Peter Griffin's academic biography is straightforward presentation of Ernest Hemingway's early years: growing up in Chicago and Michigan, his Kansas city career in journalism, volunteer service in WWI Italy, early failed romance with the love of his life, and first marriage to Hadley. I found myself wishing the volume had a simple chronology of his life to which the many insights could be referred. There are many letters and reminiscences and quite a lot of detail about years glossed over by other biographies. What emerges is an upbringing in a large and loving family, an immersion in his parents' failed relationship, war trauma, a broken heart, and an utterly conventional romance, courtship, and marriage. One realizes that Hemingway never quite grew out of the hurt and resentments of his youth. He was a hyper-literate, over-mothered, sensitive and depressive boy of a conventionally failed marriage, which never ended but also never succeeded and, more to the point, never helped the boy understand how two dissimilar people might relate and deeply support each other emotionally. Hemingway emerges as a perfect blend of his parents: privileged, intelligent, disciplined, gifted, art-loving, sensitive, sentimental, unintentionally and intentionally cruel, controlling, and nature-bound. Griffin's volume (which began as a PhD dissertation) is a crucial addition to Hemingway scholarship and a must-read for Hemingway lovers. Don't expect, however, a psychologized analysis purporting to figure out the writer's future and end. Griffin is far too respectful of and responsible toward his complex subject for that.