Having read and studied a lot on the matter, I commend Stewart for providing a good introductory overview that is mostly fair, objective, and informative in addressing the seemingly neverending conflict between the Israelis and the Palestinians.
Looking back at the history of what transpired after World War II, it is hard not to imagine whether peace would have been possible if two scenarios had played out: 1) if Israel had offered to share jurisdiction with the Arabs in controlling the Old City (Jerusalem) after the 1948-1949 war; and 2) if Israel had followed UN mandates to return the occupied territories of Gaza, the West Bank, and the Golan Heights to Arab control after the Six-Day War in 1967.
As neither happened, both sides share blame for the continued unrest, and both have committed atrocities over the decades before and after the establishment of the state of Israel. Ending terrorism from Hamas and Hezbollah is necessary for any lasting peace. However, it is not antisemitic to condemn Israel’s extremist policies over the decades with their expansion of illegal settlements and their continued confiscation of Palestinian land and property, oftentimes using the Israeli courts and legal system to oppress the Palestinians under an apartheid system of exploitation.
As the current tragedy unfolds since October of 2023, it is also not antisemitic to look clearly at what’s happening: nothing justifies the policies of Netanyahu’s regime and their continued disproportionate ruthlessness that amounts to genocide against the Palestinians, many of whom are children.
Again, I want to reiterate: condemning the Israeli government’s actions of oppressing the Palestinians is not antisemitic. Instead, it is activism that seeks to end anti-exploitation and anti-genocide. The world is witnessing horrific crimes committed against the Palestinians, and sadly any criticism of the Israel’s policies is too often falsely projected by extremists as antisemitism.
The Jewish people have a right to live in their homeland in peace, but that will never happen until the Palestinians are given the same opportunity. Much work will be required to overcome the madness, and no easy solution will recompense all the bloodshed, past and present, but no future is possible until the bloodshed stops.