Tentacles, by Roland Smith, was full of ups and downs throughout. The novel was like a roller coaster, taking you on a journey up and down and all around. I would give this book a 3 out of 5 stars mainly because of all of the downs in the book. I would not recommend this book because I felt that it didn’t appeal to a very wide range of readers, particularly high school boys like myself, it wasn’t exactly stellar on the organization, and the details were a bit over the top at some points.
Some of the strengths of the text include the detail, the action-packed ending, and the “roller coaster” effect it had. The detail in describing ships and creatures was unreal. I had a very vivid image in my mind as I was reading and I felt like it was a movie playing in my head. The ending of the novel was filled with action, which I thought was very exciting and fun to read. And the “roller coaster” effect included some of the more boring descriptive parts as well as the action-packed standoffs, explorations, and attacks.
Some of the weaknesses of the text include the sometimes overly descriptive scenes and pretty much the whole beginning. Although the description was next level, I fell like the author could’ve bumped it down a notch in some parts. And the beginning of the novel through around the two-thirds mark was mostly description and laying the background, which I know is important, just kind of boring. The author saved all of the action scenes for the end, which I feel was a poor decision. It should’ve been spaced out more throughout the text.
I would not recommend this text because it doesn’t appeal to a very wide range of readers, it wasn’t organized very well, and it went a little too big on the descriptions than needed. There were plenty of words that I found myself looking up throughout the novel and there were some ideas that I just wasn’t familiar with yet. The author also could’ve spaced out the action scenes more towards the middle of the book as well instead of saving them all for the end. And some of the details seemed a bit too much, although they weren’t an annoyance, they just didn’t seem necessary. Overall I thought it was an okay read, but I would not recommend it, especially not to middle-grade students like myself.