As a young Christian back in the 90s, I read many Banner titles. So many, in fact, that they can be said to be the chief influence on my faith until the last decade (and they still feature in my reading now). So I won't really comment on the idea of this book (a good one) and the quality of the contributors (they will all be good, and even great), but will instead mention which books influenced me as a young Christian. And in case it is needful to mention, Banner books are exactly what young believers should be encouraged to read to build a fantastic reformed and evangelical foundation.
This will take a while, as I plan to read one chapter a week, at most.
'The Forgotten Spurgeon': This book might just be the most influential of all my early reads. It gave me not only a lasting love of Spurgeon, but settled me early in historic Calvinism away from the errors of Arminianism and Hyper-Calvinism. It also showed me a godly model of how to fight for important theological truths.
'The Works of John Bunyan': I have not read all these, you might have guessed, but two of Bunyan's works had a profound influence on my first two years as a believer. The first, no surprise, was The Pilgrim's Progress. Experimental Christianity has no greater advocate than this famous allegory. The other was Bunyan's autobiographical work, Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners. I confess I was looking in this for a moment of conversion for poor old Bunyan (without success), but found instead the struggles of a man who really felt his sin. Both these books, and The Holy War read later, gave me a seriousness about spiritual matters and a desire to devour Puritan works.
'Today's Gospel: Authentic or Synthetic?' (By Walter Chantry): I honestly don't remember this book that well, but I know it was enjoyed at the time, and I know that it helped shape my early Calvinistic beliefs.
'The Reformed Pastor': Not one I have read. I have heard a few talks or lectures on it, and found them inspiring. The author of the chapter on this work is a minister in my old church in Ireland. Really nice man. I would however not fully agree with his assessment of the book. While we can be inspired by men like Baxter, and gain much from their example and precepts, the setting into which most Puritans ministered was often very different than what many ministers today face. The puritans, due to preaching to such mixed assemblies, did not really address their audiences as the people of God, they did not use a lot of comforting rubrics to the whole body, but instead were always converting their people, always exposing the hypocrites. Some congregations will need this today, others need a bit of it, but if it is done in sound and healthy churches it will create a lot of needless doubts. Those doubts will lead good saints to stay away from the Table, and cause the children to stray from the faith.
'Valley of Vision' is one I only read in recent years, so it did not shape me in my early Christian faith. However, I still found it immensely helpful. In particular it further helped my prayers transcend from so many personal concerns and thanks for salvation to adoration of God for who he is in Himself; worshiping God as God, and not just what he has done or will do.
'Jonathan Edwards: A New Biography' I twice read in my first four years as a Christian. Much of what I know about Christian experience, revival, and an educated ministry came from this book. I am a bit less happy with the results of The Great Awakening now, but I would very gladly return to this book again.
'Expository Thoughts on the Gospels' by J C Ryle is not one I read in entirety. The Banner printed these in multiple volumes. I know I read Mark, and Luke. I read some of John. Don't think I read Matthew at all. I don't highly rate these as exposition, but like Matthew Henry's commentary, they are rich in spiritual wisdom and applications. They certainly shaped my early piety.
'Historical Theology' By William Cunningham: This one is not noted as read on my Goodreads, because of the roughly 1200 pages I have only read around 80% (I only mark books as read that I actually read completely). The robustness alone makes this an awesome book for a Christian not too far into his Christian walk. But it wasn't as a newish Christian that I read this, instead it was only about 5 years ago. I was particularly interested in the section on Socinianism. Read it.
'A Body of Divinity': Back in the first year of my Christian walk, the very title of this seemed to have an effect on me! It is one of the books that was most used of God to establish a love of doctrine and a knowledge of sound doctrine.
'The Diary and Life of Andrew Bonner' I believe this did a fair amount of good to my soul in 1999. Even then I thought it was a little lacking in joy and slightly tedious in places, but I still found many great spiritual insights and an overall seriousness in religious things that laid a good foundation in a young believer.
'The Letter of Samuel Rutherford': I read this a few times. It would be hard to find a more earnest love of Christ in letter form. And as a young Christian these taught me much about suffering with Christ in view and submitting to God's providential dealings, no matter what they are. However, I do not as wholeheartedly love his 'romance-style' of letter writing as I once did. The church is corporately the bride, but Rutherford writes as if he was Christ's bride, and that is not perhaps wholly helpful.
Overall this was very edifying. It reminded me of some great books and why i was blessed by them, it reminded me of books I need to read soon (and why), and it reminded me of the enormous blessing the Banner of Truth has been in the Reformed world for decades. God bless them.