An often funny, at times bittersweet novel, Always You, Edina tells the story of endlessly good-natured child narrator Bonnie as she negotiates family and school life in 1960's Britain. Most memorable is her crush on popular classmate Joanna Bayliss, who is alternately encouraging and dismissive, and Bonnie's love for the Edina of the title, her darling, glamorous aunt, whose relationship with other family members proves to be far from simple. Through Bonnie, VG Lee beautifully explores the inner life of a clever but naive pre-teen, and is particularly perceptive about the nature of burgeoning romantic love during childhood, and a child's growing understanding of the complexities of adult relationships. As you'd expect from Lee, this is a warm-hearted novel, and at the centre of its warm heart is Bonnie's relationship with her cantankerous raisin-eyed Gran, whom, in the present day, 50 year-old Bonnie visits in a residential home. There are revelations and surprises to come from these meetings, and one in particular had me cheering out loud for Bonnie.
VG Lee is the author of six novels and two collections of short stories. In 2012, Lee was nominated for a Stonewall Award for writing and in 2014 she won the Ultimate Planet Award for Best Established Author. Her fifth novel, Mr Oliver’s Object of Desire was runner up for the YLVA Publishing Literary Prize for Fiction 2017. In March 2026, Muswell Press published 'OUR SHADOW SELVES' a psychological thriller which marked a change of direction for Lee's writing.
This book was such a wonderful surprise. I picked it up after seeing it on one of my favorite booktuber’s favorite books of 2019 video. I thought it sounded really good but I wasn’t expecting it to be a 5 star stunner. It probably won’t be for everyone as it is a really slow paced slice of life novel narrated by a young girl. There’s not all that much plot but it is beautifully written and I can’t wait to read more by this author.
This was such a heartbreaking book. I really enjoyed reading it, but I felt so depressed the entire time. All the characters were well-developed and felt so real. I cycled between hating everyone and wanting to cry for all of them. All of the characters are extremely flawed but their actions and reactions felt very realistic. And though she sometimes annoyed me, Bonnie was a good narrator. It was really interesting to see how she interpreted everything since she wasn't quite old enough to understand everything that was going on. It was also interesting to have a queer protagonist in a historical novel who wasn't ashamed of being gay or tried to hide it. It's something that I rarely see in the historical fiction I read (which makes sense given LGBT history) but it was a nice change and made sense given that Bonnie is only 10.
This book isn't for everyone; it has a slow pace and not much happens. However, it's definitely a new favorite and will probably be one of the best books I read all year.
I agree with all the 5 * reviews of this novel. It is a joy to read, moving and funny – here’s a short quote that made me laugh out loud:
I’m named Bonnie after Scarlett O’Hara’s daughter in Gone With the Wind…Mum read the first half whilst expecting and then stopped. She said she didn’t care for its sexual connotations…A few years later she read the rest of it and came into the kitchen in tears. ‘Bonnie dies,’ she told Gran. ‘Oh, I think she’ll out live the lot of us.’ Gran didn’t even look up from her crossword. ‘Not our Bonnie – the Bonnie in Gone With the Wind…’ Dad said, ‘It’s not real, Eileen. It’s not like All Quiet on the Western Front.’
This made me laugh on all kinds of levels, but I so felt for Bonnie’s mother. But then, all the characters in this novel are so well drawn and the writing is so fresh and witty, just a great read.
A tender evocation of childhood in 1950's Birmingham, with an undertow of gentle humour. Lee clearly likes her characters and we can't help but liking them too. A lovely piece of writing.
The plot twists are quite transparent but that doesn't distract from the enjoyment.
[minor spoilers alert] My only grudge is that (unless I somehow missed it) we are never told how Bonnie's parents and uncle die or why she and her cousin Susan are estranged.
I started out loving this book so much that I just don't understand what happened to my passion for it. V.G. Lee is definitely a great writer and Bonnie and Aunt Ed are delightful characters. I think I will revisit this story some day soon when I have more time to read it and give it the patience it deserves.
