In the spring of 1864, as the armies of Grant and Lee waged a highly scrutinized and celebrated battle for the state of Virginia, a no- less important, but historically obscured engagement was being conducted in the pine barrens of northern Louisiana. In a year of stellar triumphs by Union armies across the South, the Red River Campaign stands out as a colossal failure. General William Tecumseh Sherman's scathing summation describes it best, 'One damn blunder from beginning to end.' Taking its title from Sherman's blunt description, One Damn Blunder from Beginning to The Red River Campaign of 1864 is a fresh inspection of what was the Civil War's largest operation between the Union Army and Navy west of the Mississippi River. In a bold, but poorly managed effort to wrest Louisiana and Texas from Confederate control, a combined force of 40,000 Union troops and 60 naval vessels traveled up the twisting Red River in an attempt to capture the capital city of Shreveport. Gary D. Joiner provides not a recycled telling of the campaign, but a strategic and tactical overview based on a stunning new array of facts gleaned from recently discovered documents. This never-before-published information reveals that the Confederate army had laid a clever trap by engineering a drop in the water level of the Red River to try to maroon the Union naval flotilla. Only the equally amazing ingenuity of the Union troops saved the fleet from certain destruction, despite a humiliating defeat at the Battle of Mansfield. The Red River campaign had lasting implications. One Damn Blunder from Beginning to End magnifies just how devastating the diversion of so many men and so much material to this failed campaign was to the Union effort in the pivotal year of 1864. Because of the Union Army's failures, Northern plans to capture Mobile were scrapped. Military careers were made and lost. And at time when the Confederacy was teetering on the brink of oblivion, Southern morale was bolstered. Joiner puts together a compelling description of what was one of the most important military operations conducted west of the Mississippi. The fierce military action, the squabbling of the leaders on both sides, and most importantly, essential new knowledge of the Confederate defensive preparations are all contained in the pages of this new book. Civil War buffs and military enthusiasts will revel in this in-depth look at this critical, but previously overlooked campaign.
This is the best account yet of Bank's disastrous campaign up the Red River in 1864. I came away from it with a renewed appreciation of Richard Taylor and even greater contempt for the politician in uniform, Nathaniel Banks. It is shameful that President Lincoln allowed good men to die under such incompetent leadership.
One Damn Blunder is an overview of an infamous Union Army-Navy campaign in Louisiana in early 1864. Though the Mansfield battlefield is a state historic site and Pleasant Hill hosts an annual battle reenactment, like most of the Trans-Mississippi Theater this campaign seems to get relatively little attention or public interest.
The operation was rather large, with a Union Army of over 30,000 men supported by a sizeable river fleet. It was a mess for the Union and arguably a missed opportunity for the Confederates. Joiner makes no effort to put lipstick on this pig; if anything he seems to view it all as negatively as anyone.
Those looking for detailed tactical analysis or regimental-level battle narratives should look elsewhere. This book has only about 150 pages of main text and no space for that level of detail. The book looks more at the strategy and operational decision-making. Engagements are not omitted, but often only covered in brief. Steele's offensive from Little Rock toward Shreveport (Camden Expedition), conducted in conjunction with Banks and Porter on the Red River gets a chapter.
While I had a general understanding of the Red River Campaign before reading this book, one of the things I got out of it was the complicated geography of the Red River Valley: a mess of swamps, bayous, parallel channels, oxbow lakes, and cutoffs interspersed with a prairie (Avoyelles) and good agricultural land - all bordered to the south by thick pine barrens. A variety of difficult soils and a limited number of bad roads. Geography is important to understanding most campaigns, but the Red River especially and it's one that's probably strange to most people not from Louisiana (myself included).
There are photos and maps throughout, and Endnotes at the end of each chapter. Some of the photos were pretty good, some a bit small and/or dark. Some of the maps were decent, but the ones depicting engagements were awful - devoid of topography and with tiny print.
Although the author is university professor, the writing is not dry and the book proved a steady read. However, I would only call it "okay." It's trying to cover a lot in not enough space and the negativity about practically every major figure, except Richard Taylor and Joseph Bailey, brings it down.
If you're interested in the Civil War and looking for a "Don't Know Much About The Red River Campaign" book, from what I can tell this is probably still the best available and okay in that role.
One Damn Blunder is a very decent survey-level history of the Red River campaign. Joiner summarizes the key points deftly and rapidly, offers a few select descriptions of the natural environment, and provides direct and simple analysis that does not detract from the narrative. This is not a thorough history, detailing the engineering or military elements of the expedition, nor does it offer extended atmosphere or many personally compelling or heart-wrenching details. However, I would certainly recommend it for someone looking to learn a fair amount about Red River without fully immersing themselves in a dense history.
A well done account of the campaign that doesn't get bogged down in details. The maps could be better, and I found the battle descriptions a bit too succinct for my tastes.
Recommend for anyone interested in an approachable account of this oft overlooked campaign.
A great book on a topic that doesn't receive enough credit in the Civil War circles, the Red River Campaign.
I know from personal research as well as actually visiting many of the places described in the book that it is both accurate and entertaining insofar as a scholarly work can be.
At least one of my ancestors was in the battles and locations described in this book and the Red River Campaign took place in and around my "neck of the woods", Natchitoches, Louisiana and the areas north and south of it.
It's hard to imagine what the men in this war went through but Mr. Joiner does a great job of bringing history to life.