What do you think?
Rate this book
Jackaby
Rook
This standalone adventure set in the world of the New York Times bestselling Jackaby series brims with humor, heart, and—of course—a hefty dose of supernatural mayhem.
Abigail Rook never intended to be the mortal bridge between the human and supernatural world. But now, the power of the Sight--and all the chaos that comes with seeing the essential truth of everything, every human, fairy, werewolf, enchanted slip of paper, and municipal building, at all times--is hers alone. With this overwhelming new gift, she should be able to solve crimes and help New Fiddleham, New England find calm in its supernatural chaos.
The only problem? She has no idea what she’s doing.
And New Fiddleham isn't waiting for Abigail to be ready. Local witches and other magical beings are going missing, as tensions between human and supernatural residents curdle into a hatred that could tear the city apart. Abigail's fiance, Charlie, works alongside her to unravel the magical disappearances, but as a shapeshifter, he's under threat as well. Then Abigail's parents appear, ready to take her back to England and marry her off to someone she's never met. Abigail has no choice but to follow her Sight, her instincts, and any clues she can find to track a culprit who is trying to destroy everything she holds dear.
Abigail Rook never intended to be the mortal bridge between the human and supernatural world. But now, the power of the Sight--and all the chaos that comes with seeing the essential truth of everything, every human, fairy, werewolf, enchanted slip of paper, and municipal building, at all times--is hers alone. With this overwhelming new gift, she should be able to solve crimes and help New Fiddleham, New England find calm in its supernatural chaos.
The only problem? She has no idea what she’s doing.
And New Fiddleham isn't waiting for Abigail to be ready. Local witches and other magical beings are going missing, as tensions between human and supernatural residents curdle into a hatred that could tear the city apart. Abigail's fiance, Charlie, works alongside her to unravel the magical disappearances, but as a shapeshifter, he's under threat as well. Then Abigail's parents appear, ready to take her back to England and marry her off to someone she's never met. Abigail has no choice but to follow her Sight, her instincts, and any clues she can find to track a culprit who is trying to destroy everything she holds dear.
356 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 22, 2023
63 people are currently reading
10485 people want to read
About the author
William Ritter
15 books1,866 followersWILLIAM RITTER is an Oregon educator and author of the New York Times bestselling Jackaby series. He is the proud father of the two bravest boys in the Wild Wood, and husband to the indomitable Queen of the Deep Dark.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews
September 11, 2023
Sherlock Holmes cross with Supernatural.
*Read as standalone.*
Abigail Rook's power of Sight grants her the extraordinary ability to discern and comprehend auras, including those of both human and nonhuman origin. While she's still learning this new ability, she's assisting Jackaby in his investigations of the disappearances of magical creatures and beings.
Even though I like the idea and concept, I did not find anything that particularly caught my attention. Overall, an okay read. Would still recommend it to fans of Sherlock Holmes and the Jackaby series.
*Although the author stated that this novel can be read as a standalone, I recommend reading it as part of the series. I think the story will be more enjoyable if you're already acquainted with these characters. *
*** Thank you to NetGalley, William Ritter, and Algonquin Young Readers for graciously sending me a copy of the novel to review. As always, all thoughts are my own.***
*Read as standalone.*
Abigail Rook's power of Sight grants her the extraordinary ability to discern and comprehend auras, including those of both human and nonhuman origin. While she's still learning this new ability, she's assisting Jackaby in his investigations of the disappearances of magical creatures and beings.
Even though I like the idea and concept, I did not find anything that particularly caught my attention. Overall, an okay read. Would still recommend it to fans of Sherlock Holmes and the Jackaby series.
*Although the author stated that this novel can be read as a standalone, I recommend reading it as part of the series. I think the story will be more enjoyable if you're already acquainted with these characters. *
*** Thank you to NetGalley, William Ritter, and Algonquin Young Readers for graciously sending me a copy of the novel to review. As always, all thoughts are my own.***
December 6, 2023
TW// mentions of murder, violence
Before I get into my review, I need to give a little disclaimer. This book can be read as a standalone BUT if you have any desire to read the previous books in the Jackaby series, do not read Rook until you’ve read the rest of the series. This book spoils the massive twists in the main series as well as the result of the final conflict.
I read this book as a standalone and my thoughts on the book may be different if I’d read the rest of the series first. However, I have a strong suspicion that I would’ve quit the series midway through if the other books were anything like this one.
The only thing I truly liked about this book was the magic system. It was super unique. I liked the way the seer’s powers drew in colors and scents. I have never seen anything like it before.
I’m not someone who can fall in love with a book based solely on a magic system though, so this book ultimately felt very lacking.
I could tell that the author was going for a Sherlock and Watson dynamic with Jackaby and Abigail, but I felt that it wasn’t done well enough. They felt like only faint impressions of Sherlock and Watson. I usually love the Sherlock/Watson dynamic, but Jackaby and Abigail just didn’t have enough of those dynamics.
None of the other characters really caught my eye. Most of the characters felt really bland and lacking in strong personalities, especially Charlie.
I’ve seen some reviewers saying that this book is predictable if you’ve read the other books in the series, but if I’m being honest, it was even predictable for someone who hasn’t read the entire series. I guessed who the true villain was right after I read the first sentence describing them.
The writing style also never truly clicked for me. It wasn’t bad; it was just bland.
I’m probably not going to pick up the rest of the Jackaby series now. I think that if the characters were replaced with a more interesting cast and the magic system was kept the same, I could’ve actually enjoyed the series. However, Rook didn’t work for me and I can’t imagine the other books in the series working for me either.
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Before I get into my review, I need to give a little disclaimer. This book can be read as a standalone BUT if you have any desire to read the previous books in the Jackaby series, do not read Rook until you’ve read the rest of the series. This book spoils the massive twists in the main series as well as the result of the final conflict.
I read this book as a standalone and my thoughts on the book may be different if I’d read the rest of the series first. However, I have a strong suspicion that I would’ve quit the series midway through if the other books were anything like this one.
The only thing I truly liked about this book was the magic system. It was super unique. I liked the way the seer’s powers drew in colors and scents. I have never seen anything like it before.