A woman recounts herself as an eccentric 11 year old and how drastically her family was effected by her vivacious and outgoing aunt Edina. Lee paints a vivid picture with her words. With them we are transported to the sights and sounds of 1960s Birmingham. Filled with rich characters and an engaging story, I would easily read more from this author.
I wasnt expecting to en joy this book as much as i did (maybe the front cover wasnt quite what I would have chosen - though having read the book its perfect!) I so enjoyed reading this - especially as it is a very witty and imaginatyive look at growing up in the 1960s - a much more working class family than my own, but so many things identical - making me realise how much more different ev eryone is from each other now - you can walk into a house a know loadds about whose living there just from the look of it. To a certain extent that is the same in this book - there are 2 kinds of home ... aspiring rich and ordinary and they are beautifully described, as are all the family. There is real tyragedy in the lives of this family which is gradually revealed as the book proceeds - done very well by the present being her visits to her grandmother and then long flashbacks to her days growing up, not all in date order at all. Set in Birmingham, it reminded me a little of the wonderful memoir by Kit de Waal (who I went to hear recently at Manchester literature Festival)
Really worth reading - and I had never hear of this author before!
I can’t believe I’ve read another 5 star book this year. Normally, they’re an absolute rarity. After finishing the last few sentences through teary eyes I was like, “Right, that’s another 4.5 in the books. Excellent.” But then I thought, “Wait, what am I stupid? Nothing’s missing.” It has to be a 5. Because. nothing. is. missing.
Another self-contained coming-of-age, absolutely brimming with sweet, hilarious moments, beautiful writing, heartbreak, and lovable and infuriating characters. I found myself simultaneously shaking in anger and laughing out loud over and over.
🧶 Did I cry? Well almost
🌸 Would I read it again?I plan to.
🫖 Who would I recommend this to? Do you like the 60s, Britain, or have an infuriating sister-in-law?
👠 What is its seven deadly sin? Each character represents one of them which makes the book absolutely sinless.
At certain points this story seemed a bit too private and personal to let me in and I wondered why I kept on reading BUT then i got it. I started to recognise and remember what it is like to be a child and not have the full picture of family secrets. I recalled what it was like to be dazzled by adults who gave me morsels of attention and how they eventually morphed into fleshed out human beings as I grew older. I loved Gran keeping it together and our 11 year old protagonist being a quirky odd ball, those qualities you wish life didn't squeeze out of you with age.
Always You, Edina is a warm and deeply moving coming-of-age novel that beautifully captures childhood innocence, family complexity, and first love. Bonnie is a wonderfully believable narrator, kind, observant, and emotionally rich, whose journey through 1960s Britain feels honest and heartfelt. Themes of identity, memory, and the quiet complexities of relationships are woven naturally throughout the story. VG Lee’s writing is tender and perceptive, creating characters that feel real long after the final page.
Always you,Edina is a haunting book. We meet the central character, Bonnie Benson, as a child and as an adult. She is an endearing and vulnerable character in both guises with a sharp eye. Her thoughts and observations stayed in my mind long after I closed the book, as did the images of family life which V G Lee so skillfully evokes. This is a well observed and touching novel which I was truly sorry to finish. Ms Lee writes with wit and generosity.
I actually enjoyed this quite a bit. The emotional depth surprised me, especially in the second half. Edina feels real in a lot of ways, messy but relatable. The writing flows nicely most of the time, and there are some really touching moments. It’s not perfect, a few parts could’ve been tighter, but overall it’s a solid, heartfelt read.
Quick take: Always You, Edina is a breakneck action read that never lets you catch your breath. What worked: pacing that moves like a freight train and a villain with real menace. What didn't: the dialogue is stiff and the hero is a bit of a generic tough guy. Recommend for readers who want adrenaline on a long flight, skip for anyone who cares about nuance.
I devoured this and found it to be a glorious read. Edina is a horrifically wonderful creation! First book I have read by this author but it certainly left me wanting more. Most excellent!