What do you think?
Rate this book
Don't Call Me Hero #6
Stolen Hearts
In 1984, Danika Laroque, a young indigenous woman, was reported missing. The investigation went cold not long after. Decades later, a True Crime podcaster starts poking around, bringing the missing persons case to the attention of Cassidy Miller. But how do you resolve a case with no crime scene, no evidence, and no body?
Back in the Twin Cities after Julia’s father’s funeral, Cassidy is hoping for some good luck romantically, or at least a break. It’s starting to feel like her relationship with Julia has been defined by overcoming one obstacle after the next. Between rehoming Julia’s mom, a new job at a high-profile criminal defense firm, and baby fever, Cassidy worries there might not be room for her in Julia’s life. But more importantly, with Julia being pulled in so many directions, is whatever’s left over enough to make Cassidy happy?
Book 6 in the Don’t Call Me Hero series.
Back in the Twin Cities after Julia’s father’s funeral, Cassidy is hoping for some good luck romantically, or at least a break. It’s starting to feel like her relationship with Julia has been defined by overcoming one obstacle after the next. Between rehoming Julia’s mom, a new job at a high-profile criminal defense firm, and baby fever, Cassidy worries there might not be room for her in Julia’s life. But more importantly, with Julia being pulled in so many directions, is whatever’s left over enough to make Cassidy happy?
Book 6 in the Don’t Call Me Hero series.
290 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 16, 2023
95 people are currently reading
174 people want to read
About the author
Eliza Lentzski
30 books868 followersEliza Lentzski is the best-selling author of sapphic fiction, romance, and erotica including the Winter Jacket and Don’t Call Me Hero series. A historian by day, Eliza is passionate about telling the stories of marginalized communities.
Born and raised in the upper Midwest—a landscape that often shapes her novels—Eliza now lives in Boston with her wife and their cat, Charley.
Born and raised in the upper Midwest—a landscape that often shapes her novels—Eliza now lives in Boston with her wife and their cat, Charley.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 76 reviews
May 21, 2023
Another great addition!!!
Also love getting a new installment of the Cassidy Julia world. This one was great but really I only have one question...what the $#&% is Julia's age!?!?!?
Also love getting a new installment of the Cassidy Julia world. This one was great but really I only have one question...what the $#&% is Julia's age!?!?!?
December 17, 2023
Stolen Hearts is book six in the Don’t Call Me a Hero series. I read this as a standalone.
Detective Cassidy Miller is offered a thirty year old cold case by a True Crime podcaster. An indigenous woman went missing after leaving work. She was never found. Meanwhile, Julia is starting work at a new law office while dealing with family issues.
I am not sure if reading this novel as a standalone altered my view of the book but I am definitely in the contrary camp in reviewer land.
Julia appears to be in a power position over Cassidy. Not certain if this is because of the age difference or educational differences. I was not enamoured by this especially when Julia disrespected and disregarded Cassidy’s use of the agreed upon ’safe’ word. This is a trust broken by Julia.
Cassidy’ character is inconsistent in her response to situations. She is at times reacting with her life experiences taken into account and other times being childish and not in an endearing manner.
The murder mystery is lightweight with the bulk of the story being about the relationship and some story filler about Cassidy’s time in Afghanistan. I have read other works by this author and enjoyed them. Unfortunately this is a miss from me.
Detective Cassidy Miller is offered a thirty year old cold case by a True Crime podcaster. An indigenous woman went missing after leaving work. She was never found. Meanwhile, Julia is starting work at a new law office while dealing with family issues.
I am not sure if reading this novel as a standalone altered my view of the book but I am definitely in the contrary camp in reviewer land.
Julia appears to be in a power position over Cassidy. Not certain if this is because of the age difference or educational differences. I was not enamoured by this especially when Julia disrespected and disregarded Cassidy’s use of the agreed upon ’safe’ word. This is a trust broken by Julia.
Cassidy’ character is inconsistent in her response to situations. She is at times reacting with her life experiences taken into account and other times being childish and not in an endearing manner.
