After re-watching the film "Shine," based on the life of David Helfgott, a gifted pianist who battled mental illness/undiagnosed Autism throughout most of his life, I was curious to read the book LOVE YOU TO BITS AND PIECES, written by his wife, Gillian Helfgott. Several years his senior, and a noted astrologer, her telling of David's story is so detailed that I had to wonder if she kept a daily journal of every conversation and event not only from her first meeting with David but, also from what he told Gillian of his early life. Those versions could change dozens of times.
Clearly, the demands of living with David's eccentric and often erratic behavior were a challenge, but her devotion to him was apparent. However, her opinions of his father, and other people who had been an influence in his life, were colored by her own prejudices and often cruel judgmental opinions. The film omitted events and people in his life, including his first wife, that didn't fit in the version of David life that the screen writer, director, and Gillian wished to depict.
During my reading of the book, another book, written by his sister Margaret, OUT OF TUNE, arrived from my local library. Her book was a refutation of Gillian's in many ways. In scanning the book to decide if I'd read it, it was obvious that Margaret, who lived with David from childhood, had an entirely different view of his life. David's own recollections were often changeable depending on his state of mind. He and another sister both had been institutionalized for their mental issues, so even after finishing LOVE YOU TO BITS AND PIECES, I wasn't confident that all of David's perceptions and memories were accurate. Perhaps no one will ever know which stories were true, but in any case, David's remarkable musical gift, and wish to share it with people cannot be disputed.