*4 Stars*
Summary: The first anthology I’ve read that I actually liked most of the stories in! So refreshing to read about these classics remade with Latino/Hispanic characters. I enjoyed about 11 of the stories here, and definitely plan on getting my hands on a physical copy. There are a lot of unique takes and remixes on the sources, more about each specifically below!
Shame and Social Media (Pride and Prejudice):
4.5 stars
Off to a good start! I don’t know if it’s because I know and love the P&P story but this remix was super cute! This was written through transcripts of vlogs and takes place in a sci-fi future where people live in a massive ship on their way to a new planet. I would love a full length novel written in prose about this, maybe even just a novella! That way we could get to learn more about Darcy, since this relies heavily on the source text, I think. Still super cute with great topics discussed.
Break in Case of Persephone (Myth of Hades and Persephone):
2.5 stars
This story was really rather mid, unfortunately. The world building was very confusing, and there really wasn’t any explanation to it which didn’t help. It was some weird combination of sci-fi tech with mythology…? It didn’t work in the way this was written, in my opinion. There was a lot of lore that was needed and didn't get explained. Apparently Persephone and Demeter are reincarnations? Or descendants? Or magic users? I've got no clue! How did the curse of the pomegranate even happen? I also thought that the character development was a bit rushed, for both of the MCs and their relationship.
Thornfield (Jane Eyre):
5 stars
I’ve never read Jane Eyre, but I absolutely loved this story, so I’ll have to pick it up! The magic system was great, as were the characters and the world they live in. It all felt very real, and I would love to read what happens next to these characters. In such a short amount of time the author had me caring about them, worrying for their lives, and creeped out by the world!
La Cotorra y el Flamboyán (The Nightingale and the Rose):
4 stars
Another source I’m not familiar with, but I liked this one! It didn’t have a happy ending which I’m 100% mad about lol, but they do include hope for the future of the characters. This one had a neat magic system, with shapeshifters and evil witches and even a Snow White-esque theme to it. I would also love for this story to continue!
Goldi and the Three Bodies (Goldilocks and the Three Bears):
1 star
The first big disappointment lol. It’s not badly written, but it most definitely just isn’t my taste. It’s a vampire story, and the escalation of violence was so quick I almost had whiplash. We’re not meant to like the MC (I think), which is fine, but I want her to get her comeuppance, and she doesn’t in the timeline of the story, so. I would definitely read a spinoff book about her friend learning she’s a vampire and having to fight and take her down. Sign me up for that story!
This Mortal Coil (Hamlet):
1 star
Yeah, I don’t know what happened here. The story felt very macho-man, poorly written, and very info-dumpy, especially for a short story. There was a lot of telling over showing, making everything that happened super dull and boring to read about, even when they were talking about adultery and murder and political conspiracies and pregnancies like ugh I just could not care, because apparently the MC couldn’t either! There were no emotions on the page at all, and oh my gosh — this takes place in a futuristic society living on Mars. Hebrew and English are still languages in this time period, but not… Spanish? Every time the characters would speak “Spanish” it was written in a whitewashed way, like “grasyas” instead of gracias and “te kyero miho” instead of te quiero mijo, or “yo tammen” instead of yo tambien. I literally could not fathom WHY the author chose to write it this way, I ground my teeth every time it happened. Which was a lot. And I’ve had experience transforming Spanish into a fantasy dialect, it’s 100% possible to do so while keeping the soul of the language!!! Also, the character randomly had a pompadour pftttt. And just the cherry on top was that you could just tell this was written by a man. I’ll leave it with this quote:
”The weeks went by. School, work, sex. Humans fall so easily into routine, which blots out emotional spikes and mysteries. Occasionally, I would make a half hearted attempt at understanding the strange rectangle of plastic my father left me, but my time was occupied by love, final exams, the need to fool those I mistrusted.” CONTEXT: His father died a month ago and he suspects his uncle. Is he going to do anything about it? No, he’s just going to have sex, because apparently humans just fall into that routine.
#Ace
June and the Fox Boy (Beauty and the Beast):
5 stars
I really needed this after the previous one lol. It read like a Disney movie, it was so cute and pure, such a great take on the source. It is a bit rushed, but I can chalk that up to it being a short story (but give me the full book now please!!) This one really made me feel how special it is to read about main characters who are POC, and not only POC, but Latino! So refreshing and so sorely needed. The magic system in this was cool, and the fox transformation was a neat idea.