The murder mystery is lightweight with the bulk of the story being about the relationship and some story filler about Cassidy’s time in Afghanistan. I have read other works by this author and enjoyed them. Unfortunately this is a miss from me.
May 13, 2023
Eliza Lentzski is one of those authors whose books are an auto read for me and the Don't Call Me Hero series is easily one of my favorites. Book 6 finds Cassidy working the disappearance of a young indigenous women in 1984 and Julia starting a new job with a prestigious law firm.
I love a good cold case, but what makes this series so good is the chemistry and deep love that Cassidy and Julia share. They don't view each other's vulnerabilities as weakness, they support each other in every aspect. And this might just be the hottest book in the series!
I can't possibly recommend this book enough and would be perfectly fine if Eliza never ends this series.
Eliza talks about the book on the below episode of my podcast, The Sapphic Book Review.
https://www.buzzsprout.com/1935982/ep...
I love a good cold case, but what makes this series so good is the chemistry and deep love that Cassidy and Julia share. They don't view each other's vulnerabilities as weakness, they support each other in every aspect. And this might just be the hottest book in the series!
I can't possibly recommend this book enough and would be perfectly fine if Eliza never ends this series.
Eliza talks about the book on the below episode of my podcast, The Sapphic Book Review.
https://www.buzzsprout.com/1935982/ep...
August 6, 2023
Our favorite couple is back! Nothing not to like in book 6; sexy scenes are still as sexy, Julia and Cassidy’s relationship remains strong if not stronger, that big step that Julia took and….. Julia’s age is still anyone’s guess!
October 21, 2024
All of the stars and more. My heart is full. I love them so much.
God, this needs to be a tv series. Please, Eliza, I need the next book! Please never stop writing their story.
God, this needs to be a tv series. Please, Eliza, I need the next book! Please never stop writing their story.
July 14, 2024
4.5 Stars
I don’t want it to end! I just want more and more of Cassidy and Julia’s adventures. I’ve grown accustomed to their life in the two days I’ve binged their stories 😩
I don’t want it to end! I just want more and more of Cassidy and Julia’s adventures. I’ve grown accustomed to their life in the two days I’ve binged their stories 😩
October 20, 2023
Another great addition to the Don't Call Me Hero series!
Centre stage once again are Cassidy and Julia, who burn as bright as ever. As I have mentioned before, it is this couple that keeps drawing me back. But I was quite interested to delve into the side story of this installment, featuring a missing Indigenous woman from the 1980s. This topic should be getting way more attention, as it is a long standing tragedy in both Canada and the US. Though Ms. Lentzski doesn't go very deep in this storyline, and it was very predictable, I did like the change of direction. And we readers know by now it is Cassidy and Julia first, their relationship, their flaws and godDAMN their hot sexytimes. Bravo for originality!
Centre stage once again are Cassidy and Julia, who burn as bright as ever. As I have mentioned before, it is this couple that keeps drawing me back. But I was quite interested to delve into the side story of this installment, featuring a missing Indigenous woman from the 1980s. This topic should be getting way more attention, as it is a long standing tragedy in both Canada and the US. Though Ms. Lentzski doesn't go very deep in this storyline, and it was very predictable, I did like the change of direction. And we readers know by now it is Cassidy and Julia first, their relationship, their flaws and godDAMN their hot sexytimes. Bravo for originality!
June 9, 2023
I so enjoy the characters in this series of books. I’ve been hooked since DON’T CALL ME HERO and will read each one Eliza Lentzski writes. (In fact, any books Eliza Lentzski writes). The characters are so well drawn I feel I know Cassidy and Julia. Ah, Julia. Be still my beating heart. 😀. Seriously I love the way their relationship has developed as each book follows on. More to come I hope.
July 14, 2023
This editing continues in the line of the previous books, it makes it hard for me to read.
I’m not a native English speaker and when I can spot mistakes… I’m sorry but no.
One major pet peeve capitalising coming out in all its forms. Why on earth would you write that? A line like this: Would she still freely give those hugs out after I Came Out?
