinted at. Wonderful.
SEPTEMBER 20:
"The Franklyn Paragraphs":
Great, great story. This is a well-executed example of a story that takes some HPL elements (letters shared with us, the readers, to reveal horrors chiefest among them) and uses it splendidly in a modern setting and in a modern tone of voice. Modern, that is, in the 1960s and before computers. I wonder if a similar approach--but in our computer age with e-mails, attachments et al--has already been written? Could be interesting.
Again a story where not much is explained in the end, just hinted at, but it doesn't matter. The road up till then is grim and capturing in a dreadful way. Wonderful!
SEPTEMBER 23:
"The Will of Stanley Brooke":
A short tale. Campbell takes the necromancy element from HPL's The Case of Charles Dexter Ward and warps it into this one. It was a nice read. The execution and ending was, in my opinion, more like a "shocker tale" á la Robert Bloch than HPL.
OCTOBER 2:
"The Faces at Pine Dunes":
An example of a Mythos story that doesn't really have anything to do with HPL himself, but certainly has learned a thing or two by August Derleth and his bend of the genre. Some may see this as a detriment but I don't, in this case. It's just a fact. And when you get that you're into a nice ride of a tale.
It is, as is often the case with Campbell, about family relationship and dark secrets. And about witchcraft with a Mythos twist to it;-)
I liked it quite much. I found it a little difficult to follow at first, since I didn't really see what was going on, but when finally this was settled I was captured all the way to the ending's unspeakable ritual-like scene. And nice touch with the son-taking-over-the-traditions, Mr. Campbell;-)
OCTOBER 3:
"Before the Storm":
Excellent story!
The narrative is superbly strange and goes beyond what is usually done, so for a little while the reader is having a hard time figuring out exactly what is going on--and from what perspective we see things, creating an upsetting read.
The storyline is fairly classic, I discovered. A patient is at the psychiatric ward and is extremely paranoid and with a distorted sense of reality... Or...?;-)
More reviews to come, as usual;-)