A few years ago, I watched His Girl Friday, the 1940 adaptation of this 1924 play. I enjoyed the movie, so I was looking forward to reading this play.
This one’s a bit too dated for me. When judging a story, I generally try and consider the time in which a piece was written, but I couldn’t get over the casual racism and sexism in this one. Plus, Hildy Johnson is a much more interesting character as a woman (as she is in His Girl Friday). He’s kind of a jerk in the original play.
I rewatched His Girl Friday after reading the play, and I cannot believe how much better that version is. Changing Hildy to a woman is a brilliant touch, as is adding the screwball elements. More important, that adaptation cuts the chafe and gets to the heart of the story of a condemned man and the journalists assigned to cover the execution. The Front Page, to this twenty-first century reader, kills a lot of the plot’s tension with too many extraneous details and conversations. And again: even if expected for the 1920s, the casual racism and sexism was just too much (and unnecessary). Not recommended.