[November 2025 - I realised while correcting some grammatical errors in this review that I really said nothing specific about this novel and considered making alterations to correct this, then I decided against it. The only thing I want any reader of this review to come away with is a desire, no, a need to react like Anthony Blanche in Brideshead Revisited when he hears about Charles Ryder's 'Unhealthy pictures' and screams 'Take me to Charles' unhealthy pictures'. That is the response I want my review to engender so I decided against altering my review].
How to review a novel which is extraordinary, by an author who is one of the greatest writers of the twentieth century in English or any other language? Superlatives seem inadequate, mere praise just trite. It took me way too long to discover this author but once I did I knew that he was something special - like booze, drugs or sex - you may not handle it well the first time but you know that each new encounter will add depth to the experience and to yourself.
It always happens that the novels which mean the most to me leave me tongue tied - again like the first overwhelming knowledge of love/lust which leaves you with nothing to say (thank god it happened to me before we all decided to mouth pornographic cliches and in many cases actually believe we were expressing something with them). Purdy doesn't need words about him or his works he needs to be read - everything is in the reading.
One thing I will say - Purdy is not in the 'southern Gothic tradition' and that this label is frequently applied by American reviewers who thus demonstrate the paucity of their own knowledge and experience of their country. Purdy's world is that of the Midwest, of the flat Ohio plains and its small cities/towns which had an oil boom in the late 19th century and then settled back into ordinariness. I lived there and though those towns had changed greatly since Purdy emerged from them in the 1920's their underlying grotesqueness were unchanged. They exuded a conformist propriety over a cesspit of unimaginable sin - and it would be sin because they were all church dominated - and hypocrisy supporting a privileged elite whose dominance of an underclass kept stupid so it wouldn't even know how badly they were exploited. Fifty years later that time can still give me nightmares. Maybe that is why I love Purdy - I know where he comes from (up to very recently you wouldn't even find Purdy mentioned amongst the famous sons of his hometown - his death changed that, eventually).