I’m not someone who can fall in love with a book based solely on a magic system though, so this book ultimately felt very lacking.
I could tell that the author was going for a Sherlock and Watson dynamic with Jackaby and Abigail, but I felt that it wasn’t done well enough. They felt like only faint impressions of Sherlock and Watson. I usually love the Sherlock/Watson dynamic, but Jackaby and Abigail just didn’t have enough of those dynamics.
None of the other characters really caught my eye. Most of the characters felt really bland and lacking in strong personalities, especially Charlie.
I’ve seen some reviewers saying that this book is predictable if you’ve read the other books in the series, but if I’m being honest, it was even predictable for someone who hasn’t read the entire series. I guessed who the true villain was right after I read the first sentence describing them.
The writing style also never truly clicked for me. It wasn’t bad; it was just bland.
I’m probably not going to pick up the rest of the Jackaby series now. I think that if the characters were replaced with a more interesting cast and the magic system was kept the same, I could’ve actually enjoyed the series. However, Rook didn’t work for me and I can’t imagine the other books in the series working for me either.
I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
August 30, 2024
2/4/24 reread: I loved this even more following a reread of the whole series. I am emo. William Ritter, I beg of you, another book, please
Original Review (3/28/23):
Endless thanks to NetGalley and Algonquin YR for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review!
MY FAVORITE SCOOBY DOO GANG IS BACK! ♡
An important note: It’s best to read the original four Jackaby books prior to reading Rook! This is written as a standalone, and it can decidedly be read as such without too much confusion, but you’ll get major spoilers for the first four books, and I’d wager it might be a more enjoyable read when you’ve seen where these guys started.
As with the original series, Rook has everything you could ask for:
- Murder! Mystery! Magic!
- Ghosts, plural!
- Goofy, dashing, and ever-so-slightly traumatized characters (a personal favorite)
- Soft romances, and unshakeable friendships
- A human-turned-duck who lives in a pond located on the third floor of a building. Duh.
Rook is a perfect addition to Abigail’s story. It’s sweet, hilarious (seriously, I highlighted SO many great jokes), and, of course, magical. In many ways, this fifth installment of the series takes on a much lighter tone/atmosphere than the previous books, painting New Fiddleham in vivid new colors like we’ve never seen it before. We explore new sides to Abigail that even she is unfamiliar with, and get to stumble along with her as she finds her footing. The road is rocky, but filled with excitement, horror, and high-strung emotions. Ritter’s writing has undeniably improved over the years, and the depictions of the world and the chaos inside Abigail’s head and heart were absolutely perfect.
The returning characters have grown so much since we first met them; there are new dynamics to explore, but each and every one of them still feel like the characters we’ve grown to love and adore. The unfortunate side to Rook being a “standalone” is that it’s intended to be accommodating to new readers without feeling heavy or confusing; I’d have loved to see a little more domestic interaction and emotional development with some of our old favorites (or indeed, would have loved to have seen more of them in general), but alas, we can’t have it all.
Regardless, this is a must-read for new readers with a taste for historical fantasy and old Jackaby fans alike! As always, I highly recommend this series. :-)
(Also, I can’t help but notice that we were given quite an open ending… I happily hesitate to call this a fifth and final installment, but only time shall tell!)
Original Review (3/28/23):
Endless thanks to NetGalley and Algonquin YR for providing me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review!
MY FAVORITE SCOOBY DOO GANG IS BACK! ♡
An important note: It’s best to read the original four Jackaby books prior to reading Rook! This is written as a standalone, and it can decidedly be read as such without too much confusion, but you’ll get major spoilers for the first four books, and I’d wager it might be a more enjoyable read when you’ve seen where these guys started.
As with the original series, Rook has everything you could ask for:
- Murder! Mystery! Magic!
- Ghosts, plural!
- Goofy, dashing, and ever-so-slightly traumatized characters (a personal favorite)
- Soft romances, and unshakeable friendships
- A human-turned-duck who lives in a pond located on the third floor of a building. Duh.
Rook is a perfect addition to Abigail’s story. It’s sweet, hilarious (seriously, I highlighted SO many great jokes), and, of course, magical. In many ways, this fifth installment of the series takes on a much lighter tone/atmosphere than the previous books, painting New Fiddleham in vivid new colors like we’ve never seen it before. We explore new sides to Abigail that even she is unfamiliar with, and get to stumble along with her as she finds her footing. The road is rocky, but filled with excitement, horror, and high-strung emotions. Ritter’s writing has undeniably improved over the years, and the depictions of the world and the chaos inside Abigail’s head and heart were absolutely perfect.
The returning characters have grown so much since we first met them; there are new dynamics to explore, but each and every one of them still feel like the characters we’ve grown to love and adore. The unfortunate side to Rook being a “standalone” is that it’s intended to be accommodating to new readers without feeling heavy or confusing; I’d have loved to see a little more domestic interaction and emotional development with some of our old favorites (or indeed, would have loved to have seen more of them in general), but alas, we can’t have it all.
Regardless, this is a must-read for new readers with a taste for historical fantasy and old Jackaby fans alike! As always, I highly recommend this series. :-)
(Also, I can’t help but notice that we were given quite an open ending… I happily hesitate to call this a fifth and final installment, but only time shall tell!)
September 8, 2023
Initial Thoughts
This was good! While this book is technically a stand-alone, I feel like I would have benefited from reading the previous books before diving into this one. The mystery is completely contained in this book but there were a lot of other things going on with the characters that I think some background would have helped. I liked Rook, Jackaby, and the rest of the characters and was eager to see what was going on with all of the disappearances going on. I loved that there was some humor woven throughout the story as well. I listened to the audiobook and thought that the narrator did a great job with the story.
Review copy provided by the publisher. Full review to be posted soon.
This was good! While this book is technically a stand-alone, I feel like I would have benefited from reading the previous books before diving into this one. The mystery is completely contained in this book but there were a lot of other things going on with the characters that I think some background would have helped. I liked Rook, Jackaby, and the rest of the characters and was eager to see what was going on with all of the disappearances going on. I loved that there was some humor woven throughout the story as well. I listened to the audiobook and thought that the narrator did a great job with the story.
