The city is Turai, where sorcerers and assassins-sometimes, it's hard to tell them apart-ply their wares, the rulers are corrupt, the politicians are worse, and the civic guards might try to solve a crime, except that they've really got better things to do. Overweight and somewhat uncouth, Thraxas may not look like a man of action, (and he'd rather pass on the action, thank you, and order another beer), but if you're in trouble in Turai this portly private eye is probably your only hope. Not that Thraxas himself has much hope in the first of the two complete novels in this volume-A judge has fined him almost every guran he has, two old enemies have threatened his life, and his old commander in the army, after promising a solution to Thraxas' problems, has just turned up dead. Naturally, Thraxas is the prime suspect . . . . In his second case, Thraxas has received a message from an old friend in trouble in the Elvish Isles, and since the elves have no experience in investigating, Thraxas is hired to do the legwork. Naturally, as soon as he arrives in the Isles, things start getting weird. But when the going gets weird, Thraxas gets going. . . .
Meh. I like the idea of the book. A detective in a fantasy city is just the type of cross-genre I love. But the execution was not that good. There weren't any major issues, just nothing grabbed me. I was a bit annoyed at the characters using the same similes every chapter. I guess that's how normal people talk, but it's jarring in a book.
Humorous and entertaining. I very much enjoyed all the characters - each has a distinct personality that play off each other well. The little plot twists were fun, as was laughing at the repeat misfortunes of Thraxas and his friends while trying to solve all the mysteries.
A double whammy of a light read, with two books in one. These books are surprisingly sustainable though back to back readings of sequence novels, though they are all pretty similar, with lots of repetition. Lots of laugh out loud moments and absolutely no brainpower required.
Fun. I'd read the first Thraxas novel in German, but the translation was pitiful. I'm glad I gave him another chance in English. This is no must-read literature by any means, but it's quite entertaining. I liked the second story in the book much more than the first one.