I had this book in my library for a while without reading it, but when I saw it on my shelf, I knew I had to read it ASAP. See, less than a year ago, we adopted our own dog named Ollie, and walking him tends to be an adventure, so I was curious if it was something in the name. Foster's issues with his Ollie are much different than mine, and part of it is cultural, as Foster is in the UK where rules for dogs are far different than ours. His Ollie is a rescue dog who is terrified of Foster and thus doesn't obey or pay the least bit of attention to him. My Ollie loves everything, including saying hello to other dogs and getting us up at all hours of the morning when he decides he is ready for a walk (which combined means there is a big barking dog walking through the neighborhood when everyone is trying to sleep...).
In Britain, there are no leash laws, and since Foster's Ollie is a lurcher, a classification I'd not heard of before this book but it apparently classifies mixed breeds of greyhounds, salukis, and other thin dogs bred to run, Foster lets him run freely in the fields near his home. Other dog owners do the same, and Ollie has fun, but when it's time to come home, Ollie pulls out all the stops to stretch out the walk as long as possible. At home, Ollie hides in a basket, releasing a flood of urine if Foster so much as approaches him, but acts a little more friendly towards Foster's female partner. Foster consults many professionals, but no one can figure out how to make Ollie truly 'man's best friend'.
If my Ollie were allowed to run freely like the British dog, I'm sure he would be happy, as evidenced by his behavior at the dog park. Other dogs seeing 60+ pounds of Lab/Boxer mix running towards them with no restraint might be less than thrilled, but it would certainly save wear and tear on my hands and shoulders as he lunges towards any dog he sees on our walk. We haven't had many opportunities to assess his 'come back' skills, but I taught him to 'shake' and 'leave it', so I would hope he could learn that trick too.
In contrast, I don't see how coming to the U.S. would help Foster and his Ollie, especially given Foster's stated opinion that when he sees a dog on a leash, it means either the dog or the human (or both) has something psychologically wrong. Also, I live in a city, definitely not somewhere you want a running dog roaming free. Plus, no matter where they live, the relationship between man and dog has to be developed and grown at its own pace. Overall, I found the book OK, but not great, as to me it felt like a story of a guy who didn't properly do his research on what kind of dog to acquire and then when he chose his type, didn't assess the actual dog he'd be getting, and regretted his decision at every turn. It's a short, quick read, but not as good as I had hoped for.