Review copy provided by the publisher. Full review to be posted soon.
December 19, 2022
Hear ye, hear ye, Cult of Jackaby members:
We have been blessed with another (final?) installment to the post Dire King world of New Fiddlehaven. Things pick up six months after the fall of the Dire King and Abigail gaining the Sight. New Finglehamp is reeling from the arcane forces that attacked the town as well as the now-realization that nonhumans walk among them. Tensions are high. Magic is afoot.
This book delivers all the best things:
- Mystery, mayhem, and murder
- Douglas (all hail our feathered overlord)
- Soft Arbie content (we stan our cute couple)
- More of Jackaby and his wackiness
- Further exploration of New Fliddlesham
It's a lovely sequel to the Jackaby series and really shows the chaos and adjustment a nonmagical world would be plunged in to upon dealing with a magical world. It feels back to the roots of Jackaby while also refreshing and new. Each character still feels authentically themselves while having grown from the last four books and the trauma we all endured by the Dire King's plan. If you're a fan of New Fiddleham and our lovely Paranormal Investigators, you need this book.
We have been blessed with another (final?) installment to the post Dire King world of New Fiddlehaven. Things pick up six months after the fall of the Dire King and Abigail gaining the Sight. New Finglehamp is reeling from the arcane forces that attacked the town as well as the now-realization that nonhumans walk among them. Tensions are high. Magic is afoot.
This book delivers all the best things:
- Mystery, mayhem, and murder
- Douglas (all hail our feathered overlord)
- Soft Arbie content (we stan our cute couple)
- More of Jackaby and his wackiness
- Further exploration of New Fliddlesham
It's a lovely sequel to the Jackaby series and really shows the chaos and adjustment a nonmagical world would be plunged in to upon dealing with a magical world. It feels back to the roots of Jackaby while also refreshing and new. Each character still feels authentically themselves while having grown from the last four books and the trauma we all endured by the Dire King's plan. If you're a fan of New Fiddleham and our lovely Paranormal Investigators, you need this book.
August 30, 2023
★ I received an ARC by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review ★
I'm honestly bummed because I really enjoyed the original 4 Jackaby books and loved Abigail's character. So it makes sense that I would have loved this, but it fell a bit flat for me. Flip-flopping Abigail and Jackaby's dynamic honestly made their relationship less interesting. I also didn't mind Abigail being more vulnerable with her new powers, but she was insecure throughout the whole book. I also didn't enjoy the introduction to her parents, I felt like they were just added in to throw Abigail off even more. When all I really wanted was to see more Charlie, the ghost Jenny and other old characters. I would have also liked to have gotten to know the new young girl character "Grim" as well, but instead we were given scene after scene of Abigail being incompetent. There also wasn't a twist to this storyline, the characters who felt shady were... surprise! shady. This wasn't bad, it just wasn't great. Not sure if I would read anymore books in this series.
I'm honestly bummed because I really enjoyed the original 4 Jackaby books and loved Abigail's character. So it makes sense that I would have loved this, but it fell a bit flat for me. Flip-flopping Abigail and Jackaby's dynamic honestly made their relationship less interesting. I also didn't mind Abigail being more vulnerable with her new powers, but she was insecure throughout the whole book. I also didn't enjoy the introduction to her parents, I felt like they were just added in to throw Abigail off even more. When all I really wanted was to see more Charlie, the ghost Jenny and other old characters. I would have also liked to have gotten to know the new young girl character "Grim" as well, but instead we were given scene after scene of Abigail being incompetent. There also wasn't a twist to this storyline, the characters who felt shady were... surprise! shady. This wasn't bad, it just wasn't great. Not sure if I would read anymore books in this series.
2023
June 14, 2024📱 Thank you to NetGalley and Algonquin Young Readers
October 21, 2023
3 Stars
I had to force myself to finish this one. It seemed too much like previous books in the series, making it predictable. Still, I can't fault the writing or the likable characters.
I had to force myself to finish this one. It seemed too much like previous books in the series, making it predictable. Still, I can't fault the writing or the likable characters.
February 2, 2024
3.5 stars.
I enjoyed it but was a bit underwhelmed. It was nice to return to this world and catch up with these characters but I expected a bit more from character interaction. There was more focus on the plot, which was fine, but it wasn't really what I was looking for from this.
Gorgeous cover.
I enjoyed it but was a bit underwhelmed. It was nice to return to this world and catch up with these characters but I expected a bit more from character interaction. There was more focus on the plot, which was fine, but it wasn't really what I was looking for from this.
Gorgeous cover.
March 8, 2025
Miss Rook is used to being the assistant to private detective, Mr. Jackaby. But now that his ability to see supernatural auras has been passed on to her, she is having trouble taking charge during an investigation. She is completely overwhelmed and can't seem to find her confidence again. Jackaby encourages her to take the reins and let him the assistant, but Miss Rook feels utterly incompetent to handle a supernatural crime investigation. However, when her nearest and dearest are accused of murder, Miss Rook is forced to follow the trail wherever it leads.
I loved this book so much! I really liked the world-building and the way that the supernatural creatures and people are trying to mingle with ordinary humans. The police force is trying to keep track of all the rampant magic in the city, and the city government writes new laws to try to control the magical populace. Most of the supernatural people are harmless, but the police only see threats in every direction.
To see sensitive content in this book, including violence and foul language, check it out on the Screen It First website! https://screenitfirst.com/book/rook-j...
I especially loved Jackaby and Miss Rook and their detective partnership. They are both full of witty remarks and flippant little quips. Jackaby kind of reminded me of Doctor Who in the way that he carelessly meets danger with no plan and silly grin.
I loved Miss Rook's character! She is very introspective, analyzing the clues and analyzing her relationships with people. We get to see her emotional turmoil as she tries to adjust to her new reality with the ability to see auras. She goes on quite an inner journey to find the confidence to trust herself and the courage to trust others.