How can you read this and still take it seriously?
Anyway, as for the story, it’s flat. One old case brought to the attention of Cassidy by some podcaster. How this case gets solved is kind of lame and all together just plain boring. It’s all relatively flat and not entertaining. We still don’t know Julia’s age. We don’t really get more of an insight into their relationship. We have flashbacks to Afghanistan and I have no idea which purpose they serve other than page filler…
I absolutely loved earlier instalments of this series but I guess it’s all downhill from book 3 onwards. It’s a shame.
This is just my opinion and I advise everyone to definitely seek out other reviews.
I’m not a native English speaker and when I can spot mistakes… I’m sorry but no.
One major pet peeve capitalising coming out in all its forms. Why on earth would you write that? A line like this: Would she still freely give those hugs out after I Came Out?
How can you read this and still take it seriously?
Anyway, as for the story, it’s flat. One old case brought to the attention of Cassidy by some podcaster. How this case gets solved is kind of lame and all together just plain boring. It’s all relatively flat and not entertaining. We still don’t know Julia’s age. We don’t really get more of an insight into their relationship. We have flashbacks to Afghanistan and I have no idea which purpose they serve other than page filler…
I absolutely loved earlier instalments of this series but I guess it’s all downhill from book 3 onwards. It’s a shame.
This is just my opinion and I advise everyone to definitely seek out other reviews.
May 16, 2023
Worth the wait
The lack of sleep to read this book before work was worth it. A few of Julia lines will be with me all day. And I’m officially a Nancy fan. No spoilers, but fair warning, you wont be able to put this one down. Looking forward to savoring this master piece for a long time.
The lack of sleep to read this book before work was worth it. A few of Julia lines will be with me all day. And I’m officially a Nancy fan. No spoilers, but fair warning, you wont be able to put this one down. Looking forward to savoring this master piece for a long time.
May 22, 2023
Loved it! More please…
November 7, 2023
A good ending to the series. I am sad Julia didn't meet Sarah though.
August 7, 2023
Okay, I need book 7 asap and a Julia in my life.
May 22, 2023
I just love this series. This may have been my favorite of all of them. It was just calming and comforting all around.
June 1, 2023
Another great book in the series! I can’t get enough of these two and looking forward to seeing how their story continues.
May 20, 2023
I love Eliza Lentzski’s writing and DCMH is without a doubt my favorite series. I so wish I had enjoyed Stolen Hearts as much as I have enjoyed all the previous books in this series (especially Grave Mistake ❤️), but I was left feeling a little let down. It’s probably totally on me and what I find fun to read. There were a couple of scenes (like Cassidy’s birthday party) that I skipped, because the imagery was simply too intense for me. I was also a bit sad about the choice of words to describe a group of people (Julia’s new coworkers). It just didn’t sit well with me. I adored the ending, though. It was perfection! And the ice skating scene was absolutely heartwarming ❤️🥺.
May 5, 2024
I enjoyed the continuing relationship between Julia and Cassidy but I was disappointed by the case. I expected a more suspenseful and interesting case and investigation based on the premise. I was also disappointed by how the case was resolved, it felt lacklustre and anticlimactic.
May 29, 2025
This writer is just amazing. I don’t think I’ve seen such a believable relationship dynamic in a long time. Good humor, good flowing conversations, good cop story line.
I love everything about it
I love everything about it
January 13, 2026
This is my favorite book of the series. It's not just the amazing spice (which is so delicious), but for me, this book really solidifies Julia and Cassidy's relationship.
I have really enjoyed the progression of their relationship through the series and I hope it never ends.
I have really enjoyed the progression of their relationship through the series and I hope it never ends.
September 26, 2023
I’m a big fan of this series but this last installment fell flat for me. Failed expectations and all that. This book felt more like a series of disjointed “bonus content” then a cohesive novel. All that said, the final epilogue did put a huge smile on my face, so for that at least it warrants 2 stars, it was ok.
