I wanted to love this book. I really liked it, or at least I would have loved one of the five books this could have been. There was so much stuffed in here that the narrative felt unfocused. Instead of mining ten different tropes and tossing them into a blender, maybe just choosing one or two and sticking with those would make a better story. Crooked govt officials, a revolutionary pirate, a lost island, TWO different treasures, shipwrecked Japanese sailors who still think the war is still going on, an art mystery, a historical mystery, a typhoon, and lots of maritime stuff. That’s just too much. oh did I mention a weird link between the South China Sea and Homer’s Odyssey that isn’t explored? And somehow even with all that, it still managed to feel a bit dull. There was a severe lack of excitement here that had no reason to exist. The two principal redeeming qualities are that the characters are likeable, even the villain, and the prose style is like that of a kindly grandfather who gets really excited about tiny details and has a tendency to ramble about what he finds interesting. If not for the coziness of the prose, it would have felt like “hey look at all this research I did!!” But the writing manages to maintain a certain charm. Finn Ryan, I really like as a protagonist, she is brave, smart, and resourceful, though the author does play her a bit passive, things seem to happen to her rather than she makes things happen. It’s an okay book. Not enough fighting, chases and explosions to keep a wild pace, but enough interesting info to keep you seeing what’s around the next bend. Meh. As an adventure thriller enthusiast, it’s good to check off the list and see how someone plays in the sandbox, but not a must read.