The writing style is excellent. The plot is mysterious and fun! The mystery really kept me guessing, and I loved all the strange clues. Because there are magical elements in play, it's difficult to tell what is just a normal clue or what is some weird supernatural power at work. There are a lot of moving parts in the plot, and characters with different abilities and secret knowledge. It becomes like this weird game of chess with red herrings all over the place, until you realize that the red herrings are actually the center of the mystery. Such great plot twists!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for a free and honest review. All the opinions stated here are my own true thoughts, and are not influenced by anyone.
I loved this book so much! I really liked the world-building and the way that the supernatural creatures and people are trying to mingle with ordinary humans. The police force is trying to keep track of all the rampant magic in the city, and the city government writes new laws to try to control the magical populace. Most of the supernatural people are harmless, but the police only see threats in every direction.
To see sensitive content in this book, including violence and foul language, check it out on the Screen It First website! https://screenitfirst.com/book/rook-j...
I especially loved Jackaby and Miss Rook and their detective partnership. They are both full of witty remarks and flippant little quips. Jackaby kind of reminded me of Doctor Who in the way that he carelessly meets danger with no plan and silly grin.
I loved Miss Rook's character! She is very introspective, analyzing the clues and analyzing her relationships with people. We get to see her emotional turmoil as she tries to adjust to her new reality with the ability to see auras. She goes on quite an inner journey to find the confidence to trust herself and the courage to trust others.
The writing style is excellent. The plot is mysterious and fun! The mystery really kept me guessing, and I loved all the strange clues. Because there are magical elements in play, it's difficult to tell what is just a normal clue or what is some weird supernatural power at work. There are a lot of moving parts in the plot, and characters with different abilities and secret knowledge. It becomes like this weird game of chess with red herrings all over the place, until you realize that the red herrings are actually the center of the mystery. Such great plot twists!
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for a free and honest review. All the opinions stated here are my own true thoughts, and are not influenced by anyone.
August 29, 2023
2.5 stars rounded up.
I really liked the first and second books in this series. The late 1800s paranormal detectives in New England vibes were absolute perfection. It was funny and quirky, and the characters were all wonderful. I was excited to read this arc when I saw it on NetGalley.
But I gotta say, this installment wasn't as interesting as I thought it'd be. The third and fourth books weren't my favorites, so I had slightly high hopes for this one because the previous one was published six years ago. Maybe the author got his groove back and we'd get our quirky characters again.
Instead, this felt like any old detective book with the addition of paranormal stuff. Nothing really stood out for me at all. Jackaby feels like a side character in this one. And while I love Abigail, she was pretty much depressed the entire time because her paranormal sight overwhelmed her a lot.
I won't lie, I glossed over most of the second half, so I can't even tell you what happened. It wasn't a bad novel. It was just really boring most of the time. A lot of the plot felt like filler for the author to reach his word count.
I think this would've worked so much better as a shorter length Enola Holmes style novel/novella. I'd still recommend the first two novels in this series for a unique and absolutely fun adventure through supernatural late 1800s New England.
With that, I doubt I'll pick up the next book in the series.
Thank you to Algonquin Young Readers and NetGalley for this arc.
I really liked the first and second books in this series. The late 1800s paranormal detectives in New England vibes were absolute perfection. It was funny and quirky, and the characters were all wonderful. I was excited to read this arc when I saw it on NetGalley.
But I gotta say, this installment wasn't as interesting as I thought it'd be. The third and fourth books weren't my favorites, so I had slightly high hopes for this one because the previous one was published six years ago. Maybe the author got his groove back and we'd get our quirky characters again.
Instead, this felt like any old detective book with the addition of paranormal stuff. Nothing really stood out for me at all. Jackaby feels like a side character in this one. And while I love Abigail, she was pretty much depressed the entire time because her paranormal sight overwhelmed her a lot.
I won't lie, I glossed over most of the second half, so I can't even tell you what happened. It wasn't a bad novel. It was just really boring most of the time. A lot of the plot felt like filler for the author to reach his word count.
I think this would've worked so much better as a shorter length Enola Holmes style novel/novella. I'd still recommend the first two novels in this series for a unique and absolutely fun adventure through supernatural late 1800s New England.
With that, I doubt I'll pick up the next book in the series.
Thank you to Algonquin Young Readers and NetGalley for this arc.
November 18, 2023
Another great entry into the Jackaby universe. I love these characters and the world of New Fiddleham, so I was excited we got another adventure. This time focusing on Abigail as she adjusts to her new powers. I really liked that Abigail took the lead in this book, but I really wish we still got more of Jackaby. Him and the other characters (Charlie and Jenny) took a backseat, but I think the novel could have given us more of them while still making this Abigail’s story. Regardless, this was still a really fun read and I hope we get more soon!
December 26, 2022
A new (and I hope not final) addition to the Jackaby series, which you need to read first--despite what the blurb says--but Lucky You coming to them for the first time. This one's my favorite of them all, due to its starring the redoubtable (and titular) Miss Rook. Highly recommended.
August 24, 2023
"Even the cold cobblestones beneath my feet had a life to them, a history....New Fiddleham was alive. But it was also aching" Really liked this one! I read every book in the Jackaby series and loved those, so I was super excited for this one. Of course I pre-ordered it :). I actually forgot I had pre-ordered it, so when it came yesterday I literally squealed with delightful surprise. The only thing better than finally receiving a book you've been waiting for for years is forgetting about said book and when it arrives in the mail you get to re-live and experience all that joy and excitement. Getting high off books is real. Let's dive into this review!
The Plot:
Ritter's storytelling here is at a new level. He's always been a very strong storyteller, and I loved all the humor and magic of Jackaby, but Rook is fresh and goes deeper, darker. Like the previous books, Rook is told in first person and with Abigail as the narrator. However, Abigail is now the Seer; she can see mystical creatures and their magical auras, so it makes sense that her viewpoint and the way she tells this new story changes drastically. I found the evolution of Abigail's narration from the Jackaby series to this recent one highly fascinating. For one, Abigail's narration in Rook has more angst and vivid descriptions. She carries more responsibility and burden now, and her stress, fears, and doubts really shows through. Here's a passage that I found extremely interesting and well-written, and showed Abigail's angst pretty well.
