The early years of S.H.I.E.L.D. (and Hydra and A.I.M) are collected in this omnibus. The work is incredibly uneven with some greatness and some blandness. It's never really bad, but vast sections are just uninteresting. The Fantastic Four issue is further down with the other Hate Monger stories, so I start with the proper start of the series.
S.H.I.E.L.D. vs. Hydra (Strange Tales #135-141) 4.5 Stars
Nick Fury is recruited to top the global threat of Hydra and their super weapon! This arc is Stan Lee and Jack Kirby firing on all cylinders. It brings gruff soldier Nick Fury into the spy business and puts a working man spin on the spy business. The first issue is a great spy piece with the fantastic splash of the iconic S.H.I.E.L.D. helicarrier. These issues are a must read for S.H.I.E.L.D. and Nick Fury fans.
Brain Slave (Strange Tales #141-143) 3 Stars
Mentallo and the Fixer team up to take down S.H.I.E.L.D. by mentally controlling Nick Fury. This one introduces the underused E.S.P. division and links to the "Them!" arc. It's okay enough with some clever action by Nick Fury, but becomes more of a let down by how little follow up any of it actually receives.
The Day of the Druid (Strange Tales #144-145) 1/5 Stars
The Druid sends eggs to kill S.H.I.E.L.D... The Druid and his group bring a sense of the supernatural to S.H.I.E.L.D. that is completely unneeded and unwanted. This arc is where the series goes stale. The Druid is an uninspired enemy with a lame defeat. Skip these issues and miss nothing.
Them! (Tales of Suspense #78, Strange Tales #146-149) 2/5 Stars
A group that manufactures androids seeks to destroy S.H.I.E.L.D. while a new defense group puts political pressure on S.H.I.E.L.D. The mystery of "Them" returns with sadly little mystery. It is more mysterious why Fury seems so tied up by red tape that he can't just investigate A.I.M. However, A.I.M. makes it easy by being incredibly stupid.
Hydra Lives! (Strange Tales #150-158) 3/5 Stars
Hydra's back with more cunning and a vicious new leader! This arc starts with the same languid pace that the series has been hobbling on since the end of the first Hydra arc. Then, Jim Steranko takes over and the series gets a shot of adrenaline. The end of this arc isn't perfect, but it certainly has better twists and more fantastic visuals than the series has seen since it's opening issue. While it can be tough to get through, it's worth the read.
Spy School (Strange Tales #159) 3.5/5 Stars
A nice break between long arcs. It breaks up the old guard and reshuffles it for Steranko's run proper. Fury reuses a device that he picked up at the end of the "Hydra Lives" arc, has a fight with Cap, and meets his new love interest.
Yellow Claw (Strange Tales #160-167) 2/5 Stars
The old villain Yellow Claw returns to kill S.H.I.E.L.D.; weirdness follows. This arc has some more awesome art, but it goes on for far too long. One can only take so much Yellow Claw bamfing out before it just gets tired. The final few issues have some inspired work, but the twist ending is just headscratching. It's somewhat skippable, though Agent Jimmy Woo returns later in the series. Perhaps read the first few and the last few.
Today, Earth Died! (Strange Tales #168) 2.5/5 Stars
Nick Fury faces an unstoppable alien. Worth the read for Steranko's trippy visuals. The story and disappointing ending are almost undone by the possible character insight, but it doesn't quite recover.
[Issue 1 is reviewed with issue 5 further down]
So Shall Ye Reap... Death! (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #2) 1.5/5 Stars
Nick Fury vs. Evolution... Sternako's love of the weird gets the better of him. The knock-off High Evolutionary is no better than the real one. The visuals are kind of cool, but this one becomes skippable given both of the episodes surrounding it meld story and style with panache.
Dark Moon Rise, Hell Hound Kill! (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #3) 4.5/5 Stars
Nick Fury unravels a Sherlock Holmes style mystery. The biggest problem with this story is that it isn't twice as long. For some reason, Sternako's best stories seem criminally short while his worst drag on and on. The mind-bending art bends with a creepy tale that ultimately manages to feel like a S.H.I.E.L.D. story. Bravo!
And Now It Begins... (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #4) 2/5 Stars
A fill-in story that re-tells the first S.H.I.E.L.D. story from Strange Tales #135-136. It's worth thumbing through from for the art.
Who is Scorpio?/Whatever Happened to Scorpio? (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #1, 5) 5/5 Stars
Steranko's Scorpio stories are what he's remembered for and rightly so. Scorpio is a mysterious bad ass and his final fate (which came too soon) leaves the mystery on a superb note. The art merges with the tale, raising Scorpio's threat. The start of issue one echoes the end of issue five. These are the pair of issues to read in this volume.
Doom Must Fall/Hours of Madness, Day of Death (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #6-7) 3/5 Stars
Archie Goodwin and Frank Springer attempt to mimic Steranko and partially succeed. The art is cool and the stories are fine if a bit routine sci-fi spy.
Thus Speaks Supremus (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #8) 1/5 Stars
Skip this uninspired sci-fi crap. Next.
Hate Monger (Fantastic Four #21, Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #9-11) 2/5 Stars
The Hate Monger story at the start of this volume brought Fury into the current Marvel timeline. It was a below average story at a time when Fantastic Four really was the world's greatest comic magazine. Then, being clearly out of ideas (I'm looking at you Supremus), they repeat the Hate Monger story with increasingly diminishing returns and meaning (what little there was).
Target: Fury (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #12-14) 1.5/5 Stars
Speaking of reusing ideas, this one take "Today, Earth Died!" and strips it of the art and character insight. Issue 14 is somewhat enjoyable though tarnished by its connection to the prior material. Skip it.
The Assassination of Nick Fury (Nick Fury, Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. #15) 2.5/5 Stars
This one is somewhat worth a read if only to see the writer frustratingly try and end the floundering series.
Did You Hear the One About Scorpio? (The Avengers #72) 2/5 Stars
Hey, remember previous issue and the awesome mystery of Scorpio, let's "fix" all that in one issue of The Avengers. It's basically the Avengers going to a place and beating up some dudes before backstory dump and Nick Fury reveal. It's a real let down as a Scorpio conclusion and a sub-par Avengers story even for the time. Read it as the introduction to the joke that the Zodiac will become.
Assignment: The Infinity Formula! (Marvel Spotlight #31) 3/5 Stars
The volume ends with a decent Fury spy-noir tale that effectively brings back the Countess from "Spy School" and the Scorpio arc. Read it for a decent end to this mixed bag of Fury tales.