Contains SPOILERS and MY PERSONAL OPINION
Since this collects both the Destiny and The Sleeping story lines, I thought it would only be fair to make two separate reviews of them. Well, here goes
Destiny (2/5)
The plus points:
-The atmosphere. I loved the atmosphere Scott Hampton drew for the setting in ancient Gallund. It's charismatic, mesmerizing and magical in both drawing and writing. It almost has this dreamy feeling to it that just sucks any reader into the story. Despite the (honestly a little laughable) concept of Batman being a warrior in Norway who fights with an ax, it turned out to be an absolutely believable and even beautifully solemn one. This is all thanks to Hampton's success in conveying the feeling and the haunting atmosphere of ancient Gallund. It made me feel like I was reading a timeless, classic tale of dragons and knights. Just that this one had Batman in it!
-Bat man's distrust. We all know that modern-day Batman does not exactly wear his heart on his sleeve but, more often than not, his distrust and feelings towards other people are left obscure. In the case of Bat man from Gallund, his distrust and feelings for those around him were made more clear for the readers. Bat man's conscience and morals are still as hard and rigorous as Batman's, but it's still more transparent. Personally, I see this as a chance to get a little more insight at the way Bruce's mind works and the way he sees and thinks of his allies and friends. I'm aware that Bat man is not Batman, but they both still have the same basic mentality.
-Bat man's failure. Apparently, Bat man deals with his failure in very much the same way as Bruce Wayne does. They both blame themselves excessively and hurt themselves further by mulling over it again and again. The difference I see is that Bruce Wayne is more obsessive than Bat man is. Where Bat man merely hides in his caves, Bruce would probably not stop looking for a solution until he finds one (whilst also hiding in his cave). It's not really the sight of Bat man torturing himself that drew me to this, but maybe it's the sight of Bat man needing the help of another to regain his self confidence. Without Jon, Bat man would probably never have left his cave again, fearing that he would fail once more. It's nice to see this for a change.
The minus points:
-Asgard International. I'm sorry to say, but the entire concept of Asgard international is unclear and frankly very one-dimensional. They're some kind of company that forces the people of Gallund out of their village to... built a nuclear waste disposal area. Firstly, I still have no idea why Asgard International would ever go through all the trouble of scaring a few villagers just to make them move out. Can't they find another place? What's so special about Gallund? Secondly, the name. I get it that Scott Hampton is trying to make everything related to Norse mythology, but Asgard International is supposed to be a company in the real world. The company didn't even have anything to do with the story Batman and Jon were reading! So why? It would have made much more sense if he named it Frost International or even Hroth International. But even then, it would still be very uninspired and cheesy. Thirdly (and most importantly), their motives are unclear! I don't know what they want out of the entire ordeal, I don't know what they'll gain if they manage to get Gallund and I don't even know what kind of company they really are. Again, I'm sorry, but Asgard International was nothing but the 'necessary villain' in this entire story. Literature has grown out of the age to create stereotypes ages and ages ago. There could have at least been some kind of back-story.
-Batman on killing people. Okay, here is where it gets very frustrating. Multiple times in this story, I had seen Batman actively killing an entire group of people or passively watching as people get killed. We all know that's the one rule Batman will never ever ever break! And yet, he does it here. With no second thought. As we discussed before, Batman feels guilty for many things, but apparently breaking his #1 rule stirs no remorse in him whatsoever. I can forgive the times Bat man lets Jon kill people in the story book, because well, it's a story out of a storybook. But when he blows up the cave and actively drowns an entire group of people, I just couldn't tolerate that. Batman's compassion for life and obsession about justice is what defines him, and from there, his vow to never take another human life. And yet, he does it in this story. *sigh* I hope you share my frustration on this. This is one of the worst transgressions against Batman I had ever come across. (not counting the Batman & Robin movie by Joel Schumacher, but that's another story.)
-The weird people who run Asgard International. Again, like the entire concept of Asgard International, they're just as one-dimensional, mindless and uninspired. But they're even worse on one thing: they have goblin green eyes! I'm not sure what they're supposed to be. Are they some kind of mystical being? Well, they have to be humans, right? Or else, how could they run a company without raising questions from everywhere. But then, why do they look almost deformed and have weird glowing green eyes? Plot holes, plot holes everywhere.
-Jon. This may be one of the milder minus points against Destiny that I have. Unlike the other three, I simply thought Jon was a little bland. His characterization isn't well-defined and a little unclear at times. Again, I thought Jon as a character was a little too one-dimensional for my liking, although he definitely still has more character than the weird people from Asgard International. This is especially distracting since Batman and Jon's destinies are supposed to cross paths.
-Batman's destiny. I know that this is the story's main idea: that Batman and Jon meet to take down a common enemy. But, I just can't seem to accept that. I don't like to think of Bruce Wayne, an angry and lonely orphan all those years ago, becoming Batman by destiny. I prefer to think about it as a choice, or rather, sacrifice he made to defend what he believes to be right. If Batman and Jon were destined to meet each other, then naturally, it had also been destiny that Bruce became Batman. And now that I think about it, the fact that there's a book about a Bat man and a viking prince going on an adventure together makes everything just a little weirder. So, Batman's family was actually Norse? Doesn't anybody else read that book and think something was a little off?