"What? What can you tell me?"
"I don't know!" I screwed my eyes shut out of habit-not that my eyelids blocked out any of the visions. "Nothing! Too many things! Useless things! I can tell that there have been people through here. Just ordinary people. People who were proud and people who were in love and people who felt small and sad and broken. I can see echoes of their nerves and their greed and their eagerness and their stubborn, willful hope. I see your frustration even now and I can see your confidence in us-in me- fading. And I can't blame you. The truth is, I have no idea where to find your necklace, Mr. Talman. I can barely find myself in the mess, most days."
The plot of this book was fast-paced, exciting, and new. I loved every second. Also, the humor is as good as ever!
The Characters:
Abigail, Jackaby, Charlie, Jenny, Lydia Lee, Commissioner Marlowe, Alina (Charlie's sister), and even Douglas the Duck return. Loved these characters with all my heart, so I liked that they came back. Jackaby, of course, is as incorrigible as ever. New characters join our old cast, such as Agent Kit and Agent Garabrand from the Bureau of Curiosities, Inspector Dupin, a little girl named Grim, and Abigail's parents. I honestly don't remember if Inspector Dupin was in the Jackaby series before, but I really liked his tough and frank personality, as well as his interactions with Abigail. I liked all these newcomers well enough, and that scene of Abigail's parents meeting her found family on Augur Lane is a hilarious gem.
This goes into my next point, though, of what I wished this book had: more time with the old characters.
Jackaby is a still a big character, though he kind of disappears near the end and is then briefly mentioned in the last chapter. Charlie has more time in this book, as he and Abigail work together to solve the mystery.
But I need more of Jenny Cavanaugh! This sweet but badass ghost was one of my favorite characters in the series, and I wished she made more of an appearance in Rook. Jenny does have several appearances in the earlier parts of the book, which I adored. But I wanted more domestic fluff between her and Jackaby. I shipped them so hard in the Jackaby series, and they deserve their happily ever after, so I was a little disappointed that there aren't too many scenes of the two of them together. The scenes we do get of the two lovebirds are lovely and so worth getting the book for, of course, but I wanted Jenny to be part of the action more in this one.
Also, I expected more drama with Abigail's parents showing up, but tbh they really don't have much scenes. Still, the complications and self-doubt that Abigail goes through because of their arrival is interesting to read.
Overall, I highly enjoyed this book and want a sequel!! I don't care if it takes another six years to get published, but a sequel will be so amazing and perfect. Rook does leave off at a kind of cliffhanger, so fingers crossed that there will be more adventures with Abigail as the Seer.
-4.8 stars
The Plot:
Ritter's storytelling here is at a new level. He's always been a very strong storyteller, and I loved all the humor and magic of Jackaby, but Rook is fresh and goes deeper, darker. Like the previous books, Rook is told in first person and with Abigail as the narrator. However, Abigail is now the Seer; she can see mystical creatures and their magical auras, so it makes sense that her viewpoint and the way she tells this new story changes drastically. I found the evolution of Abigail's narration from the Jackaby series to this recent one highly fascinating. For one, Abigail's narration in Rook has more angst and vivid descriptions. She carries more responsibility and burden now, and her stress, fears, and doubts really shows through. Here's a passage that I found extremely interesting and well-written, and showed Abigail's angst pretty well.
"What? What can you tell me?"
"I don't know!" I screwed my eyes shut out of habit-not that my eyelids blocked out any of the visions. "Nothing! Too many things! Useless things! I can tell that there have been people through here. Just ordinary people. People who were proud and people who were in love and people who felt small and sad and broken. I can see echoes of their nerves and their greed and their eagerness and their stubborn, willful hope. I see your frustration even now and I can see your confidence in us-in me- fading. And I can't blame you. The truth is, I have no idea where to find your necklace, Mr. Talman. I can barely find myself in the mess, most days."
The plot of this book was fast-paced, exciting, and new. I loved every second. Also, the humor is as good as ever!
The Characters:
Abigail, Jackaby, Charlie, Jenny, Lydia Lee, Commissioner Marlowe, Alina (Charlie's sister), and even Douglas the Duck return. Loved these characters with all my heart, so I liked that they came back. Jackaby, of course, is as incorrigible as ever. New characters join our old cast, such as Agent Kit and Agent Garabrand from the Bureau of Curiosities, Inspector Dupin, a little girl named Grim, and Abigail's parents. I honestly don't remember if Inspector Dupin was in the Jackaby series before, but I really liked his tough and frank personality, as well as his interactions with Abigail. I liked all these newcomers well enough, and that scene of Abigail's parents meeting her found family on Augur Lane is a hilarious gem.
This goes into my next point, though, of what I wished this book had: more time with the old characters.
Jackaby is a still a big character, though he kind of disappears near the end and is then briefly mentioned in the last chapter. Charlie has more time in this book, as he and Abigail work together to solve the mystery.
But I need more of Jenny Cavanaugh! This sweet but badass ghost was one of my favorite characters in the series, and I wished she made more of an appearance in Rook. Jenny does have several appearances in the earlier parts of the book, which I adored. But I wanted more domestic fluff between her and Jackaby. I shipped them so hard in the Jackaby series, and they deserve their happily ever after, so I was a little disappointed that there aren't too many scenes of the two of them together. The scenes we do get of the two lovebirds are lovely and so worth getting the book for, of course, but I wanted Jenny to be part of the action more in this one.
Also, I expected more drama with Abigail's parents showing up, but tbh they really don't have much scenes. Still, the complications and self-doubt that Abigail goes through because of their arrival is interesting to read.
Overall, I highly enjoyed this book and want a sequel!! I don't care if it takes another six years to get published, but a sequel will be so amazing and perfect. Rook does leave off at a kind of cliffhanger, so fingers crossed that there will be more adventures with Abigail as the Seer.
-4.8 stars
August 20, 2023
The whole gang is back in a BIG WAY and I'm overjoyed that the adventures and supernatural mysteries and mayhem are continuing! This new edition to the series was just as fast-paced, addictive and hard to put down as its predecessors. "Rook" returns to the "one-crime-at-a-time" vibe of the first book, before the overarching story took over the Jackaby series.
