This is not really a review, just notes for myself. I did start to skip the horror stories and poetry - maybe I'll go back to them one day.
The Tale of the Skin, Emma Donoghue (well-written but doesn't give anything new to the tale)
Beauty and the Beast (poem), Jaimes Alsop
Gulliver at Home, John Kessel
It Had to Be You, Nancy Pickard (recommend)
The Skull of Charlotte Corday, Leslie Dick (started then skimmed)
I Am Infinite, I Contain Multitudes, Douglas Clegg (maybe I'm not swayed by body horror?)
Coffee Jerk at the Gates of Hell (poem), Christopher Jones (skipped)
Riding the Black, Charles Grant (skipped)
In the Fields, Christopher Harman (so bored)
Mbo, Nicholas Royle (skipped)
Winner Take All, Jeffrey Shaffer
Safe, Gary A. Braunbeck (skipped)
El Castillo de la Perseverancia, Howard Waldrop (recommend)
The Sin-Eater's Tale, Brennen Wysong (completely lost me)
A Visit, Steven Millhauser
A Globe of Glass, Sonia Gernes
The Fall of the Kings, Ellen Kushner and Delia Sherman (skipped)
Coyote and the White Folks (poem), Bill Lewis
Sheela Na Gig (poem), Bill Lewis
The Flounder's Kiss, Michael Cadnum
Residuals, Paul J. McAuley and Kim Newman (recommend?)
The Psychomantium, Molly Brown
In the Black Mill, Michael Chabon (skipped)
Dust Motes, P. D. Cacek (recommend)
La Muerte (poem), Pat Mora (skipped)
Spanky's Back in Town, Christopher Fowler (skipped)
Marriage (poem), Denise Duhamel
Kingyo no fun, Nicholas Royle (blah)
Bucket of Blood, Norman Partridge (skipped)
Mermaid (poem), A. Alvarez
Estate, Caitlin R. Kiernan (skipped)
The Sin of Elijah, Steve Stern (recommend?)
Driving Blind, Ray Bradbury
The Sky-Blue Ball, Joyce Carol Oates (recommend?)
The Black Fairy's Curse, Karen Joy Fowler
The Last Song of Sirit Byar, Peter S. Beagle (skipped)
Marina's Fragrance, Mayra Santos-Febres
Setting Celestial Signs on Terrestrial Beings (poem), Emily Warn
Rabbit Hole, Jane Yolen
Wild Horses, Charles de Lint
Princess (poem), Matthew Sweeney (skipped)
Audience, Jack Womack
Merlin, Robert Clinton
The Crawl, Stephen Laws (blah)
The Remains of Princess Kaiulani's Garden, Katherine Vaz (recommend?)
Dharma, Vikram Chandra