May 18, 2023
Another instalment in the Don’t call me Hero book series. One that was just as enjoyable and interesting as the previous 5.
Cassidy and Julia are characters that you can’t really get enough of. Their banter and their whole relationship is always worth the read and never has a dull moment which is all thanks to the author Eliza Lentzski. There is a very particular and unique way in which the author writes these characters and stories which is not only fun to read but also very entertaining and new each time.
There is enough of a separation between the case and the lead couple’s story that makes it still interesting and so there is no more of this than there is of that. It makes for me wanting to read all of it as quickly as I can. I liked the case the cold case team solved this time. It was realistic and Eliza Lentzski clearly did her research to even make us educated and aware.
I look forward to reading book 7 and however many books the author publishes in this book series because I will always be ready to read more about Cassidy and Julia’s journey together.
Cassidy and Julia are characters that you can’t really get enough of. Their banter and their whole relationship is always worth the read and never has a dull moment which is all thanks to the author Eliza Lentzski. There is a very particular and unique way in which the author writes these characters and stories which is not only fun to read but also very entertaining and new each time.
There is enough of a separation between the case and the lead couple’s story that makes it still interesting and so there is no more of this than there is of that. It makes for me wanting to read all of it as quickly as I can. I liked the case the cold case team solved this time. It was realistic and Eliza Lentzski clearly did her research to even make us educated and aware.
I look forward to reading book 7 and however many books the author publishes in this book series because I will always be ready to read more about Cassidy and Julia’s journey together.
May 28, 2023
Slow burn read.
When I noticed book 6 in this series was released, I actually couldn't really remember them. So I looked back and downloaded the first one, then of course I read them all again.
It's an interesting series with Cassidy the marine turned cop and Julia the brilliant aloof lawyer. Both of them have great chemistry and banter. Interesting cases throughout so never a dull moment. It was good to read them all together and realise everything takes place over less than a year, but must have taken a few yrs to write.
Threaded throughout is the back story of time in the marines and how she rescued her friend and why she has ptsd. All very interesting.
The relationship scenes are super hot 🔥 but lovely to see both of them embracing love, breaking down walls. I can see that there's plenty more threads to be explored in this series, bring it on.
When I noticed book 6 in this series was released, I actually couldn't really remember them. So I looked back and downloaded the first one, then of course I read them all again.
It's an interesting series with Cassidy the marine turned cop and Julia the brilliant aloof lawyer. Both of them have great chemistry and banter. Interesting cases throughout so never a dull moment. It was good to read them all together and realise everything takes place over less than a year, but must have taken a few yrs to write.
Threaded throughout is the back story of time in the marines and how she rescued her friend and why she has ptsd. All very interesting.
The relationship scenes are super hot 🔥 but lovely to see both of them embracing love, breaking down walls. I can see that there's plenty more threads to be explored in this series, bring it on.
May 31, 2023
Highly Recommend this Series
Wow, if I could give this book 10 stars I certainly would. Stolen Hearts, the sixth book in the Don’t Call Me Hero series, continued to expand the depth of the relationship that has developed between Julia and Cassidy. The sense that I got from Book six is that they’ll always be there to support each other and bring out the best in the other person. Lentzski also delivers some highly creative and intense sex scenes as well as some tender love scenes between Julia and Cassidy. Finally, both Julia’s law career and Cassidy’s cold case career continued to develop in this story. Do yourself a favor and read this book/series. I can’t wait for Book seven.
Wow, if I could give this book 10 stars I certainly would. Stolen Hearts, the sixth book in the Don’t Call Me Hero series, continued to expand the depth of the relationship that has developed between Julia and Cassidy. The sense that I got from Book six is that they’ll always be there to support each other and bring out the best in the other person. Lentzski also delivers some highly creative and intense sex scenes as well as some tender love scenes between Julia and Cassidy. Finally, both Julia’s law career and Cassidy’s cold case career continued to develop in this story. Do yourself a favor and read this book/series. I can’t wait for Book seven.