Jackaby has been one of those series that I recommend, loan out and gift to people constantly because it appeals to such a wide variety of readers. Whether you love a buddy mystery, supernatural adventure, slow burn romance, or fantasy world building, these books excel at all of it.
After the events of "The Dire King" seemed to wrap up this addictive series, I had little hope of ever going along on another adventure with my favorite supernatural Scooby gang. Thank you, William Ritter, for breathing new life into this series by turning it on its head and giving Abigail Rook Jackaby's former supernatural abilities. An inspired and sublime premise! Now we've got a strong female leading the team who are all sorting out their new roles and it couldn't be more interesting. Now more YA female readers will be attracted to the series as well.
I would definitely recommend reading all four Jackaby books before attempting this one. It's a detour you'll be thrilled to have taken. There are even more ghosts, fairy creatures, crimes to solve and parents to duck in this story. Speaking of ducks. I'm so glad my favorite mallard got some good scenes in "Rook" too. I need Douglas to become human again for an epic hero move sometime soon (pretty please?) and some more lovey scenes with Abby & Charlie and Jackaby & Jenny would also keep this girl happy as well. I love a good "kissing book!"
I can't wait to see where the series goes from here! It is and will remain an auto-buy for me! FIVE STARS! Thank you for the opportunity to read this ARC.
Jackaby has been one of those series that I recommend, loan out and gift to people constantly because it appeals to such a wide variety of readers. Whether you love a buddy mystery, supernatural adventure, slow burn romance, or fantasy world building, these books excel at all of it.
After the events of "The Dire King" seemed to wrap up this addictive series, I had little hope of ever going along on another adventure with my favorite supernatural Scooby gang. Thank you, William Ritter, for breathing new life into this series by turning it on its head and giving Abigail Rook Jackaby's former supernatural abilities. An inspired and sublime premise! Now we've got a strong female leading the team who are all sorting out their new roles and it couldn't be more interesting. Now more YA female readers will be attracted to the series as well.
I would definitely recommend reading all four Jackaby books before attempting this one. It's a detour you'll be thrilled to have taken. There are even more ghosts, fairy creatures, crimes to solve and parents to duck in this story. Speaking of ducks. I'm so glad my favorite mallard got some good scenes in "Rook" too. I need Douglas to become human again for an epic hero move sometime soon (pretty please?) and some more lovey scenes with Abby & Charlie and Jackaby & Jenny would also keep this girl happy as well. I love a good "kissing book!"
I can't wait to see where the series goes from here! It is and will remain an auto-buy for me! FIVE STARS! Thank you for the opportunity to read this ARC.
August 22, 2023
I love love love the Jackaby series by William Ritter. So I was thrilled when I saw that ROOK would be a stand-alone novel set in this world. Being reunited with these beloved, quirky, smart characters is one of the best feelings that is indescribable. I was also so happy this is a standalone because I was able to fully appreciate this scary adventure that Abigail and Jackaby embark on. Though I wouldn't say not to more standalones.....
This book was just perfectly crafted with danger and the BEST twists and turns and such an imaginative and immersive story. The paranormal elements are so unique, but also well described so that I could picture everything without being bogged down with details or left feeling lost and confused. I highly recommend it for other cozy fantasy lovers. I was on the edge of my seat and always looking forward to the few moments that I could read each day, but didn't feel the gut wrenching stress of a longer series. However I again feel bereft after being reunited with these fabulous characters.
This book was just perfectly crafted with danger and the BEST twists and turns and such an imaginative and immersive story. The paranormal elements are so unique, but also well described so that I could picture everything without being bogged down with details or left feeling lost and confused. I highly recommend it for other cozy fantasy lovers. I was on the edge of my seat and always looking forward to the few moments that I could read each day, but didn't feel the gut wrenching stress of a longer series. However I again feel bereft after being reunited with these fabulous characters.
November 21, 2023
This story was exactly what I needed to fill the void after the events of the Jackaby series. I adored the supernatural take on Sherlock Holmes-esque tale. These books really do stand out.
Rook takes place about six months after the end of the Jackaby series. Abigail has inherited the sight and has been trying to adjust. Even after the prolonged amount of time, she does not quite have it figured out. This is refreshingly realistic. This book could stand on it’s own, but I would highly recommend reading the other four books that take place in this world in order to become familiar with all of the characters since most of them do make a reappearance - Douglas too!
The story includes murder, mayhem, betrayal, twists and turns. The elements of mystery and character development are divine. I love Jackaby trying to be normal.
This is perfect for fans of paranormal mystery.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Algonquin Young Readers for a digital arc of the book. The opinions expressed are honest and my own.
Rook takes place about six months after the end of the Jackaby series. Abigail has inherited the sight and has been trying to adjust. Even after the prolonged amount of time, she does not quite have it figured out. This is refreshingly realistic. This book could stand on it’s own, but I would highly recommend reading the other four books that take place in this world in order to become familiar with all of the characters since most of them do make a reappearance - Douglas too!
The story includes murder, mayhem, betrayal, twists and turns. The elements of mystery and character development are divine. I love Jackaby trying to be normal.
This is perfect for fans of paranormal mystery.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Algonquin Young Readers for a digital arc of the book. The opinions expressed are honest and my own.
August 25, 2023
The Jackaby series is one of my favorites…so I of course was thrilled when Algonquin sent me of copy of Rook! It was so nice to step back into a world that has characters that I just love so much.
Rook takes place a few months after the events of The Dire King. And even though the book can be read as a standalone I highly recommend reading the 4 books in the Jackaby series. It will make this book even more enjoyable! Rook has qualities (the best way I describe it is Dr. Who meet Sherlock) that made the original seres as lovable as it is. It was great to see how Abigail has grown with her new abilities. And of course getting (again) to see the character we all know and love. This book was just so so good!
While I know this is a standalone…I hope we get to see these characters again *fingers crossed!*
Thank you to the publisher & NetGalley for the copy!
