'Why was everyone so interested in her now? When it was too late to change anything? What was the point?'
***MINOR SPOILERS AHEAD***
Let me begin by saying that Looking For JJ is a fantastic book, one which I would highly recommend to anyone looking for something a bit haunting and thought-provoking.
Also, before you read any further, I would like to clarify that Jennifer and Alice are the same person - Alice Tully is the new identity Jennifer is given when she is released from prison. This will hopefully save any confusion later.
This was a re-read for me, but it gripped me just as much as it did the first time around. Although I have some very minor quibbles (hence the four stars) on the whole, I can't praise this book enough, so I will dispense with my usual system of:
THE GOOD
THE BAD
THE UGLY
Because to call any part of this book BAD or UGLY would be to do it a huge disservice.
THE GOOD:
- Like I said, this book is incredibly gripping, even the second time around, even when I knew what was going to happen. It's not quite an on-the-edge-of-your-seat novel (it's not really that kind of book) but it's one of those that holds you in its grasp, captures your focus, so that you couldn't put it down if you wanted to.
- I am an absolute sucker for controversial literature, or taboo topics.
Lolita? Fave.
Flowers In The Attic? Love it.
One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest? My jam.
I'm also big on true crime, so this book about a 10 year old girl killing her best friend was right up my alley.
I love that Anne Cassidy chose to address such a serious topic, and that she did it with such insight and sensitivity, not only in terms of Jennifer's childhood, and the events that led up to Michelle's death, but also the way in which she explores how Jennifer/Alice copes with the consequences of what she did long-term.
This is a viewpoint that we so rarely get to hear about, and I thought that Anne Cassidy tackled in brilliantly.
- Following on from that, I also thought that Cassidy's presentation of Jennifer herself was wonderfully done. In the world of Looking For JJ, Jennifer Jones is merely a headline:
JJ: THE FACE OF A KILLER
But to the reader, she's more than that, as we follow the journey of her life before and after the murder. And as you see Jennifer/Alice's struggles, you actually begin to sympathise with her, understand her, which again, I thought was very clever writing on Anne Cassidy's part.
- For the most part, I enjoyed the dual narrative of Jennifer and Alice. I liked the way all the different fragments of Jennifer's past were entwined, coming together to form Alice's future.
THE AFORE MENTIONED MINOR QUIBBLES:
- You'll notice that I said I enjoyed the dual narrative for the most part. I did much prefer the Jennifer plot line to the Alice one. It was much more engaging, and the stakes seemed a lot higher - you could sense that it was all building up to something.
Looking For JJ is basically split up into three parts:
PART 1: Alice
PART 2: Jennifer
PART 3: Alice
And if it had stuck to that layout, it would've been fine, but the thing is, Jennifer's narrative kept creeping into the Alice bits, with no real rhyme or reason, and it meant that some of the more dramatic moments in the Jennifer section fell flat, because we'd already heard about it in Alice's flashbacks.
- Whilst Jennifer was a highly complex and multi-faceted character, Alice was a little...lacking in depth (even though they were supposed to be the same person). Whilst it was interesting to follow how she was coping with life outside of prison, I felt like we never got a true sense of who she was, and how she felt, and it was hard, sometimes, to connect her to the girl who murdered her friend.
- Frankie. What an absolute dickhead. I get that Jennifer/Alice was vulnerable, emotionally dependant, and craving love, but this guy was the pits. He pressured her into sex, he pressured her into meeting his family, he got mad when she refused to switch university to be closer to him. And the worst thing was, I couldn't tell if we were supposed to be rooting for this relationship or not.
- Finally, teeny
tiny
thing - there's some really weird wording in this book.
For example, Frankie says something like: 'I think my parents gave me this room
in order to
give them some peace and quiet'.
Or Jennifer says, 'You know that Michelle's mother
does not allow her
to go to the lake'.
Like, who talks like that?
OVERALL:
I think that this book is really important, in terms of criminology and dealing with difficult subjects. But as well as that, it's just one of those books that really sticks with you.
It's been a good four years since I read this book for the first time, and some of the scenes were still crystal clear in my mind.
Even though this book isn't quite perfect, it's incredibly relevant and will fixate you until the very last page.