June 24, 2023
Loved it
I love when books teach you something new and with this installment to the series I learned more about native Americans through Cassidy's cold case. I enjoyed following along with the detectives and the amount of time for the case seemed just right with everything else happening.
Our MCs have a good amount of romance and it was nice to see more dates and communication. I also enjoyed the spicy moments but I admit to getting a little worry in one of the scenes.
Stolen hearts is a great addition to Cassidy and Julia's story and the epilogue made me excited for more.
I love when books teach you something new and with this installment to the series I learned more about native Americans through Cassidy's cold case. I enjoyed following along with the detectives and the amount of time for the case seemed just right with everything else happening.
Our MCs have a good amount of romance and it was nice to see more dates and communication. I also enjoyed the spicy moments but I admit to getting a little worry in one of the scenes.
Stolen hearts is a great addition to Cassidy and Julia's story and the epilogue made me excited for more.
May 26, 2023
Another Exciting Addition To The “Don’t Call Me Hero” Series!
I just loved this couple. Julia and Cassidy are growing into their relationship and the new changes in their lives. Cassidy solves another Cold Case and Julia is switching jobs, again. Decisions need to be made and living together is bringing up other feelings. But we know another book is coming. Marriage, babies all things possible in the future and one we need to be part of. Eliza Lentzski - Can not wait!!!
I just loved this couple. Julia and Cassidy are growing into their relationship and the new changes in their lives. Cassidy solves another Cold Case and Julia is switching jobs, again. Decisions need to be made and living together is bringing up other feelings. But we know another book is coming. Marriage, babies all things possible in the future and one we need to be part of. Eliza Lentzski - Can not wait!!!
August 25, 2023
3.5 rounded up to 4.
I love Cassidy and Julia and I’m glad to see their story keeps evolving. I feel like Julia has had the most growth and at times I miss not having her PoV. Maybe the next installment could be split between them?
My only note is I wish Cassidy’s cases were a bit more important to the overall story. Since we do spend so much time with the investigation, it’s a bit of a let down when the conclusion comes.
All in all another good entry to the series.
I love Cassidy and Julia and I’m glad to see their story keeps evolving. I feel like Julia has had the most growth and at times I miss not having her PoV. Maybe the next installment could be split between them?
My only note is I wish Cassidy’s cases were a bit more important to the overall story. Since we do spend so much time with the investigation, it’s a bit of a let down when the conclusion comes.
All in all another good entry to the series.
September 20, 2024
This is one of my favourite series and what can’t be said for many other series is that this 6th book is my favourite so far. I love seeing Julia and Cassidy’s growth both as individuals and in their relationship, as well as Cassidy’s cold case jobs and her colleagues. Unlike other series that can feel like plots are repeating, each book in this series is fresh. I can’t wait to see Julia and Cassidy’s life in marriage and motherhood so please Eliza keep writing 😄
October 20, 2024
sweeps you off your feet
These two women are totally messed up and completely perfect. Loved all the fumbling love affair and while the sex was good it was not the draw for me to keep reading all these novels. I enjoyed the relationship and all that entailed including coming out to the folks. This author covered some really good topics. PTSD, dementia, how to get past the doubts, and how to fall in love despite loves wicked sense of humor. Thank you Eliza L.
These two women are totally messed up and completely perfect. Loved all the fumbling love affair and while the sex was good it was not the draw for me to keep reading all these novels. I enjoyed the relationship and all that entailed including coming out to the folks. This author covered some really good topics. PTSD, dementia, how to get past the doubts, and how to fall in love despite loves wicked sense of humor. Thank you Eliza L.
April 30, 2025
This is up there in top 5 series of all time. This relationship is so adorable and seeing it continue throughout every book is beautiful. You feel a connection and intimacy with the characters that you don’t get from reading a one or two-part story. The ending is so perfect and I already know what I want to see in the upcoming instalments. I can’t wait for the next release. A brilliant series by a fantastic author and a super-talented narrator, thank you! ♥️
Displaying 1 - 29 of 76 reviews