I received a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review
July 16, 2023
I received an advanced copy through Giveaways by the publisher Algonquin. I am extremely grateful to them!
This book is a continuation of the wonderful Jackaby series, which I'd also like to suggest. I was continually impressed by the story development and the lovable characters. Some new, some from Jackaby.
I was hoping for more of the same Jackaby, which I was not disappointed despite him not being the central character.
I was mesmerized by Abigail's story, with it's complications and her ability. She is deserving of her role as protagonist and central character in New Fiddleham!
This book is a continuation of the wonderful Jackaby series, which I'd also like to suggest. I was continually impressed by the story development and the lovable characters. Some new, some from Jackaby.
I was hoping for more of the same Jackaby, which I was not disappointed despite him not being the central character.
I was mesmerized by Abigail's story, with it's complications and her ability. She is deserving of her role as protagonist and central character in New Fiddleham!
August 23, 2023
I really loved that this book shows the messy end of a "final battle". Obviously it's a fantasy, but it makes it more real. Sure, there was a big evil that was defeated in The Dire King, but it didn't magically make the world perfect. A lot of stories will show there was rebuilding and things at the end, but then treat it as nothing bad ever happened again, it was peaceful. This didn't. It shows the realistic side that bad things will still happen and it takes work. Everyone won't just automatically get along and work together. Work has to be put in, an effort has to be made. It's messy. I loved it.
September 1, 2023
Even though The Dire King left us with a satisfying conclusion to the Jackaby series, I’m absolutely thrilled that Ritter’s little grey cells got to work so that we could spend more time in New Fiddleham.
This truly is one of the greatest series I have ever had the pleasure of reading. Rook picks up pretty much where we left off in The Dire King and it feels like we never left.
Readers are immediately welcomed home by Ritter’s prose and flair for creating jaw dropping mysteries.
Even though this too has a great conclusion, I know I would immediately snatch up another story if we ever get blessed by more books in this series.
This truly is one of the greatest series I have ever had the pleasure of reading. Rook picks up pretty much where we left off in The Dire King and it feels like we never left.
Readers are immediately welcomed home by Ritter’s prose and flair for creating jaw dropping mysteries.
Even though this too has a great conclusion, I know I would immediately snatch up another story if we ever get blessed by more books in this series.
Read
September 1, 2023Graded By: Mandy C.
Cover Story: Montell Jordan
BFF Charm: Platinum
Swoonworthy Scale: 3
Talky Talk: Will’s Wit
Bonus Factors: Independence, Anti-TEABS
Anti-Bonus Factor: Secret Government Goons
Relationship Status: Risen From the Dead
Read the full book report here.
Cover Story: Montell Jordan
BFF Charm: Platinum
Swoonworthy Scale: 3
Talky Talk: Will’s Wit
Bonus Factors: Independence, Anti-TEABS
Anti-Bonus Factor: Secret Government Goons
Relationship Status: Risen From the Dead
Read the full book report here.
October 17, 2023
WE DON’T GET TO SEE THE ENGAGEMENT OR THE WEDDING?????? WHAT
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 9, 2023
This was so fun! I loved being back in the Jackaby world, and truthfully, I could read an infinite number of their adventures. Perfect for those who loved the original Jackaby books and for those who like Lockwood & Co.
September 3, 2023
Jackaby’s back!
And so is Abigail, with her newfound power. She struggles to feel competent at using it, and Jackaby stands by her as she moves back into the public eye. So great to be back in this world!
And so is Abigail, with her newfound power. She struggles to feel competent at using it, and Jackaby stands by her as she moves back into the public eye. So great to be back in this world!
August 2, 2023
More reviews (and no fluff) on the blog http://surrealtalvi.wordpress.com/
This series is a true joy and it was with welcome relief to see the story continued after the arc-ending events of the last four books. Ritter has really hit his stride with effortless writing that is witty, engaging, droll, and just pure fun. This is one of those rare cases when the act of reading is just as enjoyable as following the plot itself.Story: The world has been saved! But several of Abigail's friends died in the process. Of course, death is just a setback and fortunately Charlie and Jackaby failed to remain in that unfortunate condition. There's just one wee side-effect: at Jackaby's death his powers of the sight transferred to Abigail. Now, six months later, she is learning to deal with the overwhelming sensations and information overload over seeing the truth in the world. But this buttercup needs to suck it up because there's been a murder and it looks like her boyfriend Charlie's group of canines are inexorably involved. Hot on the heels of the murder comes a pair of government agents determined to keep the small town of New Fiddleham's supernatural problems under control.
The regulars are all here again: from the crotchety police chief, to ghost Jenny, duck Douglas, to Charlie's eccentric canine family. But there are a crop of new characters that are just as fascinating and about whom whom Jackaby can make the wittiest bon mots (sotte voce, of course). There are the two government men/detectives: an uptight Dudley-Do-Right junior and a laissez fair senior. Both are there to ensure that New Fiddleham's supernatural residents are firmly catalogued and under control. But the real treat is Abigail's snooty British parents who have travelled all the way to America to discover how Abigail is doing in her paleontology digs (boy, are they going to be surprised). They amusingly get in the way all the time as Abigail is forced to use her new abilities to track down the murders/disappearances of supernatural beings in the town.
Although Jackaby doesn't have his ability, he still takes a prominent seat as a mentor/teacher to Abigail to help her use her abilities. I like that author Ritter chose to tackle this as Abigail learning to use her abilities as Abigail and not Jackaby. Which makes Jackaby often not so helpful (in his own amusing way) but very helpful at the same time. It makes for great reading.
In all, this murder mystery is a self-contained story arc and a very enjoyable read. I almost wish I had the audio version so I could have both the New England and the British accents heard. But that said, I highly recommend this fun series. Reviewed from an advance reader copy provided by the publisher.
October 1, 2023
Thank you to Netgalley and Algonquin Young Reader's for providing me with a digital ARC of this book!
