I read Joker and Luthor at the same time. Despite having the same creative team on both, I enjoyed the former yet disliked the latter. So what gives?
Both focus on the villains as the protagonists, with the usual heroes—Batman and Superman—as their antagonists. Before Joker, I wasn’t sure if I liked Brian Azzarello’s writing, but he nails it here. He doesn’t explain why Joker got freed from Arkham Asylum—he is a criminal after all—but he does explain just one part of the Joker through the narrator, a henchman named Jonny Frost. Nailing this one aspect of the Joker does enough to carry the rest of his mayhem, and the narrative distance from the madman does the story good. Even other villains have a hard time with the Joker, and Azarello writes Jonny Frost’s doomed loyalty well.
The problem with Luthor is that it has to be told from Lex’s viewpoint. He’s an egomaniac who guards his secrets, so everything is told through his perspective, and the insight that a Jonny Frost-type character could give is missing. Additionally, Joker benefits from layered storytelling—Frost clarifies certain situations, but he’s in the dark on others. Meanwhile, I missed parts of Luthor by tuning out his monologuing and apparently being dense regarding visual cues. There’s even an amusing moment where a nude Lex Luthor has a giant speech bubble over his manhood (visual cue averted!). Alas, I have that now boring opinion where I think Superman is boring, but I generally like his villains, as they’re scheming to fly kryptonite missiles and the like into his Superchin. In Luthor though, Superman is hardly around, and the bald man is kinda dull when he’s just being a seedy capitalist. Call me crazy, but the Union is not an enticing villain, and when Superman finally collides with Luthor, he glares at him silently through a window. Yup, that’s it.
This isn’t to say everything in Luthor falls short of Joker. I preferred the art in the former, as Heath Ledger seems to have shifted this era’s take on the clown. Meanwhile, I appreciated how Superman is drawn with Luthor’s skew: He looks down on humanity with a snarl and sneering red eyes. It’s a nice touch, but unfortunately, artist Lee Bermejo missed out on the chance to skew the Joker’s view of Batman… if only for a few panels. Still, the misses in Luthor are often story-related. A couple of times, Azarello brushes up against the notion of Luthor’s theology, but stops short of what could be an interesting view of the world with Superman in the mix. Maybe if he’d nailed other parts of Luthor’s viewpoint, I wouldn’t have rabbit trailed into what I’d like to see instead. One star for Luthor; four for Joker.