3.5 stars
This wasn't a bad book but man it was severely dated, you know when silent taciturn heroes and constantly sobbing heroines were in vogue. This book was drama for the sake of drama. H/h have been married for twenty years and have five kids. The hero is the silent type who keeps his emotions in check and heroine is the perfect home-maker. Then their high school reunion gets all their buried emotions out. You see in their senior year the heroine got infatuated with a new boy in town and had a stupid one-night stand with him which she regretted. When she feared that one-time had consequences she ran to her friend and the hero sister. The hero stepped in as her knight in shining armour, taking the blame, standing up to her parents, giving up his dreams of university and married her. Except for her confession on what happened that night they never discussed Kevin and swept everything under the rug. They have been happy the past twenty years even if the heroine notices that the hero tends to keep his emotions in check. But you see getting confirmation that Kevin is coming to town brings everything that was hidden to the surface.
First off all the heroine was a crying ninny. Her daughter was almost twenty so it wasn't like if the truth of her paternity was revealed it would lead to some custody battle. Second off all, all the bloody interruption between the h/H when they were having a honest conversation was annoying. The hero had loved the heroine since he met her at 14 and was hurt when the heroine got infatuated with Kevin; but in her defense she was a stupid teen. If they had talked about the past they would have realised how irrelevant Kevin was in their life, because with or without him these two would have ended up together. The heroine was a bit stupid and wrong to have never given Kevin the chance to be a father because he was just a stupid teenager and not some Lothario. Of course when he comes to town, they learn his wife is infertile and how much he wants kids. So, yup he learns about the paternity but as the hero points out to him, his selfish need to be a father will hurt his wife and destroy a secure girl's life. After I don't know how many litres of tears from the heroine the book ends. Not Judith Duncan's best work.