William Ritter’s Rook is a blessed return to form with its quirky, mystery-solving duo of Abigail Rook and R.F. Jackaby that demonstrates the true strength of the original Jackaby series. This novel picks up several months after the previous book, where an inter-dimensional war was waged, the veil between New Fiddleham and the other side was left partially open, and Abigail Rook inherited the title of the Seer from Jackaby. While it does essentially operate as a “standalone mystery” within the world Ritter has created, my first attempt at reading Rook—having only read the first book in the series—felt like jumping into a television series at the halfway point, i.e. watching Teen Wolf for the first time but starting with season 3B.
After holing herself up in 929 Augur Lane for months trying to understand and test her new powers, Abigail Rook returns to her role as a detective and is shocked to find how much supernatural chaos has been happening on the streets of New Fiddleham. Tasked with a new case, it is up to Abigail Rook and R.F. Jackaby to solve a string of homicides and missing persons cases that threatens the new, tenuous dynamic between humans and the supernatural world.
I truly enjoyed seeing the way in which Abigail Rook is struggling to adjust to her new role as the Seer and the shift in dynamic between her and Jackaby, now that he has lost the sight. (The Watson has become the Holmes, if you will.) Their different personalities and manners of investigating have been a fun draw to this series for me and I appreciated that the change in the role of Seer did not completely alter their dynamic and, frankly, further enhanced their friendship.
The original four books in the Jackaby series have their highs and lows and, while this may not technically be the fifth installment, I would consider it among the highs of the world Ritter created. These books shine when focused on the nitty-gritty of investigating odd supernatural mysteries, the fun dynamic between Rook and Jackaby, and their complicated love of the city of New Fiddleham and people—and creatures—who have made their home there.
William Ritter’s Rook is a blessed return to form with its quirky, mystery-solving duo of Abigail Rook and R.F. Jackaby that demonstrates the true strength of the original Jackaby series. This novel picks up several months after the previous book, where an inter-dimensional war was waged, the veil between New Fiddleham and the other side was left partially open, and Abigail Rook inherited the title of the Seer from Jackaby. While it does essentially operate as a “standalone mystery” within the world Ritter has created, my first attempt at reading Rook—having only read the first book in the series—felt like jumping into a television series at the halfway point, i.e. watching Teen Wolf for the first time but starting with season 3B.
After holing herself up in 929 Augur Lane for months trying to understand and test her new powers, Abigail Rook returns to her role as a detective and is shocked to find how much supernatural chaos has been happening on the streets of New Fiddleham. Tasked with a new case, it is up to Abigail Rook and R.F. Jackaby to solve a string of homicides and missing persons cases that threatens the new, tenuous dynamic between humans and the supernatural world.
I truly enjoyed seeing the way in which Abigail Rook is struggling to adjust to her new role as the Seer and the shift in dynamic between her and Jackaby, now that he has lost the sight. (The Watson has become the Holmes, if you will.) Their different personalities and manners of investigating have been a fun draw to this series for me and I appreciated that the change in the role of Seer did not completely alter their dynamic and, frankly, further enhanced their friendship.
The original four books in the Jackaby series have their highs and lows and, while this may not technically be the fifth installment, I would consider it among the highs of the world Ritter created. These books shine when focused on the nitty-gritty of investigating odd supernatural mysteries, the fun dynamic between Rook and Jackaby, and their complicated love of the city of New Fiddleham and people—and creatures—who have made their home there.
December 7, 2023
3.5 stars ~ [6.63/10]
It's been a wee while since I read the Jackaby series in full and, even though it wasn't one of those series that digs deep in your bones, I always remembered it quite well and quite fondly. I was excited to see that Ritter had decided to revisit these characters and this was another fun adventure, but I don't think it will stay with me as well as the previous books. The draw for me was always the eccentric figure of Jackaby and he kind of took more of a back seat in this in this book. I like Abigail as a character and I've enjoyed her arc throughout the series, but for a series that relies on procedural tropes - I don't think it makes sense to deviate wildly from the norm. Still entertaining though and I will continue reading if there are more books to come.
It's been a wee while since I read the Jackaby series in full and, even though it wasn't one of those series that digs deep in your bones, I always remembered it quite well and quite fondly. I was excited to see that Ritter had decided to revisit these characters and this was another fun adventure, but I don't think it will stay with me as well as the previous books. The draw for me was always the eccentric figure of Jackaby and he kind of took more of a back seat in this in this book. I like Abigail as a character and I've enjoyed her arc throughout the series, but for a series that relies on procedural tropes - I don't think it makes sense to deviate wildly from the norm. Still entertaining though and I will continue reading if there are more books to come.
August 2, 2023
Advance copy from NetGalley
It's been five years since the last Jackaby book came out. I thought the series was finished. After re-reading the books to my husband, I stumbled on the news that this one was coming out. It picks up shortly after the whiz-bang finale of The Dire King, and the aftermath makes a lot of sense the way it plays out here. I don't know if he plans to write more, but this book opened new doors for sure, and I hope Ritter continues with it. It was great to spend time with these characters again, and the mystery this time around was a good one!
It's been five years since the last Jackaby book came out. I thought the series was finished. After re-reading the books to my husband, I stumbled on the news that this one was coming out. It picks up shortly after the whiz-bang finale of The Dire King, and the aftermath makes a lot of sense the way it plays out here. I don't know if he plans to write more, but this book opened new doors for sure, and I hope Ritter continues with it. It was great to spend time with these characters again, and the mystery this time around was a good one!
September 9, 2023
Reading Rook was like coming home to someplace I didn't realize I missed so much! Rook follows the story of Abigail, the new Seer of New Fiddleham. It is a companion novel to the fantastic Jackaby saga, but as it is a standalone you can read it with no issue!
I'm not gonna lie, I didn’t realize how worried I was about Abigail and Jackaby until I read Rook. I love these books so much and the characters feel like old friends! Rook contains an entire world full of magic and mayhem that practically jumps off the page. Its pages are rich with mystery, humor, and just pure FUN!
I'm not gonna lie, I didn’t realize how worried I was about Abigail and Jackaby until I read Rook. I love these books so much and the characters feel like old friends! Rook contains an entire world full of magic and mayhem that practically jumps off the page. Its pages are rich with mystery, humor, and just pure FUN!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 202 reviews