Prefiero No (Bartleby, the Scrivener):
4 stars
Another where I wasn’t familiar with the source! This story did start a bit slow for me, and I was wondering for a while where it was going. There were a few overdramatic/unrealistic things in the beginning in regards to people making fun of the MC’s art, but then the story took a dark/melancholic turn, and when I found out the plot twist it picked up from there. It was beautifully written and super sweet.
Trespassers Will Be… (Theseus and the Minotaur):
2.5 stars
This one was weird. The inner narration quickly became repetitive with the MC letting us know over and over again what the situation was. Like okay, we get it. It was also annoying because you could clearly tell this was written by someone who doesn’t know what teens are like right now — seeing as how the kid was getting bullied for liking Guardians of the Galaxy and Stranger Things… and he called both of them “not mainstream…?” Okay… I was initially excited about this story because I thought we’d finally get a sympathetic take on the minotaur (justice for the mino!) but they just made him a racist and abusive white man lmaoo. The story also ends pretty anti-climactically with no questions answered or solved so, there’s that.
Isla Bella (The Great Gatsby):
5 stars
The concept was really well realized, I felt like I was actually on the islands with the characters! It gave me Jurassic Park meets The Great Gatsby and, strangely, Dark Shadows lol. It was very haunting and celebratory of indigenous voices. There was a point though where they compared the Gatbsy figure to Columbus and the colonizers, saying she was no better than them, but… This woman bought and developed land, yes, but she wasn’t raping and murdering people and committing genocide. It was just a bit weird to compare what Columbus did with this character. Aside from that, I really loved this story!
Evermore (The Raven):
1 star
I absolutely hated this one. It dragged. It made me seriously not want to pick up the book just to not have this story on my shelf lol. Just refer to my updates on this one because it was a lot (about 64-71%). It was boring, tried to do too many things that I lost track of, and followed a similar structure to the first story, but through “mind maps” of characters that were just poems… The story was very negative and backward, weirdly, since it takes place 70 years in the future. The main character was also willing to manipulate her mom (who has Alzheimers) and abuse her with overmedication (that actually burned her) and yeah, I couldn’t take this one. Lots of trigger warnings for this one, I think, as the characters kept thinking their problems could be solved with suicide. I can’t believe a story told in verse dragged so long.
Celia’s Song (The Little Mermaid):
5 stars
Another one I sorely needed. This was a really unique take on the story and I loved the magic and the vibes. This one managed to make you care more for the sisters than most adaptations. I loved the sea witch and the concept of a golden heart and emotions that controlled the weather. No romance in this one, just sisterly love!
Esmeralda (Sir Gawain and the Green Knight):
4.5 stars
I’m going to have to look up the source for this because I was super confused by the ending lol. Also, the character is never described until halfway through which made them hard to picture, but the world and environment descriptions were super lush, so there was no trouble there. This was really, truly beautifully written, but it might need repeat reads to truly understand for me. Loved it!
Twenty Thousand Leagues Away from Me (Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea):
5 stars
Loved this one! It was way better than the last retelling of this story I read lol. This is another future, post-apocalyptic world where the sun burns and the water overtook much of the coasts. It was very realistically done, and I loved the main character and his bond with his adoptive parents and the baby whale.
Heart of the Sea (Frankenstein):
5 stars
Similar to the previous one, this took place in a post-apocalyptic future in which NYC has been completely submerged underwater. The inner monologue of the “monster” which is a cyborg-mermaid in this one, was beautiful and melancholic. I loved the description of the undersea world. The Frankenstein character is depicted as the bad guy in this, but I feel like this version of him deserved at least a tiny bit of sympathy. He was a boy alone at the end of the world and tried to make companions, even if he wanted them to work for him. I feel like a full novel could really delve into both the characters’ psyches and complicated relationship together.
Tesoro (The Old Man and the Sea):
4.5 stars
This was another really interesting take, and another post-apocalyptic world that was set in the desert of Las Vegas instead, where the water has dried up. I’d love to spend more time in this world, too. I thought all of the characters felt real and really respected the main character’s grit.
Overall, I really enjoyed this collection! I loved so many of the stories that the ones that I didn’t don’t outweigh it. I really recommend this to anyone who needs more Latino characters and stories in their reading :)