Anyway, all in all, I thoroughly enjoyed some parts of it but the book in its entirety was quite a disappointment. :(
The Sleeping (4.3/5)
After I finished reading Destiny, I pinned my last hopes on The Sleeping. And I definitely was not dissapointed! This was one of the best Batman stories I have read so far; even rivaling Batman: Year One and Batman: Venom (which are my favorites when it comes to Bruce's psychological demons.) Now to get on with the review.
The plus points:
- The atmosphere. Some things don't change. And, fortunately, Scott Hampton's remarkable skill at creating a beautifully dreamy setting for Batman succeeded to take my breath away once more. The 'place of dreams' Bruce had ended up in was as surreal and otherworldly as it was alluring. I'm sure that everyone had at least once imagined what it would be like to explore the world where dreams come from. Well, Scott Hampton's version of this world just made me feel like I got pulled into the very fabric of our consciousness and fears. Exploring this world with the ever-so-stoic Batman just made it all the more exciting.
- The River of Forgetfulness. It's not clear what this river does to each different individual but in Batman's case, it shows him the happy and fulfilling life that could have been. This reflects (as I have mentioned before) the harsh choice Bruce had made for himself. By becoming Batman, he had chosen to pursue a dark and lonely path in a selfless war against injustice. This could very well be devotion at its coldest and most selfless. But if only he could have found it in himself to forget the tragedy that took his parents away, he could have lived a happy life alongside a loving wife and three healthy, happy children. But Batman had made the choices he wanted to make. And, the best thing about this is: he does not seem to regret any of it.
-Mary. Not the ordinary damsel in distress and also not the morally ambiguous femme fatales Batman meets in Gotham all too often. Mary is a completely different character to what readers are used to see in Batman comics. She's just a girl who made a couple of wrong decisions. Like Batman, she refuses to take another human life. And like him, she fights for what she believes to be right. But what makes her stand out is how strong she is. Even after what happened, she stubbornly clings to her own fight for freedom. Somehow, Mary managed to bring some much needed humanity into the unsettling and whimsical world of dreams.
-The lake of fire. The fact that it erases all memories means that Batman can basically do and reveal anything he wants in this world without jeopardizing his personal life. Although hesitant at first (apparently, Bruce had forgotten how to trust anyone anymore at this point), it slowly began to dawn on Bruce that everything that happened in that place would not matter anyway. This is an opportunity to see what Bruce would do and say when he doesn't have to worry about secrecy and safety all the time. We all know that Bruce wears more than just the Bat cowl, he also has to act the persona of rich-boy Bruce Wayne too. Could the Bruce in the dream-world, be the real Bruce?
-The car crash. If something would ever happen to Bruce, it would most likely be a result of his nightly activities as Batman. And yet, when he ended up lying in coma with severe head injuries it was while he was being Bruce Wayne, the billionaire playboy. It's almost ironic. I guess this shows us that while Batman appears to be as untouchable and intimidating as he is, he's still and always will be just a man.
-Alfred. I know that we didn't really get to see him much in this entire story, but in the few panels we saw him at the ending (together with the moment that showed him playing with Bruce's children in Bruce's vision) almost made me cry. After what Bruce had gone through (although he does not remember any of it) and no matter what choices he had made and would make, we know that Alfred would always be there. His love for Bruce is unconditional in that way. In Batman's dark life of violence and hatred, at least we know that there is someone out there who cares and had cared for him since before everything had even begun. His significance in Bruce's life is shown remarkably well in this story. Alfred is just one of those characters that never fails to move me in ways I can't begin to explain.
-Henry. Gosh, I think all the characters in this story all deserve a point of their own. Henry, who's basically a coward and a pessimist, had given the entire story just that little push to make it complete. Throughout the story, it was hinted that he had been wandering in this land for years. Despite knowing where the lake lies, he never seemed to find the courage to jump into it. But at the end, when the people he trusted were in danger and when his silver cord started breaking, he found the courage he needed. Perhaps, he didn't have anything to lose anymore, but he still found it in himself to do what had to be done. And, eventually, he found the courage to jump into the lake of fire and back to the waking-world where his wife waits for him. I always love to see some character development in a story, and Henry is one of the best examples I have come across.
The minus points:
-The soul-eater. I thought it was a little cliche to have Batman fight a monster before he could reach the final goal. But what I was bothered by more was the soul-eater's existence. I'm not sure what it actually is or symbolizes. Okay I get it, it's a soul eater. But why does it only select a few souls to eat? Maybe it only eats those who are worthy? But what are the specific things the soul-eater looks for in a soul? I think it would have been much more engaging to know what the soul-eater actually wants.
Well, that was definitely a long long long review! But, what can I say, this is basically a review for two books. Anyway, I decided that this book deserved 4 stars instead of its actual 3.15 average.
To all of you who read the entire review, thanks a lot and sorry for its length! :)